@LiverpoolGAF and other Premfaces
Would Liverpool have won the league with Carragher last season? We desperately miss a commanding, vocal centreback who does everything in his power to prevent goals, which is Carragher defined. On the other hand, he'd have slowed our play down and I think he needed a commanding goalkeeper to help him out, which we don't have. Plus Skrtel was our best CB (not saying much), and he'd have had to play on the left to make room for him.
Obviously there are massive hypotheticals there, but Carra was pretty good in 12/13 and our defense was dreadful last year, and cost us the league to put it simply. I'm sure he had another season in him.