Okay, I've been really busy with work since the Robin/Lucina/Captain Falcon reveal and haven't really had a chance to air my thoughts here on everything that's happened since, so I'll do so now in a rather random order:
- Sakurai is a master at misdirection and I love it. We were all so sure it'd be Shulk, and it totally wasn't, and while I still hope Shulk is in (mainly because I want the Chorus Men/Marshall), I love it. For the first time since Rosalina we really don't know what's coming next, and it's awesome. That said, Sakurai did still say we're nearing the end of the newcomer trailers, so I don't think it's wise to expect anything TOO outlandish. We're still getting to the end of the newcomers, surprise Robin/Lucina reveal or not.
- Upon further reflection (and other people have said this already), I don't think Monday's non-Shulk reveal debunks the Sal Romano leaks. His leaks never claimed to know/have everything, and this is really no different at all from when Rosalina was revealed even though she had never been in a Sal Romano leak either. I think Sal's leak gives us one (big) part of the overall picture, but Sakurai and his team have done an incredible job keeping things under wraps, so naturally it's not going to have everything. The bit about Chrom being on the list does hurt its legitimacy, but more and more it's sounding like the guy who's giving Sal his info might not even know who Chrom actually is. (Plus, there's also the thing about the GameFAQs post from over a month ago saying Lucina would be getting in but not Chrom, which is interesting if nothing else.) The fact remains that 8 out of 11 (so far) is a really great ratio that gives the leaks a lot of credence. The fact ALSO remains that two of those leaked characters were Wii Fit Trainer and Mega Man, the former of whom literally zero people would have ever guessed (nor did they), and the latter of whom many had discounted due to Capcom murdering the character and franchise the way they have in the last few years. So yeah, I'm not anywhere near ready to call Sal's leak debunked; I just don't think it ever had the whole picture, nor did it ever claim to.
- I can't believe there was ever any debate about what Lucina was. How could anyone have ever thought she was just an alt costume for Marth when she had her own box on the website? Some people...
- I'm not that knowledgable about Fire Emblem (I've only ever played the beginning of The Sacred Stones and the demo of Awakening), but *man* it really seems like people have gone from wanting Lucina like crazy to rallying against her very quickly (which isn't that uncommon for SmashGAF, I suppose). Is it because she's a clone? From what I understand about Awakening's story, there's not much else she actually could have been, so what exactly were people expecting with Lucina? I will say that it's a little disappointing that she seems to be the "cloniest" clone ever, though, with only one difference between her and Marth.
- I'm seeing a lot of disappointment about Chrom, too, which kinda surprises me. Wasn't the general sentiment about Fire Emblem reps in Smash already that there are too many similar-looking blue-haired sword users? Chrom would just have been another one of those, whereas Robin (even if I don't personally care about him/her) is a truly unique Red Mage-type character who breaks that Fire Emblem sword user archetype. Obviously Marth and Lucina are fast and lithe while Ike is powerful and slow; Awakening fans, what would Chrom have brought to the table that's unique? Would he have served as a sort of middle ground between Marth/Lucina and Ike? I'm curious as to what Chrom would have offered that people are disappointed they're missing out on.
- On the subject of Chrom, you people still fooling yourselves into believing he still has a chance at playable status really need to stop, if only to not drag out the disappointment into a slow, painful thing for yourselves. I don't have any feelings on Chrom either way so it's not personal, but it's been made clear as day that Chrom isn't playable; Nintendo even issued a direct statement after the reveal saying "Chrom is not playable in Super Smash Bros." It really doesn't get any clearer than that. If he somehow ends up being playable, though, I'll be happy to eat crow.
- I'm really, really trying not to be concerned about Marshall/the Chorus Men now, but a seed of doubt has wormed its way into my mind. After being so sure about Sal's leak for so long, I'm now a little worried since Shulk and whoever the Rhythm Heaven rep ends up being are no longer a certainty. I know I said I still think Sal's leak is legit, and I do, but I can't help but be a bit concerned only because a Rhythm Heaven rep would be super fucking awesome.
- I'm already set because I have Mega Man, but if a RH rep gets in along with Ness, Jigglypuff, and the Ice Climbers returning (now that Falcon is back), I'll pretty much have my perfect roster.
Your top three DLC character requests if they don't make the main roster?
GO
1. Rhythm Heaven rep
2. Dixie Kong
3. Wart (yeah right, heh)
Great summary, Ash.
Well, remember the Sneaky Spirit in Smash Run? I'd like to think that means a Rhythm Heaven character is in the works.
Thanks! And yeah, I do, but I don't consider an enemy in Smash Run enough of a sign that we're definitely getting a Rhythm Heaven character. We already know there are logos for games/series that don't have any character representation in the game, like Pilotwings. My gut still tells me Shulk and a RH rep are coming, I'm just not 100% sure anymore...