Stumpokapow Presents: who would win in a fight lord byron or ernest hemingway

Status
Not open for further replies.

Brakke

Banned
These threads are always boring because the answer is "well it depends on the author" so I thought I'd head that off: WHAT IF IT'S THE AUTHORS THAT ARE FIGHTING???

250px-Byron_1824.jpg


George Gordon Byron, 6th Baron Byron
English
5' 8"
Trained Boxer, Mother Fucking Lord
Don Juan, "She Walks in Beauty", The Siege of Corinth

220px-Ernest_Hemingway_in_Milan_1918_retouched_3.jpg


Ernest Miller Hemingway
American
6' even
Big Game Hunter, Boatsman
The Sun Also Rises, For Whom the Bell Tolls, The Old Man and the Sea

Two icons of masculinity enter the ring. One paragon of America, one paragon of Jolly Ole'. Figure the battlefield is some kind of wilderness, both dudes being renowned adventurers.

Hemingway definitely had more wartime experience, even though he didn't fight that much. Dude was *at* D-Day but wasn't let out the boat. Ole Ernie also had more hunting experience, but Byron, Lord Dandy was a well known animal lover and kept lots of exotic pets; was Ernie enough of a hunter to parry Byron's Animal Brethren Stampede Attack??

Course, when they get face-to-face, Hemingway gets that +2 Damage Against Lobsterbacks American Racial Bonus.

Keep in mind that in accordance with Hunger Games rules, Byron can expect Greek and Italian sponsors in addition to his native English; Hemingway can expect Cuban and French in addition to his native American. Not sure if bottles of fine olive oil are more useful than the world's finest smokes.

I think Hemingway takes it purely on the martial merits. He's got much more experience with killing, and many more brushes with death under his belt. Plus, Byron's got that clubfoot hobbling in open field.

But that said, I think Lord Byron takes it on the tilt. Hemingway was such a raging homophobe that I bet Byron could throw him off guard by going in for a kiss when they shake hands at the start of the fight. Byron's way more wily compared to Hemingway's Straight Forward At All Costs style, you better believe Byron could pull a fast one on Hemingway. Plus, Byron's daughter invented computer programming so we know dude had some strong seed.
 
So you're asking me if a hunter can best....someone who's not a hunter?

I suppose it depends on the rules of engagement. I wouldn't beet against a boxer if they're both put in boxing gloves in the middle of a ring and asked to fight. If they were dropped in the forest, however...
 
So you're asking me if a hunter can best....someone who's not a hunter?

I suppose it depends on the rules of engagement. I wouldn't beet against a boxer if they're both put in boxing gloves in the middle of a ring and asked to fight. If they were dropped in the forest, however...

Yeah, it totally depends on the situation...
 
George Orwell. Guy got shot in the throat by a sniper and survived. Shot in the throat. Man can't be killed

Except, I guess, by tuberculosis.
 
The problem with these hypotheticals isn't that the cop out answer "depends on the author" always comes up, its that the parameters of the fight aren't clearly defined (and this isn't a situation where cool looking panels can elevate the thread). Is this a hunger games battle as you touched on? Is it a brawl? Are there refs? Fight to the death? KO? We need more OP!

Eh, my money is on Hemingway anyway.
 
Stump does not present this thread, Brakke does. Stump didn't have shit to do with it.

Who Would Win in a Fight Brakke vs Stump Edition spoiler it's Brakke because I'd throw the first punch at that intrudin'-ass punkapow.
 
Hemingway would just punch Byron in the face in the proposed kiss-out scenario, stunning Byron and letting Hemingway go for the kill.
 
Stump does not present this thread, Brakke does. Stump didn't have shit to do with it.

Who Would Win in a Fight Brakke vs Stump Edition spoiler it's Brakke because I'd throw the first punch at that intrudin'-ass punkapow.

It's tradition now to say that Stump presents these threads, because he hates them. It's just the other mods teasing him. :3
 
I like how OT has turned into The Increasingly Poor Decisions of Mods Not Named Stumpkapow

This whole arc basically ends in him turning on all the other mods and starting his new splinter group, The Stumpers
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom