Support NeoGAF

[Crimsonlink]

I'd say the fact that no one is bothering to vote anymore proves otherwise.

Well maybe their favorite shows are dead so they don't feel the need to vote anymore?

Besides just because people stopped voting doesn't mean everyone stopped. We still get roughly 16-20 votes per round.

If you want to spice things up then make a grandfather clause or something. After we get to top 50 shows all votes for killing and saving stays with that show for the rest of the rounds until it dies.

YYH is saved for 5 rounds by 3 people after Top 50, it has -15 for kill votes to overcome before it can think about going down dead.

 

[ЯAW]

I'd say the fact that no one is bothering to vote anymore proves otherwise.

I think it's more about there being too many shows to vote. It's no fun to kill cannon fodder. For time to time it felt even the 90s thread had too many shows to vote for. 20 to 30 shows would be ideal imo. But it's good to have these threads so we can hear out people and polish the upcoming threads.

 

[789shadow]

I think it's more about there being too many shows to vote. It's no fun to kill cannon fodder.

I know there's a lot of shows, but having 3 or 4 shows killed in a round allows shows to be killed spectacularly easily. We would have had a bloodbath of popular shows leave with net scores of -1.

 

[Levyne]

Anyways...

Kill: He-man
Kill: He-man ; Never watched, have no memories or feelings for this show.
Save: Yugioh. ; A show I feel on the brink that younger me actually enjoyed a fair bit.

 

[MikeHattsu]

Wow. Holy crap.

I'm only voting in the rounds where shows I know about is either up for the kill or needs saving.

 

[AniHawk]

I know there's a lot of shows, but having 3 or 4 shows killed in a round allows shows to be killed spectacularly easily. We would have had a bloodbath of popular shows leave with net scores of -1.

and there'd be a lot more people paying attention and actually talking about what needs to go and what needs to stay.

 

[RumblingRosco]

Anyone that thinks DBZ is worth saving (at least for now) should vote a Save for it every round no matter what. People sniped Dragonball at the last minute the last round despite it being an actually great show, probably much better than DBZ by most considerations. There is some pseudo-alliancey-thing that is going to do the same thing to DBZ this round.

So, if you want DBZ to go on but think it's safe because no one is voting it off right now, you're going to be sad tomorrow. Throw in a DBZ save now to be safe (again, only if you actually like the show; not trying to persuade people that dislike DBZ to save it).

Kill: He-Man
Kill: He-Man
Save: DBZ

Never watched He-Man. For DBZ reasons, see above.

 

[daveo42]

Looks like the thread went pants-on-head crazy. Killing off DragonBall? Really? Ya'll need Goku-Jesus.

Kill: Transformers Cybertron
Kill: Transformers Cybertron (time to double-tap this)
Save: Samurai Jack

Transformers Cybertron should have went down last round instead of DB. It's not Beast Wars and was dumb.

Screw all the haters hating on Jack. Good shows shouldn't get kicked out so easily.

RIP in peace DragonBall.

 

[Moaradin]

Dragon Ball got sniped? What a load of crap. At least get rid of all the mediocre shows first.

Kill: Transformers: Cybertron
Kill: He-Man

transformers: cybertron was meh and I never really cared for He-Man.

Save: Yu Yu Hakusho

 

[Unspeakable Evil]

Kill: Transformers Cybertron
Kill: Transformers Cybertron
Save: Samurai Jack
Cybertron was really meh and had really annoying human characters.
Gotta protect the Jack

 

[ShinRPGamer]

Kill: Superfriends (even as a joke not letting this get any favours)
Kill: He-Man 2002 (meh)
Save: Gundam SEED tiebreakers

 

[ShinRPGamer]

Wrong thread my bad.

 

[789shadow]

About 2 hours left guys.

 

[TheAbsolution]

Kill: He Man
Kill: He-Man it was just OK.
Save: Dragonball Z. Why'd you kill Dragonball guys?

 

[ShinRPGamer]

Kill: Transformers: Armada
Kill: Transformers: Armada it was just OK.
Save: Dragonball Z. Why'd you kill Dragonball guys?

A few days late man, Armada already got killed.

 

[Crocodile]

Kill: Transformers Cybertron
Kill: Transformers Cybertron - most Transformers series haven't really impressed me or left much of any sort of impression

Save: DBZ - same reasons as always

 

[Man God]

Kill DBZ: Kai is better
Kill DBZ: Kai Majin Buu saga later this year
Save: Transformers Cybertron.

 

[789shadow]

Round 16 is now over!

Live Results Spreadsheet

 

[Skid 4 Dead]

Shit!... just missed the voting, nuts.

 

[ShinRPGamer]

InB4DBZisoutshitstorm

 

[MikeMyers]

Kill DBZ: Kai is better
Kill DBZ: Kai Majin Buu saga later this year
Save: Transformers Cybertron.

DAMN TRANSFORMERS FANBOYS YOU FUCKED DBZ OVER.

 

[ThatObviousUser]

Hahahaha, shitstorm incoming.

 

[789shadow]

Round 16 Results!

The two shows eliminated are:

Transformers: Cybertron in 56th place, with 12 kills and 1 save (Net = 11)

And they finally got it.

Dragon Ball Z in 55th place, with 12 kills and 5 saves (Net = 7)

The Top 5:

He-Man and the Masters of the Universe (2002), with 8 kills and 3 saves (Net = 5)
Mobile Suit Gundam: The 08th MS Team, with 1 kill and 0 saves (Net = 1)
Gundam Wing, with 1 kill and 0 saves (Net = 1)

The Bottom 2:

Yu Yu Hakusho, with 1 kill and 3 saves (Net = -2)
Samurai Jack, with 0 kills and 2 saves (Net = -2)

Full Results Spreadsheet

Round 17 voting is now open!

 

[ThatObviousUser]

 

[Levyne]

Gucci would be proud.

 

[MikeMyers]

DBZ DIED O_O

 

[kingkitty]

Rest now Hamtaro...

You have been avenged.

 

[789shadow]

You know what, this just isn't quite working. A few determined users can kill literally any show just by changing/making votes right before voting closes. This is especially true when there are so few people voting every round.

 

[ThatObviousUser]

Kill: Superfriends
Kill: Superfriends

It ain't no Justice League, that's for damn sure. Superfriends single handedly ruined Aquaman's reputation, while in JLU he's a hook-handed badass. Go away, Superfriends.

Save: InuYasha

 

[Crayolan]

And they finally got it.

Dragon Ball Z in 55th place, with 12 kills and 5 saves (Net = 7)

Holy shit. I just missed voting, happy to see it was a 2 vote difference instead of a 1 so I don't have to feel guilty.

 

[kingkitty]

Kill: Cowboy Bebop
Kill: Cowboy Bebop
Save: He-Man

Cowboy Bebop? More like Cowboy Bibimbap!

 

[vikki]

Should be interesting now that there is 0 to be avenged. Back to killing shows no one cares about...

 

[Outlaw]

Kill:He-Man
Kill:He-Man
save:Cowboy Bebop

Reasons: Cowboy bebop is the best of all time

 

[Levyne]

Kill: He-man
Kill: He-man. Never watched, was never interested in watching. Another show that needs to go, IMO

Save: Yugioh - Enjoyed the first half season that I saw.

 

[Skid 4 Dead]

Kill : Sailor Moon
Kill : Sailor Moon
Save : Samurai Jack

I really don't care anymore. Credibility is decreasing by the round.

 

[Crayolan]

Kill: Justice League Unlimited-Superhero shows not named Batman or Teen Titans must die
Kill: Super Friends-See above
Save: Megas XLR-Because I dig giant robots

 

[TheAbsolution]

Kill: SuperFriends
Kill: SuperFriends
Save: Megas XLR WTF guys seriously? If this goes right now, ugh.

 

[BinaryPork2737]

Kill: Gundam SEED- Out of all the Gundam shows left (that I've seen, anyway), I like this the least. Plus there's way too many Gundam shows left. Seriously.
Kill: Gundam SEED
Save: Cowboy Bebop- No fuck off. I'm not letting this thread become a complete irredeemable mess without trying to stop it.

 

[ShinRPGamer]

Kill: He-man (still meh)
Kill: He-man (So that I can...)
Save: Gundam SEED (not just for tiebreakers)

 

[Strike]

Round 16 Results!
Dragon Ball Z in 55th place, with 12 kills and 5 saves (Net = 7)

Round 17 voting is now open!

 

[789shadow]

Alright, here's how it's going down:

Kill: He-Man and the Masters of the Universe (2002)
Kill: Super Friends - Oh shit, it's Aquaman
Save: Cowboy Bebop - I cannot believe this is actually in danger.

 

[Crayolan]

Alright, here's how it's going down:

Kill: He-Man and the Masters of the Universe (2002)
Kill: Gundam SEED - will take what's his name's suggestion
Save: Justice League (Unlimited) - a Top 20 show

I see how it is. Maybe I should focus on killing off all the Gundams before the superhero shows.

 

[ReiGun]

Damn, y'all killed DB and DBZ? Ruthless up in here.

 

[iShouldGoPro]

I just want to go on record by saying

If Cowboy Bebop doesn't make the Top 5 I will lose all hope in AnimationGAF.

Just saiyan

Kill Sailor Moon
Kill Sailor Moon
Save Cowboy Bebop, because it is one of the most innovative anime of all time

 

[lazybones18]

And they finally got it.

Dragon Ball Z in 55th place, with 12 kills and 5 saves (Net = 7)

Real goddamn shame I didn't vote to kill it off. Hit the road Jack and don't you come back...

 

[BinaryPork2737]

I just want to go on record by saying

If Cowboy Bebop doesn't make the Top 5 I will lose all hope in AnimationGAF.

This can only end well.

 

[lazybones18]

I just want to go on record by saying

If Cowboy Bebop doesn't make the Top 5 I will lose all hope in AnimationGAF.

It ran on for far too damn long (and was only part of Toonami for like a year) /GMN

It's death will come very soon

 

[iShouldGoPro]

It ran on for far too damn long (and was only part of Toonami for like a year) /GMN

It's death will come very soon

Lol ok

You'd think that would warrant a reason for it's survival?
When I think of Toonami I think of Cowboy Bebop. They are one in the same.
Nuff said.

 

[lazybones18]

I was making a joke

Spoiler

I'll help kill it off very soon though lol

 

[MikeHattsu]

Rest now Hamtaro...

You have been avenged.

Kill: Cowboy Bebop
Kill: Cowboy Bebop
Save: Sailor Moon

Because the voices told me to and I liked Sailor Moon.