‘The Walking Dead’ – Season 5, Part 1 – Sundays on AMC

Status
Not open for further replies.
DAMN that was some punch .. 2 full episodes and Eugene is *still* not up.

Also, I really freaking loved Rick's dazed and stone cold look when he had the gun pointed at that cop's head. That is the face of man on the verge of insanity.

I have to laugh at this photo though, he'd probably break his wrist if he actually had to fire the gun (recoil on something like that must be insane).
 
One of the very best episodes of this show was purely filler - going back to Morgan - so I don't even know what kind of complaint it is.
 
One of the very best episodes of this show was purely filler - going back to Morgan - so I don't even know what kind of complaint it is.

But that episode added so much character definition to Carl, Rick and Michonne, and has ultimately set up his return this season. So that wasn't at all filler?

So like, really, what the fuck is filler? Maybe we should just stop using that dumb word if people insist on using it as a default negative, or misusing it to describe slower character focused episodes (which ultimately work to raise stakes for the "bigger" episodes by building stronger relationships and characterization)
 
+I'm pretty happy Daryl sided with Tyrese's plan, sometimes he gets a little too 'whatever Rick does'

-Sasha is real schupid

+I think the Beth arc is great and Beth has improved as a character

-Gabriel fights off a Walker..with his hands. His hands. A Walker. His first Walker. That should have been game over for Gabriel

+Maggie covering Eugene =3
 
But that episode added so much character definition to Carl, Rick and Michonne, and has ultimately set up his return this season. So that wasn't at all filler?

So like, really, what the fuck is filler? Maybe we should just stop using that dumb word if people insist on using it as a default negative, or misusing it to describe slower character focused episodes (which ultimately work to raise stakes for the "bigger" episodes by building stronger relationships and characterization)

I guess it describes an episode that doesn't move the plot forward, which is starting to become every single one of them. So yeh, it's a dumb word to describe an episode of The Walking Dead.
 
DAMN that was some punch .. 2 full episodes and Eugene is *still* not up.

Also, I really freaking loved Rick's dazed and stone cold look when he had the gun pointed at that cop's head. That is the face of man on the verge of insanity.

Yeah. I miss him eye-fucking the camera
 
'Doesn't move the plot forward' what in the hell kind of bar does an episode now have to cross to not qualify for this critique around here.
 
It's officially worse than Heroes at its worst.
You're crazy man. Walking Dead might lose it every so often. But Heroes was fucking awful. Like, the worst show ever.

I liked this episode. But then, I like most of them. Sasha is, however, a fucking idiot.
 
Where do people think the story is going? Its a post apocalyptic zombie infested wasteland. It can't actually go anywhere.
 
'Doesn't move the plot forward' what in the hell kind of bar does an episode now have to cross to not qualify for this critique around here.

I really dont have a decent explanation

My main grip with the show is the "Nothing happens" complain. Yet a lot of things are actually happening.... and i feel the show sucks now more than ever.

I dont know, maybe i expected something different from the road the show is taking. Like i said some replies back, season 2 was bad but we had hope things would be better in the future, so we would take more shit. Now time has passed, things didnt got better and we dont have too much patience anymore with the show.


I wish they focus more on gathering food, shelter, ammo and interesting ideas to survive/rebuild than running from annoying threat to annoying threat.


The next episode will be a great one.

I dont have a lot of hope...
 
Please explain this "definition of filler" because using the word to describe an episode of TV you don't like is the definition of lazy criticism.

Was that not the rest of my post? I felt it was disjointed and they tried to cover everyone without really giving sufficient time to any one group. I thought because of that they didn't advance much in the way of the story or the characters.

They found a yo-yo, though.

*Shrug*


Might have been my expectations were set high. I thought they'd get inside the prison at least, but we got Glenn fishing and Abe sulking and Eugene unconscious and Beth ... well, being Beth. I'm surprised she didn't try to sing Carol awake.


It felt too spread out, like they tried to connect a lot of dots between eps 4, 5 and 6 to setup for 8, without really having the kind of focus the show is capable of bringing. They filled in the gaps, almost too literally, and thus the episode was filler.
 
Where do people think the story is going? Its a post apocalyptic zombie infested wasteland. It can't actually go anywhere.
I love the show, but actually agree with this. Every other show has a hook. "Maybe they'll get off the island". "Maybe Jack will get away/vengeance". "Maybe Walt will actually earn enough money for his family" etc.

Walking Dead? Nothing. No hope. Just that Rick manages to kill everyone.

I'm okay with this, but perspective is important. I am willing to accept that everything means nothing, and everyone will die eventually.
 
Yea that was pretty dumb.

I hate it how Daryl is getting soft, and trying to get Rick to be soft too. This guy just almost killed you, and you let him live. Have they not learned anything? Every time they let somebody alive it bites them in the ass 9 out of 10 times. Just kill them and get it over with like they did in the church.

They needed him alive as a bargaining chip. If he was just some dude that tried to kill them like the Terminus people of course he'd be dead no hesitation. Daryl's not soft, he's just being pragmatic. I have no doubt he'll have no qualms with slaughtering the hospital cops when the showdown with Dawn happens.
 
Where do people think the story is going? Its a post apocalyptic zombie infested wasteland. It can't actually go anywhere.

Walking Dead is one of the few shows on TV that can happily march towards toward the whole main cast dying horribly as they work to the final episode. Or maybe all but one dies, and the final scene is the last survivor sobbing in a cabin surrounded by 100s of Walkers.

I feel if AMC are respectable to the show runners, this show could go out with an amazing finish - simply as no other show could justifiably end that way.

No of the hero characters can "win," and the show has been about them surviving during its run, so going gritty and dark seems when the show finally want to end us a fantastic way to go IMO.
 
I love the show, but actually agree with this. Every other show has a hook. "Maybe they'll get off the island". "Maybe Jack will get away/vengeance". "Maybe Walt will actually earn enough money for his family" etc.

Walking Dead? Nothing. No hope. Just that Rick manages to kill everyone.

I'm okay with this, but perspective is important. I am willing to accept that everything means nothing, and everyone will die eventually.

I like to imagine that what we're seeing is basically civilizations rebooting themselves. At the beginning there was little groups, and they didnt really have any safe places to stay. Now, groups are getting much larger, places like the prison, and Terminus are popping up. Eventally, I think, humans will get to where they were before the zombie outbreak. What we're seeing in the walking dead is just the building blocks to that future. And of course, Rick and crew what be around for it. Its so far in the future they will all be dead.
 
I have no idea why you like to talk and act like you're so smart when you've made absolutely idiotic posts in this thread that clearly betrays your lack of understanding of what is actually going on. The show sometimes does treat its viewers as idiots but when they don't, we get posts like this:



Are you really that delusional?

Hilarious post. Way to embarrass yourself.

I've been critiquing the show, And many people have echoed my comments. Many of them. You've decided to attack me instead of what I've written. You're way too attached to his show and you need to take a break and think about that.

You're crazy man. Walking Dead might lose it every so often. But Heroes was fucking awful. Like, the worst show ever.

I liked this episode. But then, I like most of them. Sasha is, however, a fucking idiot.

Hereos was more ambitious with its time travelling stuff and had plenty of great moments during the first season. WD has made a show about survival boring. Furthermore, it had made zombies boring. A true feat.
 
Walking Dead is one of the few shows on TV that can happily march towards toward the whole main cast dying horribly as they work to the final episode. Or maybe all but one dies, and the final scene is the last survivor sobbing in a cabin surrounded by 100s of Walkers.
That would be an amazing ending.
I like to imagine that what we're seeing is basically civilizations rebooting themselves. At the beginning there was little groups, and they didnt really have any safe places to stay. Now, groups are getting much larger, places like the prison, and Terminus are popping up. Eventally, I think, humans will get to where they were before the zombie outbreak. What we're seeing in the walking dead is just the building blocks to that future. And of course, Rick and crew what be around for it. Its so far in the future they will all be dead.
The only problem is that every group we've seen is crazy as hell. One of the show's themes seems to be that only the strong survive and that survival is brutal. I don't see there being a happy ending with what we've seen of the remaining humanity; they're all killers, delusional, or insane. Maybe the spin-off will change that a little.
 
Would the episode have been better if Bob actually killed Sasha? I think so. That way Tyresse can stop being a fucking wuss and go berzerk on everybody again.
 
Hilarious post. Way to embarrass yourself.

I've been critiquing the show
, And many people have echoed my comments. Many of them. You've decided to attack me instead of what I've written. You're way too attached to his show and you need to take a break and think about that.



Hereos was more ambitious with its time travelling stuff and had plenty of great moments during the first season. WD has made a show about survival boring. Furthermore, it had made zombies boring. A true feat.
You're not critiquing the show dude. You're having a massive heart attack along with a brain aneurysm and a terrible diarrhea along with it. Show has problems but it's NO WAY near Heroes terrible. The day Rick turns to Carl and says "You know Carl, we really are the walking dead" is the day when you are allowed to make that comparison.
Would the episode have been better if Bob actually killed Sasha? I think so. That way Tyresse can stop being a fucking wuss and go berzerk on everybody again.
I think so too. Missed opportunity.
 
Walking Dead is one of the few shows on TV that can happily march towards toward the whole main cast dying horribly as they work to the final episode. Or maybe all but one dies, and the final scene is the last survivor sobbing in a cabin surrounded by 100s of Walkers.

I feel if AMC are respectable to the show runners, this show could go out with an amazing finish - simply as no other show could justifiably end that way.

No of the hero characters can "win," and the show has been about them surviving during its run, so going gritty and dark seems when the show finally want to end us a fantastic way to go IMO.

I always envisioned the comics ending with essentially everyone dying and Carl having one final scene with a dying Rick and then walking into the sunset, cowboy hat and gun in hand. Show Carl however is not as likeable as comic Carl who is an amazing character.
 
Plenty of things I didn't like from the episode, let's see:
  • Beth passes by and the old guy starts coughing, no one suspects anything. Beth passes by again and magically the old guy is fine. No one suspected anything.
  • Bob and his "Were you a cop?" line when talking to Rick.
  • Shootout scene was weird. It was 5 of them against a car that appeared out of nowhere, literally.
  • Ninja zombie attacking Gabriel.
  • While we are talking about Gabriel, why the fuck did he think leaving was a good idea? No matter how fucked up he is after seeing what Rick's group does, he HAS to know he can't make it on his own.
  • Sasha's stupidity because of a guy named Bob... I had to laugh at that last scene.
 
Plenty of things I didn't like from the episode, let's see:
  • Beth passes by and the old guy starts coughing, no one suspects anything. Beth passes by again and magically the old guy is fine. No one suspected anything.
  • Bob and his "Were you a cop?" line when talking to Rick.
  • Shootout scene was weird. It was 5 of them against a car that appeared out of nowhere, literally.
  • Ninja zombie attacking Gabriel.
  • While we are talking about Gabriel, why the fuck did he think leaving was a good idea? No matter how fucked up he is after seeing what Rick's group does, he HAS to know he can't make it on his own.
  • Sasha's stupidity because of a guy named Bob... I had to laugh at that last scene.
This is a great list
 
Watched the episode last night and thought it was pretty good, shame about Sasha's stupidity towards the end, but what's happening with Rick?

The scene where he's holding the gun on the cop who attacks Daryl, he legit looks like a man who is about to break and go on a murderous rampage and his earlier reaction to Daryl siding with Tyrese in not killing the cops.

Is crazy Rick about to re-emerge? Yknow, the one who too pleasure in massacring those marauders Daryl was hanging with back in season 4?
 
I don't think there is a crazy Rick any more. I think he has went half half on being insane and being a good guy but now he has combined the two into some badass hybrid. When business needs to be handled he is down to handle it and wants to do it the best possible way.

Those were the eyes of a man who wanted to lay down that copper so damn bad lol.
 
I don't think there is a crazy Rick any more. I think he has went half half on being insane and being a good guy but now he has combined the two into some badass hybrid. When business needs to be handled he is down to handle it and wants to do it the best possible way.

Those were the eyes of a man who wanted to lay down that copper so damn bad lol.

Yeah your right, he is still in control of himself but can still go HAM when need be.

The gun he is using with the silencer is bad ass too.
 
- THR: Robert Kirkman Reveals His Biggest 'Walking Dead' Regret
"If I had to do it again, I wouldn't have done the CDC episode [at the end of season one]," Kirkman told THR of the episode in which CDC doc Edwin Jenner (Noah Emmerich) reveals to Rick (Andrew Lincoln) that everyone is already infected.

The reveal came at an early stage for the zombie drama — which had yet to break out to become the ratings juggernaut it has become in season five, where it continues to rank as TV's No. 1 show among the all-important adults 18-49 demographic.

"It possibly gave away too much information and was such a big change very early on in the series," Kirkman said.
- EW: 'The Walking Dead' star Sonequa Martin-Green on Sasha
 

I wasn't vehemently opposed to the CDC episode like it seemed most people were. I thought it was a nice departure from always being on the road or held up in a shit hole. I actually preferred the way "we're all infected" was handled in the TV show vs the comic.

(Comic Spoilers)
Rick taking Jenner's words and keeping them to himself for the entirety of Season 2 since he didn't know whether to believe him or not was great. If you actually go back and marathon Season 2, you can see there are a bunch of moments where Jenner's words are haunting Rick and he almost spills it but he doesn't want to believe it. He doesn't want what Jenner told him to be true. And then ultimately, Rick confirms the truth in the exact same way: Shane coming back even though he wasn't bit. In the comic, Rick taking a motorcycle from the prison all the way back to Atlanta to find Shane's grave felt like too much (for lack of better wording).
 
I wasn't vehemently opposed to the CDC episode like it seemed most people were. I thought it was a nice departure from always being on the road or held up in a shit hole. I actually preferred the way "we're all infected" was handled in the TV show vs the comic.

(Comic Spoilers)
Rick taking Jenner's words and keeping them to himself for the entirety of Season 2 since he didn't know whether to believe him or not was great. If you actually go back and marathon Season 2, you can see there are a bunch of moments where Jenner's words are haunting Rick and he almost spills it but he doesn't want to believe it. He doesn't want what Jenner told him to be true. And then ultimately, Rick confirms the truth in the exact same way: Shane coming back even though he wasn't bit. In the comic, Rick taking a motorcycle from the prison all the way back to Atlanta to find Shane's grave felt like too much (for lack of better wording).

I still miss Rick driving out of his way to go dig up Shane and shoot him in the end like in the comics.
 
Reedus said he "cried and cried and cried" before shooting scenes for mid season finale.

Uh oh.

tumblr_mk73dv3taG1r2acrxo1_500.gif


Good times coming
 
Reedus said he "cried and cried and cried" before shooting scenes for mid season finale.

Uh oh.

Can't wait. Wonder if something happens to Beth. I'd like to see Maggie's reaction considering she mentioned her sister's name like twice since the prison went up in flames.

I said it before but walking dead always kills (multiple puns there) on season and midseason finales. Should be a good one.

Only T-Lion got the axe in the Season 3 midseason finale but I suppose that was enough... ;_;
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom