I dishonor joe for stating that he had a great system in place as well? I hear ppl blurt out this system QB thing like its a bad thing. Bill Walsh created a system and Joe didn't benefit from it all I guess. He did it all on his own. Fuck your kudos and eat all those colts failures. Luck will never be as good as neither Joe or Brady so chew on that.
Anyone that wants to bring up the words "system quarterbacK' when it comes to Peyton and Tom, bring it on. I will demolish this argument. It's usually an uniformed Peyton Manning fan who doesn't know jack shit about football offensive systems. That ship has long sailed. That stopped applying to Brady around 2005, and that label has, ironically, better fit Manning ever since.
System quarteback by Manning fans argument is ironically the one thing that proves Peyton Manning isn't as good as Tom Brady. Peyton Manning has played in one system, pretty much his entire career,
his. And you can go research this. And anyone that's read about his offense, will know it's actually a pretty simple offense, that is executed to perfection, all credit to him. His offense in Denver, was pretty much the same offense he ran with the Colts with the exception of the last few games this year after Fox tried to add a heavier dose of the run game as soon as BB and the Pats exposed Peyton, once again.
Unfortunately as good as a passer as he is, he gets credit for being an offensive coordinator as well, and that's the area where nobody ever talks about how he is nowhere as good, and very predicatable.
It's actually that fact, the fact he is unable to adapt to any other offensive system that constantly bites Peyton in the ass against BB's defenses or Seattle's defense, or any other good, smart defense in the NFL. He's used it for far too long, and too many coaches know it all too well. He never innovated. When he runs into GREAT, smart, defenses in the playoffs, his offense has gotten exposed time and time again.
The fact Brady has been able to play under a number of different offensive systems, from a run/pass balanced offense in his early years, vertical offense during his Randy Moss years, and now a spread-option inspired Josh McDaniels offense that banks heavily on tight ends, is what
destroys the system quarterback argument(truly, you have to be ignorant to still say this if you have watched the Pats offenses change over the years), and what makes Brady the better quarterback. In fact, Brady, at age 37, has began learning how to change his game a little and add scrambling as a weapon. He's not trying to be an offensive coordinator. He lets a guy better than him at that position, Josh, DO THEIR JOB.
The main reason the Pats were so successful this year, and one of the main reasons they are in the Superbowl this year, is because Brady and the Pats have gotten so good at playing in different systems, they are now capable not just of changing offensive styles from year to year, but on a week to week basis. Good luck figuring that out.
Peyton Manning's offense, oth, in Denver, is the same freaking offense he had with the Colts. And it's why he was decimated by Seattle last year, and once again by BB this year. Manning's ego got too big too early in his career, and though he could be as good an offensive coordinator as he is a passer. He was not, and he never got any better at it. And it's cost him. Peyton Manning is in fact the real system quarterback:
One system, his.
Oh and finally, if that doesn't do it for you, then how's this: Brady just finished completing 37/50 passes, a Superbowl record, and 4 touchdowns, erasing a 10 point deficit in the 4th quarter, in a Superbowl against the best defense in the NFL the past 3 seasons. Manning's offense got demolished, just one year before by the same defense,
43-8. Manning's system stunk against the same defense Brady carved up like Swiss cheese in the same big game. You would think after it keeps happening to you, it might be time for you to change it and try something else....but even after that, Peyton Manning made no adjustments and played in the SAME system to start off the year this year, only to get demolished again, by BB and the Pats. And when Fox tried to change it up, Peyton failed miserably in it, and it cost Fox his job, and Peyton another chance at the Superbowl.