-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Uncharted 4 - A Thief's |Reviews Thread| Nateness Awaits
- Thread starter Kenzodielocke
- Start date
- Status
OrbitalBeard
Member
Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker has an 81 on MC.
The game might have tracked it for them. Any reviewers here can say?
MHWilliams with the answers.
I think it's a lock at this point.
I'm 100% I'd love it more than U1 and 3, we'll wait to see if more than 2 as well.
Can you link to a post where somebody actually predicted that?
I recall one guy predicting sub 80 specifically because quantum break got 77. Said something along the lines of "this genre is considered to be dated by reviewers, and doesn't score well anymore, quantum break proves that and uncharted 4 will score sub 80 as well"
Coulomb_Barrier
Member
Another must-have purchase for the Treystation 4 it seems.
This is so awesome I love stuff like this.
Maybe we'll be surprised and it'll jump up to 94 by midday!
GravityInsanity
Member
Back up to 94.
If it's anything like 1, 2 or 3, you can see all statistics in the Options Menu at any time. Like shots fired, accuracy, time spent running, time walking, time in cover etc.
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
Metro: "Whatever disappointment people may have had with the current generation of consoles up till now Uncharted 4 marks the spot at which those hopes and expectations are finally met. Which takes our excitement for what Naughty Dog might do next almost off the chart."
Yup rock star and ead with Mario / Zelda games have the same consistency but gta is slower but ead matches and even out does nd with its Mario zelda etc output... I still prefer nd personally I got tired of game mechanics and got into story oriented games once I found cs and dota
they got the mechanics challenge for me since then just just go to other games for an experienceMore critics.
all these 10 and still 93...
Kralamoonard
Member
I'm more surprised at Polygons score lol -- people were expecting much lower 
Neoleo2143
Member
Oh yeah, that game. I was too captivated by it. Shame though, I personally think it the perfect offspring to it's parent game.
I'm guessing they mean vehicular exploration, general exploration and exposition etc. But they don't really explain it very well. I think those negatives will depend on how invested you are in to the graphics, tech, character banter, treasures and extras etc. Some will love exploring every nook and cranny, taking screens, admiring the visuals, listening to the characters talk amongst each other etc, whilst others may just want to quickly move on to the next segment.
Original Man
Member
Spoiler in that gif? I didn't want to know she was in the game!
Back up to 94.
How many perfect scores to compare to TLOU and UC2?
Eolz
Member
Undertale is at the same score/timeframe on opencritic.
MP skin.
TrojanBlade
Member
How come mc score gets stuck even with more higher scores after certain number of reviews? How does it work?
It could go down to 92 after IGN's and EDGE's reviews, honestly more chance for that.
Kenzodielocke
Banned
I don't know either. It's from the Multiplayer.
Mp taunt gif nothing to do with the campaign
MP bro.
GarciaHotspur
Member
Back up to 94.
still 93 with 53 critics
Tricky I Shadow
Banned
Everything in this thread has been predictable, it's kind of boring to be honest. Meh, whatever, bring on May 10th!
**goes back to playing Overwatch**
**goes back to playing Overwatch**
SilentFlyer
Member
18 perfect scores so far.
More critics.
Dammit. I went with 94.
Ascenion
Member
I think it's mathematically impossible for it to surpass or even match 2 at this point. 2 didn't get any 7s if I recall correctly
I'm sick of this culture where we prey on people's enthusiasm and hype because it makes for good "internet" fodder. Mamarobotnik has this famous wall of shame that I'm on, but honestly, a majority of those posts were from people who were genuinely suprised and non hostile. Meltdown culture and being a character is one thing, but we've had people specifically in Uncharted threads not to play the game, but to remind every one they are here to laugh and mock people. IMHO That sort of behavior is just as irresponsible and crass.
Any major game with a fanbase that scores low will have some sort of inflammatory backklash.
Agreed. And so far, most people's expectations were in line. It's been echoed over and over again: "This is the best Uncharted yet-"; "This is best game on the PS4;" if these two quotes aren't enough to atleast motivate a passing interest in playing the game- than Uncharted and PS4 aren't for you.
The fact that Steve Burns ended up liking it is a massive plus for the game. HINT: he really isn't a fan of the first three.
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
18 Perfect scores, now
Now I know she can dance, is there no respect for the uninitiated?
brickarts295
Member
Kenzodielocke
Banned
Nate n Sully reading the review thread:
Poimandres
Member
Are you sure those people actually exist?
Funny that some people are angry about an 8.8, but there's no review party without some angst!
Great scores, congratulations Naughty Dog.
Area Jugones 10/10
http://areajugones.es/uncharted-4-el-desenlace-del-ladron/analisis/
http://areajugones.es/uncharted-4-el-desenlace-del-ladron/analisis/
Kralamoonard
Member
Just curious then, why did he end up reviewing it? Not saying you have to be a super fanboy of the series but surely someone who's a loose fan at worst?
- Status