I got bored and decided to do a "How much I want a stage to return" for each stage returning to smash 4, and what system I think they should be on.
Starting with
smash 64:
Congo Jungle
Number of smash bros appearances:
2
Desire for return:
40%
System:
Wii U
Reasoning: I'd make it higher, since this was brought back in melee, but 3DS already has a DK retro stage, so I doubt they'd have this one too. To bring this back, it would basically need a full remake for Wii U, so I say its chances are low.
Dream Land
Number of smash bros appearances:
2
Desire for return:
70%
System:
3DS
Reasoning: Basically, it's the original battlefield. Simple in design, would work great on 3DS. They would have to modify it to get rid of the flying dedede in the back, or at least replace him with alfonzo.
Hyrule Castle
Number of smash bros appearances:
1
Desire for return:
90%
System:
3DS or Wii U
Reasoning: It has never made a return, but I think it's a solid stage, especially if Temple is killed off. It fits perfectly fine on either Wii U or 3DS, but would obviously take a lot more work to adapt to Wii U. I think this is a fan favorite, so it would be nice if it made it back.
Mushroom Kingdom
Number of smash bros appearances:
1
Desire for return:
30%
System:
3DS
Reasoning: Would be nice to have a retro Mario stage, especially if they implement the wrap-around from balloon fight, but i don't think many people have fond memories of the stage. We also already have a POW block item, which was one of the main gimmicks of the stage.
Peach's Castle
Number of smash bros appearances:
1
Desire for return:
10%
System:
3DS
Reasoning: It's a pretty dull stage, probably my least favorite in the original smash. It's almost like a debug stage that they made into a real one. It's so random and doesn't really 'feel' like a mario stage. It's like they threw in the peach's castle art asset in the background and called it a day. With the current way that sakurai seems to love being true to each series, I don't see this one really coming back.
Planet Zebes
Number of smash bros appearances:
1
Desire for return:
80%
System:
3DS
Reasoning: This is probably my favorite Metroid stage ever made (outside of possibly pyrosphere. The melee ones were no fun, to me, and the gimmicks/hazards from the brawl ones were too powerful (Full screen lava waves, complete stage flips!). This is simple in design, can have an updated background, and work really well. A final destination version would be really nice, too.
Sector Z
Number of smash bros appearances:
1
Desire for return:
100%
System:
3DS or Wii U
Reasoning: Just like corneria, but in outer space. It would be nice to get this version back, rather than the one from melee/brawl. This is one of my favorite stage designs, and i'm glad it's been in every smash bros so far, but it'd be a cool throwback to have THIS version over the melee/brawl version.
Saffron City
Number of smash bros appearances:
1
Desire for return:
75%
System:
3DS
Reasoning: I'd love the 3DS to get this over an old/new pokemon stadium. It's a good way to showcase some pokemon (coming out of the door), and I think people really enjoyed this stage.
Yoshi's Island
Number of smash bros appearances:
2
Desire for return:
85%
System:
Wii U or 3DS
Reasoning: I think this was beloved by many in melee, and it's a good alternative to battlefield, with the slanted platforms. The level looks great, and it's basically the only nod we have to 'Yoshi's Story.' I'd love for this to come back on any platform.