The Witcher 3 | Review Thread

What's the word on combat in this game? I couldn't get into The Witcher 2 because I felt like I was being pushed into using traps/magic even when I wanted to build my character to be a melee fighter. Does the combat sound better in that regard?

Surprisingly, many reviewers have listed the combat as a positive, when I totally expected it to be the game's weakest point.

So it looks like the combat is quite fun in this game
 
I have seen a twitch stream where Geralt was asked about his previous events and if you want to know them, they are this ones:

Aryan La Valette is alive/ is dead
Who did you chosed in Flotsam - Roche or Iorveth ?
Is Henselt alive or dead ?
Did you go save Triss or Saskia ?
Did you let Sheala de Tancarville be killer or did you saved her ?

I'm downloading the Witcher 2 again so I can check my quest journal.
I can't remember any of that :-/
 

Urgh.

atkMCSj.gif
 
CDPR comes off as a Valve type company from when they were a lot smaller maybe in 2010-11. GOG Galaxy alongside Witcher 3 is going to help them cement a nice place next to Steam.
 
Looked strange because it seemed like Geralt's hair was unaffected by the wind when everything around him seemed like it would break in half.
 
Metacritic is dumb and all, but currently Witcher 3 is above Dragon Age: Inquisition in the rankings. Honestly, with how mass market a game needs to be to score so highly, I don't know whether this is a good thing or not.
Wonder when EA will acquire these folks.
7fkwKww.gif


But seriously, if it ever happens we now know who to blame.
 
I have seen a twitch stream where Geralt was asked about his previous events and if you want to know them, they are this ones:

Aryan La Valette is alive/ is dead
Who did you chosed in Flotsam - Roche or Iorveth ?
Is Henselt alive or dead ?
Did you go save Triss or Saskia ?
Did you let Sheala de Tancarville be killer or did you saved her ?

And if you never played Witcher 1 & 2 how do you know what to choose ?
Is there some context to these questions ? Those names mean nothing to me right now....

I really liked how Mass Effect did it with interactive comic based decisions.
 
And if you never played Witcher 1 & 2 how do you know what to choose ?
Is there some context to these questions ? Those names mean nothing to me right now....

I really liked how Mass Effect did it with interactive comic based decisions.

Presumably, these are for people who played the previous games. If you are on PC with saves or you're completely new then you're probably better off declining to answer the questions.
 
I have seen a twitch stream where Geralt was asked about his previous events and if you want to know them, they are this ones:

Aryan La Valette is alive/ is dead
Who did you chosed in Flotsam - Roche or Iorveth ?
Is Henselt alive or dead ?
Did you go save Triss or Saskia ?
Did you let Sheala de Tancarville be killer or did you saved her ?

Goddammit, I just watched a summary of both games last night and only remember who half these people are.
 
Goddammit, I just watched a summary of both games last night and only remember who half these people are.
VanOrd said a guide would be put up on Gamespot describing the background of these choices to people new to the series. Strange the game would just throw them at newcomers though
 
Metacritic is dumb and all, but currently Witcher 3 is above Dragon Age: Inquisition in the rankings. Honestly, with how mass market a game needs to be to score so highly, I don't know whether this is a good thing or not.

7fkwKww.gif


But seriously, if it ever happens we now know who to blame.

I wouldn't call Blood Borne mass market and it scored similarly
 
I watched a bit of video reviews here and there (trying not to overdo it since I do plan to play this at some point) and despite many aspects of the game looking great, there's something that's really bothering me.

The swordplay looks really stupid based on what I've seen so far.

example: http://www.gfycat.com/KindlyBraveBufeo

It just looks like a lot of really weightless spinning. There are other things, too, of course, but it just looks dumb and the spins are constant.
 
I watched a bit of video reviews here and there (trying not to overdo it since I do plan to play this at some point) and despite many aspects of the game looking great, there's something that's really bothering me.

The swordplay looks really stupid based on what I've seen so far.

example: http://www.gfycat.com/KindlyBraveBufeo

It just looks like a lot of really weightless spinning. There are other things, too, of course, but it just looks dumb and the spins are constant.

If it's anything like the other games, you're just looking at a very low level player using the starting attacks.

As far as how fast, nimble, and spinny Geralt is--that's just his style. Sorry bro.

1249282749302433933.gif
 
You know how DA:I had those dragons that were tough to kill, does The Witcher 3 have similar enemies that are really hard to kill? Like level 50-60 enemies spread throughout the world?
 
I watched a bit of video reviews here and there (trying not to overdo it since I do plan to play this at some point) and despite many aspects of the game looking great, there's something that's really bothering me.

The swordplay looks really stupid based on what I've seen so far.

example: http://www.gfycat.com/KindlyBraveBufeo

It just looks like a lot of really weightless spinning. There are other things, too, of course, but it just looks dumb and the spins are constant.

Geralt's sword fighting style is described as being derived from dance so it makes sense.
 
It's PC gameplay around 60 fps as well, according to the streamers.

IGN guy said they're walking through an area of the city that he has never been to except in passing, and he played ~120 hours.

EDIT: Highest level armor is acquired through crafting, not a vendor.

Visually it looks pretty much the same as PS4
 
I started playing The Witcher 2 again recently on a new PC I bought and it looks gorgeous. But I was struck by how bad the game mechanics were in some aspects.

You play this preternatural monster hunting badass. So what do you do for a large part of the game? Rummaging through containers for scraps of leather and other crap to craft into objects.

Total mood killer. The Bioshock series and Elder Scrolls had the same issue. I haven't played The Witcher 3 but if it suffers the same issue it might put me off trying it.
 
I watched a bit of video reviews here and there (trying not to overdo it since I do plan to play this at some point) and despite many aspects of the game looking great, there's something that's really bothering me.

The swordplay looks really stupid based on what I've seen so far.

example: http://www.gfycat.com/KindlyBraveBufeo

It just looks like a lot of really weightless spinning. There are other things, too, of course, but it just looks dumb and the spins are constant.

Geralt's sword fighting style is described as being derived from dance so it makes sense.

Yup. They're constantly saying pirouette, parry and riposte in combat in the books.
 
I started playing The Witcher 2 again recently on a new PC I bought and it looks gorgeous. But I was struck by how bad the game mechanics were in some aspects.

You play this preternatural monster hunting badass. So what do you do for a large part of the game? Rummaging through containers for scraps of leather and other crap to craft into objects.

Total mood killer. The Bioshock series and Elder Scrolls had the same issue. I haven't played The Witcher 3 but if it suffers the same issue it might put me off trying it.

Have you ever played an RPG before? They're full of crap to pick up and sell/craft with.
 
Top Bottom