[DF] Mortal Shell PS5 vs Xbox Series S/X
- Thread starter AnotherOne
- Start date
pasterpl
Member
Looking at vgtech stats and DF video
Xsx higher resolution (it is now becoming a trend)
both consoles are dropping frames
win for team green
for those saying that we should wait for patch, you mean same way as we did with dirt5
also werent screenshots from one section of hitman3 (where xsex dropped some frames) used to convince us it runs better on ps5
Xsx higher resolution (it is now becoming a trend)
both consoles are dropping frames
win for team green
for those saying that we should wait for patch, you mean same way as we did with dirt5
also werent screenshots from one section of hitman3 (where xsex dropped some frames) used to convince us it runs better on ps5
Stuart360
Member
Yep, some people take this stuff waaay too far.
Superayate
Member
59.96 vs 59.89, saying that's better performing...
Snake29
Banned
10 secs before your timestamp he says he encountered his first drops in fighting scenarios, then shows it. Why you cut that out?Once he opens the door, two enemies attack and the framerate drops to 50, while downstairs five or six more enemies are waiting, which is quite intense action for this game (if you played it at all). Later, he shows how XSX powers through the very same spot without any dip.
I didn't cut any shit out. It was the start of the drops and you said "it was dropping during intense fights", and thats false since nothing was happening during my timestamp. You can see the screenshot with some intens fight locked at 60fps.
Watch my timestamp again, what was so intens when he opent that door and killed that one enemy? On my screenshot you can see 3/4 enemies and a lot of particles while maintaining locked 60fps.
If you think i was trying to hide something lol, i just showed you the point where it's starts dropping.
Last edited:
ethomaz
Banned
Yeap if you ignore tearing, streaming, and framerate...
Last edited:
FatKingBallman
Banned
But XSX isn't 1440p.
PS5 performing better overall. DF didn't said that, but video shows it. Period! What, you need a DF to tell you what is better? LOL
VG Tech is very assiduous about details. This is why he provides far more informative framerate and resolution results than Digital Foundry.
Like i've said, we will see (hopefully) what will happen when resolution patch for PS5 arrive. For now, PS5 is better performing version
Last edited:
SoloKingRobert
Banned
The Framerate is a Streaming Texture bug on Xbox Series X, can be patched with more optimization. I can't say the same about PS5. VRR eliminates Screen Tearing on Xbox Series X.
Last edited:
Stuart360
Member
So no one going to answer my question?, or are you all too embarrassed that you are warring over a game that you dont even own?>
FatKingBallman
Banned
Everything is bug on XSX, even the tools :/
Yeah, but VRR doesn't fix framerate drops nor texture streaming
Last edited:
FatKingBallman
Banned
Another game at a higher resolution on Series X?
Ans another game with everything else worse on XSX?
Chessmate
Banned
Last edited:
pasterpl
Member
look at the vgtech frame rate stats
also how is it that issues with ps5 versions will be fixed with patches but you not even considering that bugs on xsex version will get fixed as well
Looks like an actual trend is emergingAnother game at a higher resolution on Series X?
SoloKingRobert
Banned
PS5 is the only console that drops frame rate during combat, high 40s, while Xbox Series X is stable.
Xbox Series X streaming texture bug doesn't affect gameplay.
FatKingBallman
Banned
PS5 has severe framerate drops at a much lower resolution than XSX. Bon appetit.
XSX has even more severe framerate drops with screen tearing and worse texture streaming. Enjoy your meal.
Epic Sax CEO
Banned
DF and the others should NOT released these comparisons when they already know that it's fucked and the developers and working on fixing the fucks. It's a waste of time.
FatKingBallman
Banned
VGTech tech is telling you what you've ignored
Physiognomonics
Member
It's for the clicks
SoloKingRobert
Banned
The PS5 version had severe Frame Rate drops to high 40s, while Xbox Series X was stable. Xbox Series X only dropped 1 or 2 frames. VRR eliminates Screen TearingXSX has even more severe framerate drops with screen tearing and worse texture streaming. Enjoy your meal.
Topher
Identifies as young
And no point in the video did they say the frame rate in combat on PS5 drops into the "high 40s".
Last edited:
FranXico
Member
Resolution ceiling difference was not intentional. Patches incoming.Another game at a higher resolution on Series X?
Snake29
Banned
Like i said before and where my timestamp started. The drops started when even nothing happened, and not "intense fights".
Last edited:
Werewolfgrandma
Banned
Love all the wait for patch to fix my broken version but your broken version is staying static. The saddest of fanboys you bunch are.
SoloKingRobert
Banned
Thanks for proving my point /s
Last edited:
Strider Highwind
Banned
So do any of you actually like the game? I donated to it's development when it was first announced by the team and I've ran through it a few times on PC.
I see y'all arguing in these threads and I always wonder do any of you actually play the games you get banned console warring over
And don't come at me, I'm not on either side i own both the ps5 and X + Switch and a very dope Rig lol
I see y'all arguing in these threads and I always wonder do any of you actually play the games you get banned console warring over
And don't come at me, I'm not on either side i own both the ps5 and X + Switch and a very dope Rig lol
Topher
Identifies as young
pasterpl
Member
Warring is a full time job, no time to play silly games /sSo do any of you actually like the game? I donated to it's development when it was first announced by the team and I've ran through it a few times on PC.
I see y'all arguing in these threads and I always wonder do any of you actually play the games you get banned console warring over
And don't come at me, I'm not on either side i own both the ps5 and X + Switch and a very dope Rig lol
Bernd Lauert
Banned
I beat the game on PC. It's pretty good for what it is.So do any of you actually like the game? I donated to it's development when it was first announced by the team and I've ran through it a few times on PC.
I see y'all arguing in these threads and I always wonder do any of you actually play the games you get banned console warring over
And don't come at me, I'm not on either side i own both the ps5 and X + Switch and a very dope Rig lol
Strider Highwind
Banned
It was a pretty good game for a Souls like type clone, much better than Lords of the Fallen lol. And
pasterpl
youre right, ...I read these threads like "do these folks even actually play some of this stuff?!"I know damn well nobody in that "Destroy all humans" thread even gave a damn about the game lol
Last edited:
Great Hair
Banned
Congratulations!
Concerned ExBox Suspects and their Fox pets are finally able to enjoy their victory in peace and with grace ...
Schmick
Member
There are already posts about a PS5 patch so why not for the XSX
Silent Viper
Banned
Why this thread so active? How many of you are really interested in this game?
Schmick
Member
I think there needs to be a specific place in NeoGaf where only non-fanboys can be part of. Accounts would have to be verified (somehow). But the fact is we keep seeing these threads with arguments on what performs better but not actually talking about the games themselves. The story, game mechanics etc etc...So do any of you actually like the game? I donated to it's development when it was first announced by the team and I've ran through it a few times on PC.
I see y'all arguing in these threads and I always wonder do any of you actually play the games you get banned console warring over
And don't come at me, I'm not on either side i own both the ps5 and X + Switch and a very dope Rig lol
FatKingBallman
Banned
PS5 didn't have any frame drops during combat nor screen tearing. LOL. That drop to 49-50 starts when he opened the door, not during fight. LOL
What else Xbox fan will use for excuse- tools, VRR.... Does DF, VGTech, NXG analyzing games with VRR? No. They analyze games how it is, in its pure form, not with some modern TV features because, guess what, the vast majority of gamers globally doesn't even have VRR TV. Using VRR is just excuse what you, Xbox fans, are often doing if some game on XSX doesn't outperm clearly the PS5 version. Same with "tools" crap. You, Xbox fans, just embarrassing yourself with excuses over and over
He actually proved how you were wrong.
Last edited:
Kuranghi
Member
I just want to know when Control will have its gamma fixed on PS5, DF said the devs are aware but I can't get a single response from Remedy or 505 through any channel I've tried. Is it even available from PS Plus anymore? Fuck, its probably too late anyway, oh well will just see it with RT when I get new PC this year instead.
FatKingBallman
Banned
Maybe they are waiting for better tools.
Iced Arcade
Member
We should just have a comparison thread where all these VS's head to heads can go in.
a big ol' jolly place where people can battle over games they won't play. people bring all the other previous games into the conversation anyway.
a big ol' jolly place where people can battle over games they won't play. people bring all the other previous games into the conversation anyway.
Last edited:
Elog
Member
Xbox brigade out in full force. PS5 stable 60 except when entering two areas in the game - ofc Riky posted those two - otherwise solid 60. XSX fluctuates much more when playing - not stable 60 FPS in the same way and texture loading issues with blurry textures that impacts gameplay.
Looks like a good PS5 version except the resolution that is locked at PS4Pro for some reason - we ofc need to see if those stable 60 are possible on the PS5 once the resolution is 1800p.
Looks like a good PS5 version except the resolution that is locked at PS4Pro for some reason - we ofc need to see if those stable 60 are possible on the PS5 once the resolution is 1800p.
Last edited:
Duchess
Member
According to How Long To Beat, it's 10-12 hours.
Good length, to be fair. Encourages repeat plays without getting too daunting at that length.
M1chl
Currently Gif and Meme Champion
longdi
Banned
Another game at a higher resolution on Series X?
seems like also slightly better fps, in the sanctum of flames level, DF mentioned SX holds 60fps while ps5 dips to 50fps.
I wonder how ps5 will perform when the higher res patch is out?
The other areas where SX fps dips, DF said it was because of level streaming bug. The player running through the levels, and the fps dips while things load.
Last edited:
FatKingBallman
Banned
That dip started during door opening, not during fight, though.
longdi
Banned
not just at the door opening, but a little more while the player moves about. i also saw ps5 drops tiny fps while in battle in the sanctum.
FatKingBallman
Banned
XSX version also has framerate drops in chamber area during fight ( before it starts running ) and also has a framerate drops during fight in Sanctum of Flames ( not so much like PS5 in that area, but it has it ). But of course, that doesn't matter for XSX. :/
Last edited: