Yeah, this was a great write up that echos a lot of my thoughts. I'm still not terribly far (just a little over 7 hours), but I find it's gameplay loop still fascinating. It's almost a guarantee that I'll get bored eventually and move on to something else. The same thing happened with the Witcher 3. I played until I got bored, then came back in a few months and finished it. Love that game. Sometimes, I think it's good for a game to have that kind of ebb and flow. I also don't think every game needs to be powered through from beginning to end in record time. I couldn't imagine putting in 30+ hours in three days like that one guy did. Maybe I will in the end. I'm sure my livestreams of the game have been pretty awful, because they still primarily take place on the same planet in the same star system, but I'm not playing to be entertaining. I'm playing at my own pace in a way that satisfied me.
For me, liking the game doesn't mean I'm blind to the many shortcomings and issues of the game. It just means that despite those issues, I'm still having a good time with the game. I'm 37 years old. I've been gaming since the NES released in North America in 1985. I've played a wide variety of games, some of them classics, some of them mediocre, some of them outright terrible, and some of them flawed gems. I think NMS is a flawed gem. Games don't exist in a "GOAT" or "Dogshit" existence. Some games will hit it out of the park for you, some of them won't. I've said time and time again, I'm not a fan of CoD or Gears of War. I don't like them, and I've played them. Doesn't mean those games are garbage because "I don't like thing," it just means they aren't for me, so I don't bother engaging in discussion in threads about those games, because I just wouldn't have anything I'd consider worth saying outside of, "Not for me."
That thread is embarrassing (as a lot of review threads are), because people are frothing at the mouth for schadenfreude. Like that thread about Star Trek Beyond underperforming and people being gleeful for some reason. So much internet culture seems to anticipate observing failure or disappointments, because they have this perverse love of seeing the people that had their hopes on the product succeeding get upset and disappointed at failure. It's really fucked up and weird to me. I subscribe to the philosophy of "If I don't like something, I move on and don't waste anymore of my time on it." I'm not going to live journal my displeasure every chance I got. Maybe I just derive more joy from talking about something I like, rather than things I don't.