Verge: The Internet is fucked

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe it's because I'm old but I did just fine without it. Sure I can only speak for myself but I certainly don't need it. In fact it kinda destroyed my job (at least made it way less enjoyable). So I would have no issue with the internet being gone by tomorrow.

You do know the internet is more than just your job and social media, right?
 
Again I'm not dismissing the importance of the internet in this day and age just saying that it's ridiculous to compare it to something like water. And that I personally don't need it.
 
Maybe it's because I'm old but I did just fine without it. Sure I can only speak for myself but I certainly don't need it. In fact it kinda destroyed my job (at least made it way less enjoyable). So I would have no issue with the internet being gone by tomorrow.
If you want the internet gone, then yes, making it a utility is probably a bad idea.
I think it's in the interest of the US citizens and its economy to have the best internet possible, and the current model is failing to achieve that pretty spectacularly.
 

Then why does my water and electricity not get "better and faster and cheaper" over time? And how come I don't have competition for my energy bills? Oh, that's right, because there is no competition for water and electricity.

I would definitely take an internet utility that is highly regulated by the government over what we have now. But to talk about it like it is water and electricity, then complain about competition creates a contradiction.
State utility boards have tight control to make sure water and electricity companies justify all of their costs. It is different state to state, but pure profit going back to the company is very limited, the rest has to go back to rate payers. Rate increases or service changes, like an arbitrary download cap in the internet realm, would require extensive filings with evidence for hy they need to be in place. Then a public hearing would be held do all the negatives could be drawn out.


Also, that Compete Coalition mentioned above is backed by large industrial customers, the only group that would stand to benefit from deregulated energy. Residential customers do not benefit, and in many states they have been hurt by electric competition due to the loss of the subsidization by industry.
 
I love how some of you lot think that your view of the world is the only one. Wake up. Others have different feelings and opinions. And that's ok. Just because YOU would be ok without any Internet access, doesn't mean everyone else would too. And no, just for the record, we're not just using it for Facebook and Twitter. I don't even use either of them. Some of us have businesses that require the Internet. My children are home schooled, over the Internet. I am a developer who works from home, over the Internet. When I lost my job last year and had to look for a new one, both companies I had multiple interviews with needed me to be online for VOIP conferencing. I couldn't just go to the library for that.

I'm sick and tired of the ridiculous attitude people have of "This is how is it in my life, so everyone else's life must be the same." The world isn't black and white. What works for you, doesn't always work for someone else. Open your eyes and get your heads out of your asses. Yes, your opinion matters, but it's not the only one.

Again I'm not dismissing the importance of the internet in this day and age just saying that it's ridiculous to compare it to something like water. And that I personally don't need it.

I get that, and I have no problem with anyone who says that they personally do not need it. It's the people who are dismissive of the needs of others simply because they could do with out that I have an issue with.
 
The world without internet?
I'm pretty sure I can live without it, the company I work for however....as well as the companies that my company work with....
Yeah, I like having a job.
 
Internet is a damn requirement for school now. Everything is done online. The government will never do anything about it as long as lobbyists are allowed to line politicians pockets and theyve actually made it illegal to outlaw lobbying or do anything about it.
 
Are they being cheap or scheming to not hire as much people as they should? Because surely they have to know not every person has the internet due to their current living conditions.
I'm going with being cheap and scheming (cheap to save money, scheming to use this to issue more sanctions), over here they seem to be more interested in sanctioning benefits (cutting all benefits for months at a time) instead of helping people get a job (like I said, they're removing everything that helps you) - it was quite a shock when I learned my local job centre was removing phones and job points.

When (at the time) I asked how I was meant to search/apply for jobs under this setup (as I had been told to use the website), I was told "the local libraries allow you a free 1 hour a day on computers - use those".
 
3333570688.png


DAMN IT VERIZON
 
I don't know. This argument is blowing very close to the 'teh Internet is a human right'. Businesses owe people nothing. They are service providers. ISP's function on fulfilling a want, NOT A NEED. People can function in society without being online. They really can.

I want to participate in the modern economy. I do participate in the modern economy. I enjoy the Internet. I like having a Fast Speed, which I appreciate I am lucky to have. I pay for this service, and if my provider makes faults or I am unhappy with the service, I complain or withdraw.

But make no mistake - equating it to heating, water and gas, semantically what people equate Utilities to be (regardless of how the reality is), is a dangerous game. My family would cope just fine at home with no Internet. I'm 31. Society was just fine before it, and it will be fine with whatever comes after.
The problem is that people not being online is detrimental to society as a whole due to slower communication and innovation.
 
Again I'm not dismissing the importance of the internet in this day and age just saying that it's ridiculous to compare it to something like water. And that I personally don't need it.
Do you have an issue with heat, gas, sewage, and electricity being considered like water?
 
Anyone who doesn't think the internet should be treated as a utility or that it's merely a luxury should describe to us how a scenario where the internet entirely going down plays out. I'm guessing it would be pretty catastrophic, for the economy, for businesses, and an enormous change for the lives of hundreds of millions of people. This shit shouldn't be in the hands of a couple monopolistic corporations.
 
Do you have an issue with heat, gas, sewage, and electricity being considered like water?

People die if they don't have safe drinking water. It's a big cause of death worldwide. People die if they don't have reliable heating from gas or electric. You see this every winter.

The internet is not like these things.
 
People die if they don't have safe drinking water. It's a big cause of death worldwide. People die if they don't have reliable heating from gas or electric. You see this every winter.

The internet is not like these things.

I was unaware that "you might die if you don't have it" is in the definition of a utility.
 
It bugs me that the title of the article is so broad and inflammatory when it's really only talking about America.

I've been using the Internet since the early 90's and the performance has steadily gone up while the price to access it has consistently gone down. I can't really complain about that.

I think the Comcast/Time Warner merger would be bad for consumers and Americans should stand up against it.
Majority of gaf is American. If there was a thread title that said president signs some piece of legislation would you get angry the title didn't specify which president? Get over it.
 
People die if they don't have safe drinking water. It's a big cause of death worldwide. People die if they don't have reliable heating from gas or electric. You see this every winter.

The internet is not like these things.

Yeah it is, those utilities are now highly dependent on the internet for providing service. Many companies would not be able to run at all, no credit/debit transactions at the grocery/department stores. It is an essential part of the US infrastructure and economy.
 
Fantastic article. The global economy runs on the internet now, the US Gov letting cable companies have their way in the US is a very bad thing for the global economy long term.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom