The only way this mess receives half decent critic scores is from the "open world" handicap. As long as you throw a turd into a sandbox you'll captivate half of today's audience.
No Man's Sky: 72
Just Cause 2: 84
Shadow of Mordor: 84
FFXV can ship with frequent framerate drops, horrific voice acting, and a terrible story, but as long as people can run around in a field and clumsily smack things, that's all they'll need. Shadow of Mordor completely rewrote LOTR's lore, had only two maps, and shipped with locked disc DLC and no one cared.
"Open world" is a powerful crutch.