Which Silent Hill should Bloober remake next?

Which game?

  • Silent Hill (1999)

    Votes: 172 66.7%

  • Silent Hill 3 (2003)

    Votes: 35 13.6%

  • Silent Hill 4: The Room (2004)

    Votes: 23 8.9%

  • None (let them make an original SH game)

    Votes: 28 10.9%
  • Total voters
    258
Jordoon said:
Yeah I agree. Why can't we all just let the games we loved live on fondly in our memories? And if we must indulge, emulation is always there.

Instead companies keep regurgitating old games because it's cheaper, safer, and nostalgia is a helluva drug. Kind of blows mind that most people wouldn't rather have a new experience, new story, etc. The poll results are very surprising to me.
Click to expand...
Low risk, full pay. (If done well)
And it works both for the hardcore fanbase and the guys that weren't even born yet back in the 90s.

Though for a kinda dead franchise (now coming back from death) as Silent Hill, I kinda understand the expectation of a well done remake/reboot. It's been a long time since the Ps2 games, fanbase had to deal with a lot of average-crappy games since then. Or just deal with rumours about nothing.

Then we have things like Horizon Zero Dawn, Until Dawn or Last of Us Part 1 for Ps5. Pointless as fuck.
 
EverydayBeast said:
People are all over silent hill how about we play the first one? We haven't seen silent hill on store shelves, it's always interesting silent hill trailer, they should follow the yakuza format. I don't trust silent hill.
Click to expand...
Adam Sandler Comedy GIF by Netflix Is a Joke
 
They should remake SH1 as a ton of people havent played it.

Afterwards, they shouldnt remake any of them and release a new one.

SH3 and SH4 are still great experiences, but not sure if worthy of a remake as of yet.
 
ricardo_sousa11 said:
They should remake SH1 as a ton of people havent played it.

Afterwards, they shouldnt remake any of them and release a new one.

SH3 and SH4 are still great experiences, but not sure if worthy of a remake as of yet.
Click to expand...
People said the same about RE4 and the remake was still great. I see no problem with that. Even though characters and story are the same, they are new games.

I'd love for them to make new Silent Hill stories, but I don't trust them with the creative direction (The Medium, ewww)
 
I think they already said that they have no interest in 1 and 3 and they chose 2 because was more in their style.

Maybe the success of the remake is gonna make them change their mind, money tend to do that to people.

If i have to chose, then sh3, i never played that one.
 
Last edited:
FingerBang said:
People said the same about RE4 and the remake was still great. I see no problem with that. Even though characters and story are the same, they are new games.

I'd love for them to make new Silent Hill stories, but I don't trust them with the creative direction (The Medium, ewww)
Click to expand...

Making the same game over and over is useless.

I'd prefer they would take risks.
 
If Konami wants to imitate Capcom sooo bad...how about making remakes AND new numbered entries AND rescueing the classics? No, making a remake is not enough to preserving a classic, it's just another version of the story.
 
SH4 is narratively kind of a successor to 2. Also the weirdest of the 4 original SH games. So I would love for them to start with that and then maybe SH1 + 3 after that.

But my guess is they'll remake SH1 first and then make an original title.
 
freemandos said:
If Konami wants to imitate Capcom sooo bad...how about making remakes AND new numbered entries AND rescueing the classics? No, making a remake is not enough to preserving a classic, it's just another version of the story.
Click to expand...

This is a big problem I see when companies make remakes for "the modern audience" instead of respecting the original game. They beliveve they have the right to take out any "rough edges" in the design because they think it doesn't please modern sensibilites. It's like remaking Taxi Driver or other 70's movies and removing stuff that some might consider offensive today. You just water down the original vision and you practically say that the gaming audience needs to have their medium Disney-fied and infantilize them. I understand there's a difference between remakes and remasters, but I still think you should be as faithful as possible to the original. Otherwise, why not just make a new game instead?
 
Last edited:
they should have cybil be hostle and try to arrest harry for coming there and have him get away and be handcuffed behind his back like in the movie. also i think matt smith would be a good harry
 
Last edited:
lolol I never voted back then but just came jumped in this thread and voted for silent hill 1. I saw the future all this time ago.
 
Last edited:
So with this, SH3 will also be a given as well, right? I wonder if we can also get SH4. That is where my interest in the series ended. SH4 was the last good SH game, IMO.
 
Azure Crystal Gaming said:
So with this, SH3 will also be a given as well, right? I wonder if we can also get SH4. That is where my interest in the series ended. SH4 was the last good SH game, IMO.
Click to expand...
I'd assume so considering the connections between SH1 and 3. I know a lot of people questioned why they did things out of order, but I think it makes sense the way they did it. SH2 is widely popular among the fans, and 1 and 3 are connected. So, the order makes sense IMO. I'm assuming 4 is kind of up in the air as it's another that isn't directly connected. I really enjoyed 4 as well, though the least out of the 4, but still, I'd love to see it remade as well. I'm sure it's on the docket.
 
bloober should do this game;
www.silenthillmemories.net

Silent Hill 5 (Team Silent)

Unreleased, cancelled and rejected Silent Hill projects
www.silenthillmemories.net

the cancelled team silent sh5 that was chosen for the more western silent hill homecoming. it could be a new silent hill and also a remake of a game that never existed
 
Azure Crystal Gaming said:
So with this, SH3 will also be a given as well, right? I wonder if we can also get SH4. That is where my interest in the series ended. SH4 was the last good SH game, IMO.
Click to expand...

I think it will highly depend on sales performance. If the remakes keep selling then they'll keep making them. 2 was the most popular so we'll have to wait and see how 1 remake performs. Surely 2 Remake success will prop it up. I expect 1 to reuse a lot of 2 assets so maybe it will help with developing costs and time.
 
I would've liked a Silent Hill 4 Remake more than a Silent Hill 1 remake. Mostly because I think that SH1 aged well, actually. But I am certainly not mad that they're remaking 1.

I'd kinda like to see Bloober making a new, original SH game next, though.
 
Idk if a remake is the right choice for SH1, it is a very odd game and it relies a lot on PlayStion 1 hardware to deliver its horror but I would love to see what they do with it, other than that The Room is a very underrated game so yeah that
 
Jesb said:
I think they should give these guys a shot at a new original silent hill.
Click to expand...
I think they should ressurect team silent's cancelled silent hill 5 concept that was abandoned for a more western direction for the series (homecoming). it could masquerade as a new silent hill. i have a feeling all of bloobers silent hill stuff is gonna SLAP
qj.net

Silent Hill 5 will be scary even in broad daylight - QuickJump

You know how everything - even a cuddly, snow-white, red-eyed bunny - looks scarier in the dark? That's why very few horror movies ever take place in
qj.net
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Silent Hill 1 remake announced - Konami/Bloober
News  2 3 4 5 6
286
2K
GrayChild replied
Silent Hill 2 Remake PS5 Pro Patch Is Still In The Pipeline
2 3 4
199
2K
CellarDoor81 replied
[Rumor/Grain of Salt] Silent Hill 1 & 3 remakes by Bloober Team in development
2
87
7K
Heimdall_Xtreme replied
Silent Hill 2 Remake is now available DRM-free on GOG
News 
19
803
Dr.Morris79 replied
  • Poll
In case Bloober makes another Silent Hill game, which would you prefer?
27
2K
ShadowNate replied
Top Bottom