Leyasu
Banned
Ok, what did Insomniac release after Sunset Overdrive?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Xbox passed on deal to make Marvel games to focus on their own IP - Head of Marvel Games
- Thread starter 3liteDragon
- Start date
Ok, what did Insomniac release after Sunset Overdrive?
skit_data
Member
As far as I understand, that game is what would become Spider-Man. It’s possible they had some sort of agreement but there’s no info on that afaik.
Edit: Ah, yeah they released the Ratchet & Clank Remake in between SSO and Spider-Man. And a few other, smaller games.
Last edited:
Decontamination Silo
Banned
I wish they actually focused on new IP. Are we really gonna be playing Gears of War 14, Forza 16 and Halo Infinite 2 in 2050??
Dick Jones
Gold Member
I agree. EA backed Xbox to win the last gen with Titanfall 1 and Xbone had good sales in the first year. To an outsider it would have made sense for an American Company doing very well (at that time) to be given first refusal by Marvel.
Leyasu
Banned
It is not easy to say with certainty that X studio could have worked on a marvel I.P
Last edited:
Topher
Identifies as young
Perhaps, but it didn't even have to be Insomniac. Microsoft could have found a capable developer. They should have found a way to make it happen.
Nothing really notable except for Ratchet and Clank which would have been done by a separate team.
Insomniac Games - Wikipedia
Dodkrake
Banned
I follow zero "console warriors" on Twitter, from any system.Man, I never realized how many of you guys follow gutter tier console warriors on twitter. It's almost scary
Keep sending postcards.
Swift_Star
Banned
They could’ve hired a studio for that, you know?
AdjudicatorHead
Member
Literally what Sony did… given Insomniac was still independent at the time
Calverz
Member
So I’m guessing the narrative being pushed here is Xbox could have had all these marvel games since 2014 rather than focus on Halo, gears and forza? As if to say Spider-Man etc?
Well I for one could not care. In the last year 8 years I have far more played and enjoyed those trio of games series faaaaarrrrr more than any one marvel game. So Phil chose right.
Well I for one could not care. In the last year 8 years I have far more played and enjoyed those trio of games series faaaaarrrrr more than any one marvel game. So Phil chose right.
Last edited:
Leyasu
Banned
Yeah they probably could have done. Like who though?
Last edited:
Swift_Star
Banned
You like playing iterations of the same game over and over again?
Goalus
Member
So you are not looking forward to "Spiderman with claws"?
That is shocking to hear.
March Climber
Gold Member
Yes, I quoted myself from a different thread and yes it applies here too. It's especially odd here since the video games are completely different than the movie properties.
Edgelord79
Gold Member
Why does it matter to you? Maybe they do.
That’s not my cup of tea, but for others they really like that type of thing.
Kokoloko85
Member
I didnt say it doesnt mean anything. Its just everyone has games in the pipeline.
Blind or not, they are selling the same. Series X/S has sold the same as Xbox One in 16 months and the Series is cheaper.
Xbox One‘s trajectory was also looking to outsell 360. It just didnt happen. I doubt Xbox reaches 360 numbers again. The landscape was in there advantage and probably wont happen again like that.
Both Xone and Series S/X sold better than the 360 after 16 months. 30% of the lifetime sales, but they are selling the same, so that doesnt mean much.
2 of the biggest AAA dropped last year with Halo and Forza. Gears will be another big one. Forza Sport another one. Hellblade 2. The new ip we’ll have to see
We’ll just have to wait and see
skit_data
Member
It’s not necessarily an ”either-or”-situation even if a lot of people seem to read it that way for some odd reason. As proven with how Sony used a then external studio in Insomniac.
Last edited:
Topher
Identifies as young
Microsoft had the resources to make all those games you loved as well as make Spider-man.
If not Insomniac, then perhaps Remedy.
Swift_Star
Banned
It’s a question. Can’t we ask question anymore? Lmao, don’t need to get defensive.
Calverz
Member
I enjoying playing good games and good sequels.
I don’t enjoy superhero games. At all.
D
Deleted member 471617
Unconfirmed Member
I simply disagree. At that time, they were basically two years away from shutting down Lionhead, cancelling Fable Legends and Scalebound and rumors had it that no funding was going into Xbox One so wouldn't have made any sense at that time. If anything, it probably would have back fired. As for finding an external studio, outside of Playground which are having their own issues with Fable, who else could they trust? Crytek, Remedy, etc. were external partners and both are long gone in regards to working with Microsoft exclusively.
Should Microsoft get Marvel/Disney/Lucas (and WB for that matter) now though? Absolutely.
Calverz
Member
It’s narrative that’s being pushed as far as I can tell. I mean we have people here quoting Twitter fanboys.
Swift_Star
Banned
So you like playing iterations of the same game over and over, got it. Nothing against that if you enjoy repetition. You do you.
Topher
Identifies as young
Well, I'll agree with you that if the rumors were true that Xbox was being defunded then it would make sense for Spencer to turn it down. Outside of that, I'll agree to disagree.
Leyasu
Banned
Remedy? lol
Nah man, I think that there's a reason why they stopped collaborating after Quantum Break. But, if we went with Remedy, which superhero do you think that they could have done?
Cyber_hunter026
Member
People genuinely associate the doctor strange ip with them.
Ambassadors probably. Did the same thing when MS, one of the richest companies in the world invests nothing into VR. Like having less games is good but having the same games coming, that were coming anyway, with Phil writting another company fat cheques is genius and great for them. I mean they rejected this to focus on their IPs and look at all the amazing games coming from their IPs...What is this narrative that Microsoft not making a Marvel game (not necessarily Spider-man) last gen was somehow a good thing? Xbox One's first party library was horrendous. A game like Spider-man would have been a huge boost.
But somehow, Sony getting not just that franchise, but the relationship with Marvel that created both the Miles Morales sequel and Wolverine was a good thing for Microsoft?
I've heard it all.
Calverz
Member
Hahahaha so salty. Iterations of the same game over and over…..do you really want to go down that road? As I said I don’t enjoy superhero games. I can’t think of one Iv enjoyed since 2014. Whereas I have had a ball with halo, gears and forza games. Sorry if that doesn’t fit your narrative preference.
Leyasu
Banned
Ok, I have never heard of Dr strange (don't hate me).
Edgelord79
Gold Member
I’m not defensive. I’m just genuinely curious why you would ask something like this considering you are clearly in the Sony camp and you know precisely what you are doing.
You can use words like “triggered” and “defensive” all you want but it’s pretty clear what your intentions are whenever you get into these types of threads.
Swift_Star
Banned
Series is at around 14.5 million 18 months in. Xbox one was around 12million after 18 months. That’s about a 20% increase.
Also they dropped the Kinect a half a year in or so, Making it $400. So their average sale price was the same.
Last edited:
Cyber_hunter026
Member
Imo there is a wealth of opportunity or possibilities with this character. but if not remedy, there is insomniac due to the whole rifts and dimensions.
ChorizoPicozo
Member
nah. this is not the full story.
Topher
Identifies as young
If they let Quantum Break burn that bridge then they were being foolish, imo. I agree with
Cyber_hunter026
. Dr. Strange would have been a good choice.
Leyasu
Banned
Imo there is a wealth of opportunity or possibilities with this character. but if not remedy, there is insomniac due to the whole rifts and dimensions.
If they let Quantum Break burn that bridge then they were being foolish, imo. I agree with
Yeah I have just been reading up on Dr Strange. Remedy are rumoured to be developing it too.
I agree, Microsoft should have carried on working exclusively with Remedy. They are good srtudio.
CircleOfFire
Member
When Microsoft passed on it? That's some spectacular mental gymnastics right there.
Kokoloko85
Member
Xbox one hit 13 million by May 2015. https://www.thetechgame.com/News/si...les-top-13-million-units-worldwide-sales.html
Basically they are very close.
Series S is much cheaper and mostly in stock I think
Funny Aaron Greenberg didnt mention that Xbox One also outsold 360 month by month in the first 16 months lol. He just mentioned Series X/S trying to make it sound like it was something special
Last edited:
I’m not sure where you’re getting those numbers from. Since Xbox doesn’t release numbers it’s hard to know for sure.
This is off vgchartz. “The Xbox Series X|S has sold 14.43 million units in 18 months, while the Xbox One sold 11.81 million units.”
Also the series s is $100 cheaper and X is $100 more. Averages out to be the same. I have no idea what the split is.
This is off vgchartz. “The Xbox Series X|S has sold 14.43 million units in 18 months, while the Xbox One sold 11.81 million units.”
Also the series s is $100 cheaper and X is $100 more. Averages out to be the same. I have no idea what the split is.
Cyber_hunter026
Member
So, it's marvel's fault. for coming to Microsoft, and ask if not attempt to strike a deal. for any potential marvel property to be exclusive to Xbox? and Microsoft turned them down. but it's their fault?
Last edited:
It's all in the wrist
Member
Thank God.
Lognor
Banned
Yeah cuz gotg and avengers did gangbusters. Lol
Incase you didn't know, both games did poorly.
Kokoloko85
Member
Im just saying what I read before:
“The Xbox One reached the milestone for the week ending June 27. The console sold 94,057 units to bring its worldwide lifetime sales to 13,054,203”
People shit on vgcahrts but they have been accurate loads since 2010
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
Chances are they would have been bad Marvel games anayway. I would rather see them focus on their own IP. The fact that they dropped the ball last gen, doesn't mean this would have been a good deal.What is this narrative that Microsoft not making a Marvel game (not necessarily Spider-man) last gen was somehow a good thing? Xbox One's first party library was horrendous. A game like Spider-man would have been a huge boost.
But somehow, Sony getting not just that franchise, but the relationship with Marvel that created both the Miles Morales sequel and Wolverine was a good thing for Microsoft?
I've heard it all.
Last edited:
MasterCornholio
Member
Sometimes you just need to take a risk. I don’t believe Insomniac has ever worked on a Marvel IP before so there was some risk in letting them make Spider-Man. Unless you take the same risk with someone else you’ll never know if they are capable of making something good or not.
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
I see you are easily triggered.
Lognor
Banned
Majority of Marvel games have been trash. Out sounds like ms made the right call
Nydius
Member
If you want to brag about being an unpaid marketing shill, hey, more power to you.
If you take that "Ambassador" badge seriously though, as if that "pledge" you had to sign means anything of significance, I suggest you seek actual professional help. It's a PR campaign where Microsoft found out they can exploit their fans to do marketing for them, not the damn Freemasons or something.
Topher
Identifies as young
That was a matter of timing though. If GotG had released first then it could have been a major hit. As it was, it had the Avengers stink on it. But if you are going to point to past performance then you should include Spider-man selling 20 million followed by Miles Morales selling 6.5 million.
I think you gotta go for it when given the opportunity, but @peter42O makes a good point that there could have been other circumstances that prevented it from happening at the time.
Similar threads
- Locked