Support NeoGAF

[Laws00]

I always get breyers ice cream because it's the cheapest and most common.

Ben and Jerry's ice cream is ok to me. Need to explore them more.

Friendlys I like that the ice cream is creamy as hell.

I just bought Blue Bunny Ice Cream and about to see what that's all about. I'm trying Salted Caramel Craze and Vanilla Bean. Bunny Tracks they only had 1/2 fat and they didnt have S'more Please or Red Velvet Cupcake.

So whats your favorite ice cream flavor and or brand?

I'm also curious how wal mart brand Great Value ice cream taste.

 

[Fat4all]

Chunky Fucky

 

[NoblesseOblige]

Store bought I really like Kroger's Private Selection. In particular this flavor:

My favorite though is from the state university's dairy store.

 

[Laws00]

Store bought I really like Kroger's Private Selection. In particular this flavor:



My favorite though is from the state university's dairy store.

That looks expensive as hell

 

[mcfizzle4]

Half Baked

 

[Westbahnhof]

Black Cassis is my current available favorite.
But Apple-Vinegar from Eisgreissler is GOAT.

(also great: pumpkin seed oil ice cream)

 

[Novocaine]

Vanilla. The most malleable. Also vanilla is the best flavour of anything ever.

 

[Indrid Cold1]

Wall's 99, with a Cadbury flake.

 

[NoblesseOblige]

That looks expensive as hell

When on sale it's usually $1.66 for a pint. Otherwise it's $3 a pint I think.

 

[Westbahnhof]

Vanilla. The most malleable. Also vanilla is the best flavour of anything ever.

Maybe dilute it a bit, so the flavor doesn't overwhelm you?
Sickening.

 

[NoblesseOblige]

Vanilla. The most malleable. Also vanilla is the best flavour of anything ever.

Not the best flavor of sex.

 

[Toki767]

Cookies & cream is my go to if I don't know what else to get.

 

[Novocaine]

Not the best flavor of sex.

Have you tried it?

 

[Fliesen]

Depends.

When i'm getting a cone with multiple scoops, one of them is always chocolate.
When i'm at home, i feel like Vanilla is the most versatile one - you can cut up a banana, drizzle it with melted chocolate, eat it with hot raspberries.
For "eat it straight from the pint in front of the TV" purposes, i guess it's either B&J Chunky Monkey or ... New York Super fudge Chunk.

Just this weekend i found out that i'm apparently super weird for liking mint+chocolate chip ice cream...

 

[scamander]

I prefer ice cream from small ice cream parlours. They always try new things and my favourite flavours change on a weekly basis, but right now I love everything with Buttermilk in it (Buttermilk-Tangerine or Buttermilk-Seaberry for example).

But Apple-Vinegar from Eisgreissler is GOAT.

disgustedjimcarrey.gif

 

[Westbahnhof]

Have you tried it?

You didn't start out with vanilla?

I prefer ice cream from small ice cream parlours. They always try new things and my favourites flavour change on a weekly basis, but right now I love Buttermilk-Tangerine.



disgustedjimcarrey.gif

First you mirror what I think, then you stab me in the back. Try it if you see it anywhere.
Slight sour taste with lovely sweetness, amazing.

 

[Laws00]

When on sale it's usually $1.66 for a pint. Otherwise it's $3 a pint I think.

That doesn't seem bad

 

[Novocaine]

You didn't start out with vanilla?

Nah man straight to the weird shit.

 

[Captain Skeleton]

If you ever find yourself in Scotland, go to Nardini's.

 

[Fat4all]

Nah man straight to the weird shit.

straight to monkey-bone flanagans

 

[wandering]

Tillamook is my jam

That doesn't seem bad

It's a grocery store faux-artisanal generic brand

 

[Teriyaki Blues]

Store bought I really like Kroger's Private Selection. In particular this flavor:



My favorite though is from the state university's dairy store.

I might have to hurt you a little if this is available near me.

I don't really have a favorite flavor, I try and cycle different ones through. My family has been destroying Tillamook ice cream for the last couple of summers, which might be the most consistently good store bought brand I've ever had. Even their single flavors are great, very fond of the strawberry one.

Locally, I have a shaved ice place near me that does Dole Whip. Not even sure if it counts as ice cream but I could easily eat it every day and never get tired.

 

[Westbahnhof]

Nah man straight to the weird shit.

A rabbit killing pervert who prefers vanilla to actual flavors.
Christ.

 

[arigato]

I prefer ice cream from small ice cream parlours. They always try new things and my favourite flavours change on a weekly basis, but right now I love Buttermilk-Tangerine.



disgustedjimcarrey.gif

Tangerine flavor in ice cream actually sounds like a very good idea. Gonna have to try that one out.

 

[TheSkullPrince]

Vanilla because you can put almost anything on it.

Love putting hot fudge on it, or pouring it over warm chocolate chip cookies or hot apple pie...my mouth...it just.....well, I mustn't be vulgar in present company.

 

[scamander]

Tangerine flavor in ice cream actually sounds like a very good idea. Gonna have to try that one out.

Do it, it's amazing!

First you mirror what I think, then you stab me in the back. Try it if you see it anywhere.
Slight sour taste with lovely sweetness, amazing.

Ok, I promise I'll try it if they still offer it the next time I'm in Vienna.

 

[Novocaine]

A rabbit killing pervert who prefers vanilla to actual flavors.
Christ.

Vanilla is a flavour.

Not my fault rabbits are stupid.

 

[Westbahnhof]

Ok, I promise I'll try it if they still offer it the next time I'm in Vienna.

Good.
...I think it's long gone already. :'C

Vanilla is a flavour.

Not my fault rabbits are stupid.

Vanilla is half a flavor at most.
Can't really argue the rabbit part, I just read it and wanted to use it to shame your vanilla loving butt.

 

[Musha_Soturi]

Proper Cornish ice cream is the best

 

[MarkMclovin]

Phish Food.

 

[Lord Fagan]

While I get a sense of deja vu about this thread, the answer is still obviously Graeter's.

 

[Novocaine]

Vanilla is half a flavor at most.

I'd fight you IRL for this heresy if I could

 

[Grizzlyjin]

Blue Bell Banana Pudding. I've had a couple others like it, but none that top it.

 

[TheSkullPrince]

Vanilla ice cream on a hot fudge brownie, sweet Jesus.

 

[Westbahnhof]

I'd fight you IRL for this heresy if I could

Fuelled by the power of black cassis, I'd overpower you like everything overpowers weak vanilla.

 

[Fox1304]

Nothing will ever top this for me.
Perfect mix of smooth, crunchy, sugary, refreshing.

 

[Skyr]

At the moment it's this one:

I also love plenty of b&j..
Hell give me any ice cream I'll eat it :|

 

[retroman]

Mint.

Of course, it's almost nowhere to be found here in Holland. Bunch of savages.

 

[Sunster]

Ben & Jerry's: Half Baked

 

[Laws00]

reminds me i need to try some more haagen dazs

 

[Tevious]

Publix Ice Cream was my go to ice cream when I was in Florida. Now I just go to Baskin Robins or McDonald's because there aren't many choices here in Korea.

 

[beelulzebub]

I know it may not be a proper answer for this thread, but since everyone already has a lot of the good shit covered, Halotop ice cream is shockingly great for ~350 calories a pint. Good second choice if you have a sweet tooth but want to add some protein/ration your calories a bit.

 

[Laieon]

Bluebell Mint Chocolate Chip

 

[sphinx]

I love Häagen Dazs' business approach:


"our pint is $4,99, the competition's is $1.99, we don't give a fuck, you'll buy ours, you always do"

lol

 

[Skyr]

I know it may not be a proper answer for this thread, but since everyone already has a lot of the good shit covered, Halotop ice cream is shockingly great for ~350 calories a pint. Good second choice if you have a sweet tooth but want to add some protein/ration your calories a bit.

I tried halotop when I was on vaccation in the US recently and thought it was pretty bad.
Still better than nothing when you are on a diet a guess.

 

[+Aliken+]

No brand crap. Only proper ice cream

As for flavour... hard as there are so many but Yogurt is one of them.

 

[Usobuko]

Vanilla
Dark Chocolate
Durian ( Mao Shang Wang )
Lime
Mango

Vanilla right at the top.

For mainstream brands, I like Haagen-diaz and Movenpick. Don't like the mixed clutterfuck of most Ben and Jerry flavours.

 

[winterymint]

www.saltandstraw.com Ooey gooey brownie

www.amplehills.com The munchies

 

[hotcyder]

It's the only thing my home town is particularly renowned for (and only really by people in short distance). It is excellent though.

 

[Noctilum]

Moomer's blueberry cheesecake. You'll have to go to Traverse City, MI to experience this heavenly bliss though. The shop is on their farm. The cows are milked in the morning to use in the ice cream, fruit is picked there and they bake most everything else to put in there as well. It's all made in one spot then handed to you.