• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Why was Spencer pushed?

It is also (unlikely) possible he is really retiring, could also be for health reasons. The guy worked there for 35 years, his net worth is in tens of millions of dollars.

Bond not leaving a farewell message might mean she was really fired without notice, which would be strange for such a high profile executive.

Sarah did leave one. I posted it in the other thread.

Both of them leaving at the same time raises eyebrows is all I'm saying. I think Phil was given a choice, and he chose to retire with his $25+mil net worth.
 
Give him credit for the positives and Apparently it's never his responsibility when the outcome is a negative one.

Don
Terry Myerson
Satya
Amy
The tools
Wait till next E3 etc

Fuck off
 
Last edited:
Could have something to do with Phil convinced Microsoft to spend $100 Billion dollars on studios and has very little to show for it?!

Microsoft investors are asking Wendy of they could have instead put that money into AI or Drone technology?!
 
If you want a more complex answer:

Microsoft as a whole makes far higher profit margins than gaming industry, Xbox existence came down to Ed Fries et others convincing Bill Gates that Sony was taking over the PC Gaming space and therefore, the PC space itself, which was a major threat to Windows, and PC gaming suffered in the 00s with plenty of studios dropping their commitment to it and go for Playstation, Xbox and Nintendo instead.

Fast forward, PC gaming is in full force, Sony is porting their games to the platform, the budget costs are so huge that developers make multiplatform as a priority since porting is a dot in the budget sheet, Microsoft probably see this as evidences that they will never be threatened in their core business and Xbox can exist as a profitable per unit niche than a slim margin popular brand (think like automakers, they have been killing cheap cars for SUVs for this reason).
 
I think he was fired as was Sarah Bond. I don't know the reason but if I was to guess it would be:

Satya Nadella has for the last 2 years made some big impositions on the Xbox arm of the company forcing AI and profit margins. I believe Phil and Sarah went along with these probably pushing back a bit but being corporate citizens ultimately did what they were told.

This essentially has destroyed the Xbox brand and caused caused investor questions, Xbox was never a jewel in the crown but had some growth and had stabilized during COVID. Now it's struggling and much worse after Satya's interference.

Unfortunately, Satya never takes responsibility for his screw ups (of which there have been many under his tenure), this is hence an effort to shut down criticism; so he fired Phil and Sarah( giving them payouts to shut them up and take tHe fall).

Sarah will be taken care of financially, and I suspect Phil just said F&@k it after getting a big goodbye check and looking at the value of his stock.
We will unfortunately never know what happened from those two key players
 
Top Bottom