Finished The Wishsong of Shannara today.
Here's my review:
Looking forward to taking a break from fantasy after 1800+ pages of Terry Brooks. In short, just read Elfstones of Shannara.
Here's my review:
While mercifully shorter than Sword of Shannara, this felt like a remix of that book and the vastly superior Elfstones of Shannara. The opening act felt far too familiar, and once the adventure got going, I just couldn't find anyone to really latch onto from a character perspective. Of special note, Rone Leah was a total wet blanket whose emotional reaction to everything was cranked to 11. I can't believe that Brin decided to stay with him at the end of the book, and the writing of slang like "for cat's sake!" made me cringe on more than one occasion.
The writing was serviceable, and there were sections where Brooks had the description down to an art, but it was fairly pedestrian for much of the adventure. I felt a block between myself and the book, as if I were watching these characters from behind glass and never really given a reason to connect to them. Still, I enjoyed parts of it, and at least it was over quicker than Sword.
I won't be diving back into this world for a while, but I think it's safe to say that this trilogy can be ranked as such:
1. Elftstones of Shannara
-----
2. Wishsong of Shannara
3. Sword of Shannara
If someone were to ask me whether or not they should read this series, I'd suggest just reading the plot summary for Sword of Shannara to get familiar with the characters, then read all of Elfstones of Shannara, and read the summary of Wishsong somewhere as well. This was likely more enjoyable 20-30 years ago than it is today, but being so far removed from that context, it's hard to recommend it over so many better books and series. 3/5
Looking forward to taking a break from fantasy after 1800+ pages of Terry Brooks. In short, just read Elfstones of Shannara.