• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

WWE Holding All-Day Creative Meetings Today & Friday

Status
Not open for further replies.

krae_man

Member
They will probably shoehorn in some way to make Bryan more prominent and eventually get a title win. However, it won't be a proper backed push and as such will fail, they will go "see see" and we'll get Cena-Orton #9000 and more Big Show main events.
 
He's got no chance. No chance in hell.

XUL7y.gif

Believe.
 

kirblar

Member
If anything, I think Ziggler will have less TV time. They're going to have to fill in Punk's spot with 3-5 older wrestlers who can barely move. No time for Ziggy.
Ziggler needs to get himself over. The "be more selfish" critique is a real one.
 

bigkrev

Member
How could they be so out of touch with the fan favs?

Merchandise sales (Cena sells by far the most merch), ticket sales- a few weeks ago, the Cena house show in Sacramento outdrew the Bryan house show in Vancoover on the same night (and those markets are about the same size), and PPV buys (Summerslam with Bryan on top had a massive drop from last year, and all of the fall PPVs with Bryan main events sold poorly)
 

Musolf815

Member
They look at the sales of their merchandise. Unfortunately kids still love Cena so WWE keeps him in the spotlight.

This plus main eventers being decided by Vince, who is notoriously mood swingy with pushes (see: Ryback) and guys he won't give up on despite being horrendously not over (Del Rio).
 

Rapstah

Member
Summerslam, with Cena/Bryan on top, should really not be used to point out why Cena PPVs draw better than Bryan PPVs. The fall PPVs, there's a billion arguments either way for why those should have drawn or couldn't have drawn, but Summerslam, come on.
 

Showaddy

Member
I'm wondering how iron clad Batista's contract is, Wrestlemania's absolutely fucked with him main eventing at the moment but is that something they can fix by just saying 'fuck it you've flopped down to the midcard' or are they stuck with him?
 
Hope they come out with an announcement like they did with the start of the attitude era

I think the only thing that will really save them is if they do a Cena Heel turn....Bryan wins the Title and they fastrack Sting vs Taker

Bryan vs Punk at WM
 
I'm wondering how iron clad Batista's contract is, Wrestlemania's absolutely fucked with him main eventing at the moment but is that something they can fix by just saying 'fuck it you've flopped down to the midcard' or are they stuck with him?

They can simply write a match which puts up the number 1 contender spot...i think they have done it before
 

bigkrev

Member
Summerslam, with Cena/Bryan on top, should really not be used to point out why Cena PPVs draw better than Bryan PPVs. The fall PPVs, there's a billion arguments either way for why those should have drawn or couldn't have drawn, but Summerslam, come on.

The previous year was Lesnar-HHH and Cena-Punk-Show. This year was Cena-Bryan and Lesnar-Punk, and did 70K less buys.

Those are basically all the same people, with Bryan swapped in for HHH.
 

Penguin

Member
So the article cites Keller of PWTorch for breaking the story, but it is neither on their site nor does he mention it on Twitter

Was it during like his radio show?
 

krae_man

Member
PPV buy rates have been steadily declining for years anyway. It's one of the reasons the WWE Network is even a thing. It's just an excuse.
 

aparisi2274

Member
I'm not a hardcore viewer, but I'll watch from time to time.

When I saw the insane 'YES' chant after Bryan won a cage match on Raw last week, I assumed WWE would fast track him to top card draw and have him in some main event at Wrestlemania and then I hear what happened at RR. What a shame. CM punk did the right thing by leaving.

Sometimes I wish they would take creative control away from HHH because it seems like he only books wrestlers that he likes.

Oh well, curious to see how this all plays out.
 

krae_man

Member
I'm not a hardcore viewer, but I'll watch from time to time.

When I saw the insane 'YES' chant after Bryan won a cage match on Raw last week, I assumed WWE would fast track him to top card draw and have him in some main event at Wrestlemania and then I hear what happened at RR. What a shame. CM punk did the right thing by leaving.

Sometimes I wish they would take creative control away from HHH because it seems like he only books wrestlers that he likes.

Oh well, curious to see how this all plays out.

That's every booker ever pretty much.
 

bigkrev

Member
PPV buy rates have been steadily declining for years anyway. It's one of the reasons the WWE Network is even a thing. It's just an excuse.

Rumble and Elimination Chamber were up (but Rock was involved),Money in the Bank was up. Yes, PPV as a whole is down, but by basically every measurable metric including TV ratings (someone tracked all the quarter hour gains over the past few years for different wrestlers, Bryans drawing power is nothing like the strength of his reactions at Raw and on the Internet.

Are all of the numbers flawed in some way? Absolutely. But none of the indicators that actually mean anything money-wise point to Bryan being a gigantic superstar.
 

Ravager61

Member
I know that all this CM Punk stuff and these panicked meetings and rewrites backstage are probably not a work, but I wish they were. It would be amazing.
 

kirblar

Member
Such a shame what they did to Zack Ryder. I wasn't really a fan but he was over and his merchandise was selling decently. Still Vince no like.
Ryder's name shows up on the "bleeds viewers" list that was compiled for 11/12/13, unfortunately. That list actually helps explain a lot about their thought process.
The previous year was Lesnar-HHH and Cena-Punk-Show. This year was Cena-Bryan and Lesnar-Punk, and did 70K less buys.

Those are basically all the same people, with Bryan swapped in for HHH.
The problem is that the product has been super-stale for a very long time, hence the continuous downward trajectory.
 
Summer slam has a low butyrate because E has conditioned fans to expect the worst . Don't think many people thought Bryan would debut a new finisher and beat cena clean
 
Q

Queen of Hunting

Unconfirmed Member
remember when daniel bryan lost to sheamus in 8 seconds lol
 

Spider from Mars

tap that thorax
They should let Wrasslegaf book for WWE. We would either make Raw the highest rated show on cable or put the company out of business in a month.

Out of business in a month
 

krae_man

Member
Unless they give a wrestler a proper 3-6-9 month build, they really have no right to say "see this guy isn't a draw".

Ryback wasn't a draw and received "boring" and "Goldberg" chants, but they still spent 9 months aggressively pushing his character and "feed me more" slogan.
 
Punk said during a Q&A earlier this month that the WWE didn't even have concrete plans for Wrestlemania. He criticized that they should already be planning for next Wrestlemania which I know they used to do in the past.
 

Chopper

Member
Unless they give a wrestler a proper 3-6-9 month build, they really have no right to say "see this guy isn't a draw".

Ryback wasn't a draw and received "boring" and "Goldberg" chants, but they still spent 9 months aggressively pushing his character and "feed me more" slogan.
Only to drop it and turn him heel for no discernible reason. What a waste of time.
 

kirblar

Member
Punk said during a Q&A earlier this month that the WWE didn't even have concrete plans for Wrestlemania. He criticized that they should already be planning for next Wrestlemania which I know they used to do in the past.
They need to be planning things top to bottom all the time. It feels like Vince wasn't all that personally involved in storytelling/scripting/creative during the late'90s/early '00s boom and so over the years they've shifted to something more closely resembling the '80s, which has been terrible for business.
 

strobogo

Banned
When people say Ziggler needs to get himself over more and be more selfish, they don't mean do stuff like Ryder did. They mean to not over sell everything and make everything done to him look like death. He sells a punch from Santino like he would Bork beating the shit out of him. He's made a career out of making others look so good that it has damaged him. He needs to be a little more judicious in when he's going to over sell. Dudes sells exactly the same for Miz's weak ass offense as he did for Big Show and Cena.

They need to be planning things top to bottom all the time. It feels like Vince wasn't all that personally involved in storytelling/scripting/creative during the late'90s/early '00s boom and so over the years they've shifted to something more closely resembling the '80s, which has been terrible for business.


No way. In the 80s, everything was booked months and months in advance. The main event to next year's WM was planned at the end of this year's. When Randy Savage was brought in, they had 8 months of shit laid out from his first day. EVERYTHING was planned out well in advance and only got changed unless someone really shit the bed, got fired, or got injured.
 
Cornette said in one of his shoots that when they'd have creative meetings, if Vince got called away to answer a phone call or something, they could do absolutely nothing in the creative process because Vince had the final say so they sat there getting nothing done until Vince came back. I'm assuming the same is done here. You can't be creative without consulting one (or two) people who have the final say in anything that's done.

so much truth to that must be horrendous lol
 

kirblar

Member
No way. In the 80s, everything was booked months and months in advance. The main event to next year's WM was planned at the end of this year's. When Randy Savage was brought in, they had 8 months of shit laid out from his first day. EVERYTHING was planned out well in advance and only got changed unless someone really shit the bed, got fired, or got injured.
But was the undercard given the same level of attention back then that it was in the attitude/post-russo era? That's the big thing I see- it's been left to rot for nearly a decade.
 

strobogo

Banned
But was the undercard given the same level of attention back then that it was in the attitude/post-russo era? That's the big thing I see- it's been left to rot for nearly a decade.

Absolutely. Everyone had gimmicks and stories and the ones that didn't were jobbers to the stars, which is a role that doesn't exist anymore. From top to bottom, everything was planned out at least 6 months at a time in the 80s. Russo didn't invent the concept of giving mid carders angles. And most of the mid card angles were terrible, but people say "well at least they had something to do". I don't agree with that. No angles is better than bad angles.
 

krae_man

Member
Only to drop it and turn him heel for no discernible reason. What a waste of time.

But John Cena was hurt and needed 2 weeks off. That was totally a valid reason to put Ryback in 4 consecutive matches he creatively could not win, then have him lose clean at mania for no reason other then being a random swerve for random swerves sake.
 

kirblar

Member
Absolutely. Everyone had gimmicks and stories and the ones that didn't were jobbers to the stars, which is a role that doesn't exist anymore. From top to bottom, everything was planned out at least 6 months at a time in the 80s. Russo didn't invent the concept of giving mid carders angles. And most of the mid card angles were terrible, but people say "well at least they had something to do". I don't agree with that. No angles is better than bad angles.
We have "no angles" now, and bad ones are definitely better. There's a reason people actively tune out 15 minute matches that mean nothing.
 

strobogo

Banned
Time filler matches are better than bad angles that damage careers after them. Guys can get over just on ring work today, which wasn't possible in the Attitude Era because TV matches were 3 minutes long and the main events might be 10 at most. Daniel Bryan, the most over guy on the roster, got over because of his in ring work. CM Punk originally got over on his work as he wasn't given a lot of mic time until his big heel run against Jeff Hardy. Cesaro gets reactions from doing awesome shit in the ring. Dolph got over originally based strictly on his ring work because he's terrible at talking. It's a different era.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom