Support NeoGAF

[the-pi-guy]

I'm into consensual sex.
Where does that put me?

Also I'd like sex in public. Maybe with someone watching (consensually of course)...

1

 

[NoblesseOblige]

I'm into consensual sex.
Where does that put me?

Off the charts you sick sick person.

 

[nilbog21]

Guys I work in a hospital why do people enjoy being pee'd on

 

[Abstrusity]

I'm into consensual sex.
Where does that put me?

Also I'd like sex in public. Maybe with someone watching (consensually of course)...

1

Exhibitionism is probably at least a 2. As soon as I'm done with this PotD run, I'll work on a scale.

 

[kavanf1]

2-3 at most, and I'm fine with that.

Someone really needs to put examples at each number on the scale to allow more accurate judgement though.

 

[Fried Food]

probably a 5

 

[mrpallyguy]

Probably a 10

 

[mr2xxx]

The fact that I have to Google some of the weird shit you people are into already puts me near the bottom.

 

[nkarafo]

Is there a limit in what can we can talk about? Or we risk a ban?

I just want to know what counts as a 10. There's some really crazy shit on the internet. Usually stuff you never see on regular porn sites like Youporn. Some of it highly illegal.

 

[Pamplemousse]

I just want to know what counts as a 10.

Scat play

 

[nkarafo]

Scat play

From what i have seen, this is a 6 at most.

 

[B.O.O.M]

If your fetish causes you problems it can be removed by a therapist. Usually it's not worth doing but if it's troubling you that may be the way to go.

Yeah mate might just have to do that in the future. It doesn't bother me and I don't even actually want to act out on it..but I worry it may affect my relationships. Let's see

 

[AnathemicOne]

Scat play

 

[alternade]

I usually hover around a 6.5 but can easily ramp up to a 8 or 9 depending on who I'm with and if it mutual.

 

[iSnakeTk]

Where am I on the scale if i like to do her while she has her clothes on?

Seeing woman naked is boring af so I leave something to my imagination.

 

[PreyingShark]

Dude, FA isn't even the worst. Trust me.

FA is pedestrian compared to like even IB.

True. I've seen people move to IB specifically because FA's rules were "too strict", after all...

 

[NoblesseOblige]

Where am I on the scale if i like to do her while she has her clothes on?

1.25

 

[Blackie]

Is there a limit in what can we can talk about? Or we risk a ban?

I just want to know what counts as a 10. There's some really crazy shit on the internet. Usually stuff you never see on regular porn sites like Youporn. Some of it highly illegal.

There is always a limit to what can be talked about. My guess is that certain illegal stuff will risk a ban or worse.

 

[woopWOOP]

My fantasies are a 6+ atleast
I don't even know how I'm supposed to explain it
So I won't

 

[DarknessTear]

6-7. Probably more of a 6.

 

[nkarafo]

Ok, here's what i consider a 10. This is mostly stuff that aren't meant for fapping anymore I HOPE. Should be just morbid curiosity.

Things i dare to watch:

Real snuff movies
Necrophilia
Vomit / Gore


Things i would never dare to watch (but i know they exist)

Spoiler

Sexy models crushing small animals with high heels

Spoiler

Nevermind, too risky to mention

Is there anything worse than those?

 

[iSnakeTk]

1.25

I guess Im pretty normal then.

 

[Snowybreak]

True. I've seen people move to IB specifically because FA's rules were "too strict", after all...

It has a good image interface, but in terms of community features, SoFurry and Weasyl are the best. They also have lax rules similar to IB, I don't know why people don't use them.

 

[NoblesseOblige]

Real snuff movies

Are you talking actual or simulated snuff? Because last I checked there's not been a legitimate snuff film. There's been videos of people dying, but they weren't staged or produced for erotic purposes in order to qualify as a snuff film.

 

[Abstrusity]

Well, if we want to do a scale, should we put more weight on noncon stuff? If it's noncon, does it make one fetish higher on the scale than otherwise? Is it noncon if you want it to happen to you, secretly, but not openly?

Content extremity OR grossness, but they can't intersect, because preferences ...are different.

We need to come up with a GAF standard of fetishes.

In addition, we'd also have to separate it into a sliding scale between submissive and dominant tendencies, because that would ALSO change things.

 

[nkarafo]

Are you talking actual or simulated snuff?

Mostly fake but realistic. Like Niku Daruma or August Underground.

I have seen real stuff too

Spoiler

(Luka Magnotta videos)

since i'm a gorehound and check shock sites every now and then. For me all that stuff is morbid curiosity and fascination with gore and death but i know some people get on with such things. So it's a definite 10.

 

[VanCityGamer]

Wow, some of the stuff you guys are into is fuckin' disgusting. Just nasty.

I'm probably a 1 or 2.

 

[jackal27]

3?

I think we're pretty vanilla tbh, but I'm surprised I learn that the wife and I are into stuff our friends aren't.

 

[nkarafo]

Wow, some of the stuff you guys are into is fuckin' disgusting. Just nasty.

I'm probably a 1 or 2.

Just a heads up, some posters like me only mention things that exist so we can have stuff to compare. how would we know what counts as a 10?

 

[disappeared]

Source Filmmaker is like my kryptonite right now. But mostly just like Overwatch stuff.

That's probably not even a fetish.

So like 2.

I nutted all over a girl's face once and that was awesome. She didn't have a gag reflex.

 

[Cyanity]

My go-to porn site is e621.net, so uh, 8 maybe? I'm awful

edit - people in here already mentioned furry porn as only being a 6 or so, so I guess I'm safe?

Some of the stuff I've seen though...definitely higher on that scale.

 

[NoblesseOblige]

My go-to porn site is e621.net, so uh, 8 maybe? I'm awful

I think that depends entirely on which tags you filter by, though by default it probably places you above a 3.

 

[Abstrusity]

Alright, guys and gals, I'm working on this scale. Intent plays a part in this, as well.

I am of the opinion that most things would be lower than 5. Grossness doesnt' really count.

After 5, we get into malicious intent sorts of things. Rape, force, etc.

Things that are present in fiction but cannot be achieved in real life would vary on intent, and thus, 5 is the consensual/nonconsensual line in the sand.

Can we agree on this?

 

[AnathemicOne]

Alright, guys and gals, I'm working on this scale. Intent plays a part in this, as well.

I am of the opinion that most things would be lower than 5. Grossness doesnt' really count.

After 5, we get into malicious intent sorts of things. Rape, force, etc.

Things that are present in fiction but cannot be achieved in real life would vary on intent, and thus, 5 is the consensual/nonconsensual line in the sand.

Can we agree on this?

Where would Consentacles be?

 

[nkarafo]

Alright, guys and gals, I'm working on this scale. Intent plays a part in this, as well.

I am of the opinion that most things would be lower than 5. Grossness doesnt' really count.

After 5, we get into malicious intent sorts of things. Rape, force, etc.

Things that are present in fiction but cannot be achieved in real life would vary on intent, and thus, 5 is the consensual/nonconsensual line in the sand.

Can we agree on this?

I think grossness counts as weird.

 

[Cyanity]

Alright, guys and gals, I'm working on this scale. Intent plays a part in this, as well.

I am of the opinion that most things would be lower than 5. Grossness doesnt' really count.

After 5, we get into malicious intent sorts of things. Rape, force, etc.

Things that are present in fiction but cannot be achieved in real life would vary on intent, and thus, 5 is the consensual/nonconsensual line in the sand.

Can we agree on this?

Where does Fox x Falco macro porn play into this

 

[DarkKyo]

Alright, guys and gals, I'm working on this scale. Intent plays a part in this, as well.

I am of the opinion that most things would be lower than 5. Grossness doesnt' really count.

After 5, we get into malicious intent sorts of things. Rape, force, etc.

Things that are present in fiction but cannot be achieved in real life would vary on intent, and thus, 5 is the consensual/nonconsensual line in the sand.

Can we agree on this?

Wtf, I don't agree with this at all. OP said weird, not rapey. 10 is merely SUPER WEIRD, not super non-consensual. Don't try to bring rape into a weird fetish thread please.

 

[jackal27]

Alright, guys and gals, I'm working on this scale. Intent plays a part in this, as well.

I am of the opinion that most things would be lower than 5. Grossness doesnt' really count.

After 5, we get into malicious intent sorts of things. Rape, force, etc.

Things that are present in fiction but cannot be achieved in real life would vary on intent, and thus, 5 is the consensual/nonconsensual line in the sand.

Can we agree on this?

Rape is not a fetish. It's not even sexual. It's oppressive violence, plain and simple.

 

[Snowybreak]

Where does Fox x Falco macro porn play into this

4, most likely 3

 

[Linkyn]

Alright, guys and gals, I'm working on this scale. Intent plays a part in this, as well.

I am of the opinion that most things would be lower than 5. Grossness doesnt' really count.

After 5, we get into malicious intent sorts of things. Rape, force, etc.

Things that are present in fiction but cannot be achieved in real life would vary on intent, and thus, 5 is the consensual/nonconsensual line in the sand.

Can we agree on this?

I disagree. You can get really out there without waving consent.

For instance, I'm open to just about anything (although I can't exactly predict how I'll end up responding to it), as long as it's consensual (even rape fantasies are a huge turn-off for me).

 

[Kisaya]

Apparently 2-3. I guess I'm pretty boring :|

 

[Gordon Shumway]

Isn't it subjective though? I'd say mine is short women way shorter/taller than me. I'd also say about 100/10.

 

[Abstrusity]

I would put it at a 2. Consent is present, and, assuming that the ...tentacle monster is capable of rational thought approaching a person, then it's just like fucking an alien.

However, it would be between 3 and 4 based on a few modifiers -- if the monster is not sentient beyond a beast, then it would be considered something akin to bestiality, in which case I'd peg it at a 3. If this is true, and the person purposely put themselves into the position with the intent of satisfying a fantasy, it is 4. Similarly so, if it is sentient and the second part of the previous is true, then it could be considered a 3.

Intent and a number of modifiers would change things.

So, crossdressing might be a 1 on the scale, but crossdressing with the intent of being caught is a 2. Being MADE to crossdress against your will, regardless of you liking it or not, would be a 5, and further modifiers based on the intent of the person forcing you would also increase (or decrease) that end result, with a minimum of 5 due to the "force" aspect.

 

[Corpsepyre]

I'd say a 1 or a 2. Nothing to it, really.

 

[supernormal]

I would put it at a 2. Consent is present, and, assuming that the ...tentacle monster is capable of rational thought approaching a person, then it's just like fucking an alien.

However, it would be between 3 and 4 based on a few modifiers -- if the monster is not sentient beyond a beast, then it would be considered something akin to bestiality, in which case I'd peg it at a 3. If this is true, and the person purposely put themselves into the position with the intent of satisfying a fantasy, it is 4. Similarly so, if it is sentient and the second part of the previous is true, then it could be considered a 3.

Intent and a number of modifiers would change things.

So, crossdressing might be a 1 on the scale, but crossdressing with the intent of being caught is a 2. Being MADE to crossdress against your will, regardless of you liking it or not, would be a 5, and further modifiers based on the intent of the person forcing you would also increase (or decrease) that end result, with a minimum of 5 due to the "force" aspect.

Fetishes are serious business.

 

[Wild Card]

I'd probably rate myself at a 6. I was into futa before everyone thought it was cool dammit.

Also where does armpit fetish count, I was thinking about it and it's not really any weirder than a foot fetish, just less common.

 

[Permanently A]

assuming 1 to be missionary with hand holding

and 10 to be illegal shit

I'd put myself at a solid 7

 

[Steel]

Where would a pain fetish rank I wonder? Like, not minding bleeding pain fetish. Probably pretty low going by some people's stuff here.

 

[Cyanity]

I would put it at a 2. Consent is present, and, assuming that the ...tentacle monster is capable of rational thought approaching a person, then it's just like fucking an alien.

However, it would be between 3 and 4 based on a few modifiers -- if the monster is not sentient beyond a beast, then it would be considered something akin to bestiality, in which case I'd peg it at a 3. If this is true, and the person purposely put themselves into the position with the intent of satisfying a fantasy, it is 4. Similarly so, if it is sentient and the second part of the previous is true, then it could be considered a 3.

Intent and a number of modifiers would change things.

So, crossdressing might be a 1 on the scale, but crossdressing with the intent of being caught is a 2. Being MADE to crossdress against your will, regardless of you liking it or not, would be a 5, and further modifiers based on the intent of the person forcing you would also increase (or decrease) that end result, with a minimum of 5 due to the "force" aspect.

I think we're getting a little too scientific here. One person's 3 is another person's 8 in the world of porn, so I can't see a person's sexual fetishes being easily lumped into some sort of quantifiable and constant scale like that.

 

[Abstrusity]

Fetishes are serious business.

Of course they are. The wide spectrum of something as common as sex ranges from what orifices used, to WHERE you use those orifices, to where you finish, what you wear, what you DON'T wear, HOW it's done, and etc.

And that's before you get into anything "weird" at all!

One must create a scale, lest the entire thread is people posting numbers that mean nothing, and we can't have THAT, can we? This discussion MUST be scientific!