• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

True Swing Golf (DS) - Gamespot review

Wario64

works for Gamestop (lol)
6.0

http://www.gamespot.com/ds/sports/touchgolf/review.html?sid=6142778


The Good: Healthy number of courses; good use of game-sharing.
The Bad: Bland presentation; meager feature set; touch-screen controls devoid of subtlety.


For a game from a publisher and a developer that have both done some interesting and accomplished things with the game of golf, True Swing comes out surprisingly flat. Last year's Tiger Woods PGA Tour for the DS was admittedly a flawed product, but there's still no one good reason to pick up True Swing Golf instead of, or even in addition to, Tiger.
 
I love the idea of stylus swing, but fuck does that game look boring. I had it pre-ordered, but cancelled it after reading so many "the mechanics are good, but it'll put you to sleep" impressions.


Please Nintendo - Mario Golf DS. Please.
 
noooooooooo!!!

i was really, really looking forward to this, but i guess i'll have to keep my psp around so i can play hotshots golf every other night...
 
Boo'urns. Been wanting a portable golf game, was assuming this was going to be good. Hot Shots Golf PSP it is (especially now that it's cheap).
 
Yeah, I played this at the Australian DS Tour thingy and even for a golf game it's pretty boring. The animation is hilarious though, when it took me like seven hundred shots to get the ball in the hole, my golfer looked like he'd just shit his pants.
 
Pimpbaa said:
Boo'urns. Been wanting a portable golf game, was assuming this was going to be good. Hot Shots Golf PSP it is (especially now that it's cheap).

you won't be disappointed. hotshots golf is one of the few games i play regularly on my psp. i love that game...and i'm not a golf fan at all.
 
IGN
http://ds.ign.com/articles/682/682539p1.html

The game's look may be an initial turnoff, but you'll easily be able to see the gameplay shine through. T&E Soft has pulled off a really fun and challenging golf game with some great course designs and a fantastic, intuitive touch screen swing mechanic. The lack of any sort of license is a bummer, but the game design definitely holds its own without them, and True Swing Golf's real claim to fame is that it offers up something unique for golf fans to appreciate.


7.0 Presentation
15 courses in a good variety of locations, and eight different, customizable characters. But don't expect realworld players or locations, or features beyond straightforward golf.
6.0 Graphics
Animations are decent and the golf terrain's modeled well, but the visuals are really muddy and low resolution.
8.0 Sound
There's not a whole lot of speech in this game, but the nice SNES-style background music and standard "golf clap" audio works to the game's subtleness.
8.5 Gameplay
Though it's missing some elements like mini-challenges and a basic driving range to practice swings, this is a really great playing golf game using the touch screen as control and swing mechanic.
9.0 Lasting Appeal
Single cartridge is well worth the play, especially with four players in the network doodling up phallic images to screw up the golfer at the tee.
8.0
Impressive OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)
 
Was there alot of interest for this game? I saw a Fry's ad with that "On shelves by..." tag or whatever which they usually only do for bigger releases.
 
Yeah I played the demo at the Aus wifi tour, I would rather have a cool version of Golf? though for DS.

screen_19658_4_Snap3.jpg
 
Oblivion said:
I'll take GS's word over IGN anyday.
You should just read the reviews and decide for your-self. Like for instance, I agree with IGN's Nintendogs review more then GameSpot's Nintendogs review but I also think GameSpot's Battles of Prince of Persia review is much better then IGN's BoPoP review.
 
Hmm, I've had this game for over a month and I like it a lot.

Sure there are a couple of imperfections here and there.
Like the stylus missing or mistaking certain input. Like trying to grab the cross-hair for choosing your area of where you want to get the ball to go and instead it game simply gives you a closeup of the area a couple of yards away.

Or when you are on the swing screen. Sometimes after adjusting the spot where you want to hit the ball and you try to grab the club, the game still thinks you're trying to change where to hit the ball.

But these are minor things which are overcome by simply letting go of the screen and touching it again.

it initially seems like the game is taking great care to determine the speed of your swing, but after a few games, you'll realize that regardless of how much you try to vary the speed of your shot, it will almost inevitably end up traveling at roughly 70, 90, or 110 miles per hour. There's also no way to choose any type of shot other than a full swing, which means that the shape of your shot is always determined by which club you're using.

The same basic concept of drawing a line to swing the club applies to the putting mechanic in True Swing, though it takes away the speed factor and adds a guideline on the upper screen that makes the entire short game achingly easy. All you have to do is line up the shot, check against the guideline on the upper screen, and repeat until the guideline is lying on top of the cup.
That's just plain wrong.
The first couple of holes are very easy, that's certainly. Simply because the the green's and basically the entire courses are pretty much flat when you start out.

In the later clubs there is much more variety and simply following the line will get you very, very little.


They also make it seem as there is not much there but the bare basics. But I found out the customization of the golf equipment which you have to buy using money you earn from tournaments, makes a big difference in the way you choose to play the game.

There are lots of courses and the way the game controls with the stylus does make a big difference in a positive way.

The graphics are nothing more then pretty nice, I'll give them that. And the music has grown on me since I started playing the game.

It's in no way the perfect golf game. But I personally agree much more with the solid 8 than with the meager 6 score.
 
It's a nice, addictive golf game. I agree with the presentation comments, it's incredibly bland and it lacks in content as far as modes an things to do go. Graphics are bad. Championships are set up pretty boringly.. But the gameplay itself is fun and relaxing. Buy when it's cheaper.
 
I'm a big fan of this game.

And I do not agree with the bland presentation criticism. Or rather, I do think it's bland, but I like it that way.

It takes guts for Nintendo to do a sports game with no Mario, no franchisettes, no cartoon characters and no sports-license. This is being sold purely on the back of the gameplay, and that deserves to be applauded.

If you look back at SNES Super Tennis' relatively plain presentation with fondness, you'll prolly like the blandness in this too. No messing. No pretence.

Dullness rox!
 
Drinky Crow said:
buy a psp and hot shots



Yeah, Hot Shots on the PSP is a stunningly addictive golf game. That game owned me for a solid 2 weeks when I first got it. It's one of those games that i'll never sell. It's that good.


I had high hopes for True Swing on the DS as I figured it would be cool to have a good touch screen golf game. These two reviews have confused me though. I'm very much on the fence right now. I'll admit I got a little bored just watching a couple of IGN's videos. Thats not always a good sign. :/


I should probably just save my damn money but.
 
I loved Hot Shots Golf so I decided to give this one a chance... and for once I fully agree with Gamespot. Gameplay mechanics are good but the game is flat. Boring. You'd better pick another game.
 
Prospero said:
So did anyone else around here pick this game up yet?


Not me, and i'm usually a sucker for this type of game on the DS. The game just doesn't sem to have much going on. Either that or my self control has gotten much better in recent months. :lol
 
Yeah--the reviews tend not to be clear on why the game might suck.

If it sucks because reviewers expect a Nintendo golf game to be brightly colored and have power-ups and such, and instead the game is no-frills and purist, then that makes it a must-buy for me.

If, on the other hand, the game doesn't play well, that's another thing altogether.
 
Prospero said:
Yeah--the reviews tend not to be clear on why the game might suck.

If it sucks because reviewers expect a Nintendo golf game to be brightly colored and have power-ups and such, and instead the game is no-frills and purist, then that makes it a must-buy for me.

If, on the other hand, the game doesn't play well, that's another thing altogether.

Yeah exactly. On the other hand it is part of the collection of games for the older generation in Japan like Brain Training (uh what's it called again... Generations, I think...). That's why it is not that colorful, I think. But the GS score is quite low compared to the press average (around 7,8 i think)...
 
Apparently it's going to be $24.99 from 1/29 to 2/4 at Target. I'll wait for that sale--by then maybe more reviews will be out.
 
jarrod said:
Or just buy Mario Golf Advance.
Oddly enough, Mario Power Tennis was in my top five GOTYs for 2005, but I really didn't care for Mario Golf that much. Maybe because the doubles partner was bad, maybe because it's awkward to try and comprehend a putting green that's represented with arrows, maybe because several of the stats were unnecessary to even bother, maybe because I kept accidentally somehow triggering a replay of my last shot, or maybe I just don't like golf. I don't know.
 
Ok, I broke down at bought this game today. I used the wonderful $10 off Best Buy coupon. I only paid $25 so I figured it was probably worth that price. My self control isn't as good as I had hoped. :lol


My first impressions are ok. The game is certainly put together pretty well. It's got very simple but nice menus and the options are certainly plentiful.

The graphics really do dissapoint, even for a DS golf game. Tiger Woods which came out for the DS launch, looks very comparable to this. Here we are over a year later and this is the best they could do? I don't think so. I think this is just plain lazy ass programming. There is even popup of textures during the fly-overs of each hole. The overall look is ok but thats it.


The gameplay feels alright so far. Keep in mind that i've only played a few holes. I played a decent amount of Tiger Woods DS and this plays about the same. In fact, i'm not even sure I can say that True Swing plays better than Tiger. It's a tough call.

So, it seems that this game offers a few more cool things compared to Tiger (single cart multiplayer, a lot more courses than Tiger, and more options). It's just sad that they didn't put in the effort to make this the definitive DS gold game. :/
 
I like it. part of that may be my freakish nostalgic affinity for the SNES T&E Soft golf games, but it's a nice simple golf game. it's a bit stately, but I'm an elitist anyway!
 
I dunno... I picked this up when it came out in Japan, and while it's fun for a while, ultimately it's kind of dull. I think this is more to do with the lowkey presentation though. If it had the character design, customisation and other bells & whistles that Hot Shots has, it would be the better game, thanks to the interface. It's really fun to play with the touch screen.
 
I picked this game up earlier this week, and I've played through two rounds.

I like it, at least so far, and I think a 6.0 score is undeserved. The closest comparison for the game is to the PGA Tour Golf games that were on PC/Mac before the era of Tiger Woods licensing. There are lots of indicators on screen to help you drive and putt, but they don't make the game easier--my scores in both rounds were -2 on the easiest course, whereas in a round of Tiger Woods I'd be off my game if I didn't get -12 or better.

The negative reviews seem to be focusing on the lack of customization, options, graphics, etc.: all these things are ultimately immaterial to the gameplay. This game is for purists only: no rainbows flying behind the ball when you get a good drive; no unrealistically long drives right off the bat (the 1W drives 210 yards off the tee, not 350); no golfer prancing up to the tee and whacking the ball with the driver one-handed; no stupid-ass aftertouch where you direct the ball's path in midair after you've already hit it with the club. My only real complaint so far is that landing in the rough or in the bunker doesn't appear to carry as much of a penalty as it should, but the game is already hard enough as it is. Swing controls are perfect--if you whiff shots you have no one to blame but yourself.

I like Mario Golf for what it is, and I like Tiger Woods fine enough (again, for what it is). But this game shouldn't be criticized for not being either of those. Graphics are kind of so-so, I'll give you that, but even so it's worth the $25 I paid for it.
 
Quick scenario/question here:

So, I'm a big fan of Mario Golf: Advance Tour (GBA)... played the hell out of it, and it remains one of my favorite golf games of all-time.

I'm currently waiting for my Hot Shots Golf: Open Tee (PSP) to be delivered... should be here any day now. I've played all the other HSG games to some extent, and enjoy the intuitive, pick-up-and-play feel of those, too.

I've never been a big fan of the Tiger Woods series on any platform, but I played semi-oldskool PC golf sims like Links/Links 386, etc. quite a bit.

So, my question is this: Given the above, do you think True Swing Golf has legs for someone like me, or is the novelty of swinging with the touchscreen going to wear off? I've heard that it does "feel" like you're really swinging a golf club, but it's hard for me to confirm without actually having given it a shot in person. I've been on a handheld gaming binge lately, so any further information (aside from what's already been said) would be helpful. Thanks!
 
I think it's a great game. Not very flashy, but golf fans won't really care. It's still not as good as Pebble Beach on the Saturn though.
 
siege said:
I think it's a great game. Not very flashy, but golf fans won't really care. It's still not as good as Pebble Beach on the Saturn though.
you damn pebble beach fanboys! waialae is superior!
 
It's a half decent game, but with HSG:OT and even MGA available I simply wouldn't recommend this one. My biggest complaint was the touch screen swing mechanic, which while initially it seemed rather deep and complex, soon reveals itself to be very basic, shallow and rather gimmicky. The aiming thingy that appears after lining up the shot kinda kills the whole 'skill' aspect, and the detection recognition of the various nuances of the line you draw is shit. The game only registers like 3 or 4 speeds no matter how differently you draw, and there is no shot selection. It's uber basic, and completely lacks the depth of other golf games.
 
Heian-kyo said:
It's a half decent game, but with HSG:OT and even MGA available I simply wouldn't recommend this one. My biggest complaint was the touch screen swing mechanic, which while initially it seemed rather deep and complex, soon reveals itself to be very basic, shallow and rather gimmicky. The aiming thingy that appears after lining up the shot kinda kills the whole 'skill' aspect, and the detection recognition of the various nuances of the line you draw is shit. The game only registers like 3 or 4 speeds no matter how differently you draw, and there is no shot selection. It's uber basic, and completely lacks the depth of other golf games.
Thanks for the feedback! I guess for now, I'll skip it, unless I'm starved for something else in the golf realm. HSG:OT just arrived today, so that should satiate my craving for some good golfing fun for the time being.
 
ntb825 said:
I love the idea of stylus swing, but fuck does that game look boring. I had it pre-ordered, but cancelled it after reading so many "the mechanics are good, but it'll put you to sleep" impressions.


Please Nintendo - Mario Golf DS. Please.

QFT

Mario Golf is one of my favourite series.
 
Top Bottom