Support NeoGAF

[789shadow]

One of? You mean the worst.

I dunno man. Of all things on God's Earth, Wulin Warriors could be that thing.

 

[lazybones18]

One of? You mean the worst.

Hmm...might have to gun for the Batman shows next >

 

[789shadow]

Hmm...might have to gun for the Batman shows next >

I wouldn't put up much of a fight if you decided to target The Batman. Beyond or, god forbid, the Animated Series. Heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeell no.

 

[ThatObviousUser]

Kill: Star Wars: The Clone Wars
Kill: Zoids: New Century Zero
Save: Zoids: Chaotic Century

Zero is crap compared to Chaotic Century.

There's not much of a plot or stakes and feels like a generic arena-ish show. This is why I always hated that stupid Zoids show that Toonami would always air instead of the far-superior Chaotic Century. The latter was a stupid boring arena show, the latter actually had a super interesting plot, mythos, and characters.

Unfortunately they stuck Chaotic Century at the ass crack of dawn (like 6am I believe) but that didn't stop me from watching it.

Chaotic Century is way better than IGPX.

You probably mean Zero Century, which was garbage.

Chaotic Century/Guardian Force is honestly one of the most underrated anime ever. Such a shame.

The other ones suck though. Especially New Century Zero.

 

[Veelk]

Kill: One Piece
Kill: One Piece
Save: Megas XLR

MXLR really went before it's time.

That show was some of the best humor around.

 

[bigosc2k]

Kill: hamtaro fuck that show, too cute for my taste
Kill: hamtaro ditto as above

Save: one piece the fuck is wrong with you people for trying to vote this off

 

[B-Dubs]

Hmm...might have to gun for the Batman shows next >

Now, you have gone too far!

 

[789shadow]

One hour until voting closes! Get in any last minute votes or edits now, and proofread your posts to make sure they follow the rules.

 

[Skid 4 Dead]

Hamtaro is the new ReBoot.

As long as Reboot isn't the Reboot of the thread, I will be satisfied. I await it's elimination cordially.

 

[Crocodile]

Kill: Bakugan - boring show that has no appeal to anyone over the age of 10. bleh.
Kill: Rave Master - I've only seen the dub which I know had a ton of liberties taken with it but this still looks like generic shonen 101 to me :/

Save: One Piece because c'mon the show is much better than many shows still on the list. Why are people targeting this show again?

 

[lazybones18]

Kill: Bakugan - boring show that has no appeal to anyone over the age of 10. bleh.
Kill: Rave Master - I've only seen the dub which I know had a ton of liberties taken with it but this still looks like generic shonen 101 to me :/

Save: One Piece because c'mon the show is much better than many shows still on the list. Why are people targeting this show again?

Cause the beater hating nakama need to suffer

 

[vikki]

if you pm me i will ignore you and do my own thing. fair warning.

If anyone PMs me, I may answer.

Spoiler

I have no idea if I'll follow the advice though.

 

[Poltergust]

I propose that we get rid of most of the animated shows first such as Ben 10 and Transformers.

I didn't see Ben 10. Worse than OP and Naruto, so changing my kill votes to that.

Alliances are game-ruiners for the rest of the game's players.

Look I don't like PM campaigns either.
Be public about the stuff that you want changed.
But seriously though there are shows on this list that are absolute garbage and shouldn't be here.
And spoiler alert,

Spoiler

They aren't One Piece.

For all that is good, Can we kill something else off please?
Lie Ben 10: Alien Force.
Why is this still here?
It wasn't as good as the original for sure.

*sigh*

You guys are too late. I initially voted for Ben 10 literally minutes after the second round started, but no one else did until now. It's gonna be moving on, unfortunately. You are better off voting for something that may actually be on the chopping block.

We'll get Ben 10 next round. ^_^

 

[TheAbsolution]

*sigh*

You guys are too late. I initially voted for Ben 10 literally minutes after the second round started, but no one else did until now. It's gonna be moving on, unfortunately. You are better off voting for something that may actually be on the chopping block.

We'll get Ben 10 next round. ^_^

Hmm. What shall I switch my vote to then? Hmm. I'll try Bleach.

 

[Skid 4 Dead]

I don't condone it, but backdoor politics really makes these threads interesting. Everything going according to plan is rather dull. Although, otherwise, it is heartbreaking.

 

[Doctor Decimate]

Kill: Hamtaro
Kill: Hamtaro
Save: One Piece

Hamtaro didn't belong on an action block. Even the 4kids dub of One Piece should beat so many shows on this list

 

[Sylverstone14]

#teamhamtaro

Man, if they brought this back...

 

[789shadow]

Round 2 Voting is now closed!

Just a reminder that two shows will be eliminated every round from now until the Top 10

Live results spreadsheet.

 

[Poltergust]

Kill: Hamtaro
Kill: Hamtaro
Save: One Piece

Hamtaro didn't belong on an action block. Even the 4kids dub of One Piece should beat so many shows on this list

Nononononoooooo.

Just... watch this while you wait for the results to come up (not spoilerish):

4Kids Scene

Funimation Scene

4Kids One Piece skipped entire arcs. Arcs that would be very important later on in the show. It's indefensible.

 

[Crimsonlink]

*sigh*

You guys are too late. I initially voted for Ben 10 literally minutes after the second round started, but no one else did until now. It's gonna be moving on, unfortunately. You are better off voting for something that may actually be on the chopping block.

We'll get Ben 10 next round. ^_^

Sadly I realized the voting system too late. Ben 10 will go down for sure! Out of the Transformers I think Armada was the worst one personally.

 

[Doctor Decimate]

Nononononoooooo.

Just... watch this while you wait for the results to come up (not spoilerish):

4Kids Scene

Funimation Scene

4Kids One Piece skipped entire arcs. Arcs that would be very important later on in the show. It's indefensible.

Hey I hate that dub as much as the next guy, but Bakugan? DICE? That Fantastic Four show?

 

[belushy]

#teamhamtaro

 

[lazybones18]

One Piece with more kill votes than SAO. So nice

 

[Vesmir]

Nononononoooooo.

Just... watch this while you wait for the results to come up (not spoilerish):

4Kids Scene

Funimation Scene

4Kids One Piece skipped entire arcs. Arcs that would be very important later on in the show. It's indefensible.

Ok see I didn't know that was a travesty done by 4Kids (but its fucking 4kids so why would I be surprised). That whale thing was legit entertaining. I would have to watch more of the Funi dub before I vote against OP again.

Also my vote was thrown out for a bs reason. Whatever, I guess.

 

[Levyne]

Yall a bunch of animals.

 

[Poltergust]

Ok see I didn't know that was a travesty done by 4Kids (but its fucking 4kids so why would I be surprised). That whale thing was legit entertaining. I would have to watch more of the Funi dub before I vote against OP again.

Also my vote was thrown out for a bs reason. Whatever, I guess.

Unfortunately, One Piece is out of luck, it seems. You won't be voting for it again.

 

[Imperial Bishop]

[BETRAYAL INTENSIFIES]

 

[Skid 4 Dead]

This is already way more level headed than the 90s thread. So glad to see.

 

[789shadow]

Round 2 Results!

The two shows eliminated are:

Dragon Ball GT, in 84th place, with 17 kills and 2 saves (Net = 15; tied with One Piece, eliminated first based on least amount of saves between the two.)

One Piece, in 83rd place, with 39 kills and 24 saves (Net = 15; tied with Dragon Ball GT, eliminated second based on least amount of saves between the two.)

The Top 5:
Bleach, with 15 kills and 6 saves (Net = 9)
Bakugan Battle Brawlers, with 7 kills and 0 saves (Net = 7)
Star Wars: The Clone Wars, with 4 kills and 0 saves (Net = 4; tied with Zatch Bell!, placed ahead due to higher all-time net score.)

The Bottom 2:
Hamtaro, with 12 kills and 18 saves (Net = -6)
A whole bunch of shows, with 0 kills and 1 save each (Net = -1 for all)

Round 2 Full Results

Before I start Round 3, some announcements and rule updates:

1. Remember that from now until the Top 10, 2 shows will be eliminated each round.

2. Please be extra careful that you have an explanation in your post. I've been lenient on some borderline cases so far, but not anymore.

3. Your explanation must be in the post proper, and not in the reason for editing at the bottom of the post.

And with that, Round 3 voting is now open!

 

[Papercuts]

 

[remist]

Team Hamtaro moving along with 18 saves.

I suggest we get rid of some of the really bad stuff like Ben 10 and Bakugan Battle Brawlers next.

 

[Levyne]

Kill: Hamtaro
Kill: Hamtaro - Should have never been on Toonami, not an action show.
Save: Gundam Wing

RIP One Piece.

 

[Imperial Bishop]

One Piece, in 83rd place, with 39 kills and 24 saves (Net = 15; tied with Dragon Ball GT, eliminated second based on least amount of saves between the two.)

 

[Drago]

Kill: Bleach, same reasoning as before, just a show I hate to watch. If One Piece is gone this is going next
Kill: Bleach

Save: Hamtaro, can't hate. Loved watching it when I was young >_>

 

[lazybones18]

39 kills

SUCK IT, NAKAMA! That's what you get for fucking with Kirito Da Gawd!


Now on to more pressing matters (1 DB show down, 2 more to go)

Kill: Bakugan
Kill: Zatch Bell
Save: Hamtaro

Must save the Ham-Ham Alliance

 

[789shadow]

Welp, I guess that's that.

Kill: Hamtaro - Demon rodents from hell must die.
Kill: Bleach

Save: Dragon Ball Z - because are you fucking kidding me lazybones.

 

[Imperial Bishop]

SUCK IT, NAKAMA! That's what you get for fucking with Kirito Da Gawd!

You did this to yourself, LB. You chose incest over quality. Remember that.

RIP One Piece.

 

[Bio-Frost]

Kill:Hamtaro
Kill:Hamtaro
Saveragonball

As awesome as hamtaro was it did not belong on toonami.

 

[ThatObviousUser]

 

[Slamtastic]

Kill: Batman the Animated Series
Kill: Batman the Animated Series

Preemptively attacking overrated shows.

Save: Dragon Ball Z

Except this overrated show which I also overrate

 

[Doctor Decimate]

you know what? let's kill DBZ. let's just go full-on, balls-out stupid with this thing. what do we have to lose now?

 

[Crimsonlink]

Kill: Ben 10
Kill: Ben 10

Save: Bleach

Lets get rid of the worst of the bunch shall we? Ben 10 is not a very good show imo and the different season don't help.

 

[Man God]

KillBZ because of Ocean Dub.
KillBZ because of Falconer Music
Save: Hamtaro. Plenty of action here. More than Blue Sub no 6 that boring but beautiful show.

 

[ThatObviousUser]

2. Please be extra careful that you have an explanation in your post. I've been lenient on some borderline cases so far, but not anymore.

Is quoting my old posts OK? I've spoken at length in the various Toonami OT's about my love/dislike for most of these shows.

 

[Skid 4 Dead]

edited

 

[bobbychalkers]

Kill: D.I.C.E.
Kill: D.I.C.E.
Save: Dragonball Z - Too early for this shit!

 

[789shadow]

Is quoting my old posts OK? I've spoken at length in the various Toonami OT's about my love/dislike for most of these shows.

I'll allow it.

Also my vote was thrown out for a bs reason. Whatever, I guess.

You're right. I'll add your votes to the results. But it will be a rule going forward that your explanation must be in your original voting post.

 

[Imperial Bishop]

I don't care anymore. Time to watch the world burn.

Kill: Hamtaro
Kill: Hamtaro
Save: Yu Yu Hakusho

I don't dig giant robots, I don't like bats, but I do like brats with fancy watches.
After much meditation, I've decided to go with Hamtaro, because hamsters are vermin.

 

[belushy]

Kill - Zatch Bell - I think I watched like one episode of this, and I just really didn't like it.
Kill - Zatch Bell
Save - Dragon Ball Z - This shouldn't be voted out so early. Gonna have to back out on the Ham team for this round, sorry guys.

edit: FINALLY EDITED FOR THE LAST TIME BECAUSE I FORGOT THE DANG REASONING.

 

[Man God]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYOKfLCu02Y

Tom approves of them, why won't this thread?

#teamhamtaro.