Microsoft / Activision Deal Approval Watch |OT| (MS/ABK close)
- Status
bitbydeath
Gold Member
It's been done since the CMA first blocked it, IMO. Will be interesting to see if MS goes for another extension.
Bernardougf
Member
Cant imagine de degrees of delusion someone has to live in to think that THIS xbox administration is going to revive old games from ABK and improove its game output in any way shape or form ...
Schmick
Member
There won't be another extension after the most recent one. If the deal cannot be closed before 18th Oct then acquisition is dead.
MasterCornholio
Member
The only way I can see that happening if something goes wrong with the CMA. Which I doubt.
Zathalus
Member
Imagine being so far into console wars that you think the only reason people praise Persona 5 is that it came to Gamepass. It's not like it's one of the most acclaimed JRPGs ever made or anything. Metacritic actually ranks it as the highest rated JRPG of all time as well (Elden Ring rates higher but that's not really the same thing).
Personally it was the best game I played on my PS4, actually finished the OG and Royal twice.
Personally it was the best game I played on my PS4, actually finished the OG and Royal twice.
Ar¢tos
Member
It's hilarious to read posts saying that MS will bring back Space Quest or Quest for Glory just because they have such a good heart and good intentions! (Even if it means losing money because only a few dozen care about those games - I would love those games back, but I'm realistic)
bitbydeath
Gold Member
Something already has, now MS are trying to negotiate.
I think the best one could reasonably hope is add to BC the late 00 ID games that are unavailable right now.
I doubt MS will do much more than that this gen.
Last edited:
Solidus_T
Banned
Having a good heart is how they became a 2.5 trillion dollar corporation! Just like Apple and their good heart!
/s
Last edited:
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Now, some news, for a change and breaking the topic trend 
Full transcript from the CMC between MS, Activision, CAT.
Full transcript from the CMC between MS, Activision, CAT.
Nobody was saying Persona 5 isn't a good game or shouldn't be praised but the reason it's coming up in discussions 7 years later by people affiliated with xbox is for exactly that reason.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Now, some news, for a change and breaking the topic trend
Full transcript from the CMC between MS, Activision, CAT.
Thirty7ven
Banned
Persona 5 was a PlayStation exclusive. I know some people only play gamepass games, and some people have this weird attachment to Sega, but I believe it's ok to admit Persona 5 appeals to a very specific audience just like Final Fantasy XVI does.
The point is that you can't complain one has too many cutscenes when the other also has way too many cutscenes. And no, Persona 5 doesn't have better cutscenes lol
The point is that you can't complain one has too many cutscenes when the other also has way too many cutscenes. And no, Persona 5 doesn't have better cutscenes lol
Is there a reason fuck would be in there? was someone supposed to have said that during the hearing? If this is a joke wooosh, i'll go grab it from the wall behind one sec.
Exactly, especially as Persona 5 is one of the most cutscene heavy games released in existence.
You literally spend 45.15% of your playtime in cutscenes.
And before anybody gets the wrong idea again and thinks I'm saying this is bad or that I don't like Persona 5:
I love persona 5, enough to complete the game twice, 300+ hrs, reach level 90+, beat the twins and get the platinum trophy.
Zathalus
Member
It wasn't brought up by somebody affiliated with Xbox though. The conversation started with complaining about a pro Xbox podcaster. I simply jumped in to point out that in no measurable metric is FF16 the better game, while agreeing that it is perfectly fine to enjoy FF16 more.
It was brought up in an xbox podcasters show so how was it not brought up by somebody connected to xbox/gamepass? when I say affiliated I don't mean hired directly or a subsidiary.
The question is why are we making this comparison between these two games in the first place now? That's the question you should ask yourself. Then you can ask yourself if "too many cutscenes" is a valid criticism and should apply to one game and not to the other, which is far more cutscene heavy.
Last edited:
Zathalus
Member
It was brought up in this thread as an attempted "gotcha" moment against a Xbox podcaster. It's right there for you to read. I don't even know what video or podcaster is being discussed, I just jumped in to comment about the claim that FF16 is the better game compared to Persona 5, mostly because Persona 5 is one of my favourite games of all time.
But really, why care about the comparison being made? Both games are in the same genre and one was just recently released, doesn't seem odd to compare them.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Good question, we should ask the user who needlessly dragged both as a platform comparison in the first place.
Also.
Love it.
Last edited:
Punished Miku
Gaslighter Pro: 16.7 Fireflops
Just wait until Hellblade 2 starts getting trailers. I've already been told multiple times I'm a hypocrite if I end up liking it. I just need to stop engaging with that stuff, but it's hard sometimes.
Thirty7ven
Banned
It's like Yakuza, it's riddled with check marks, excessive cutscenes, it's third person, really wants to be cinematic, no customization, average mechanics, open world but it's always the same map, been around since 2005, 14 years before it came to Xbox… and now… you know where I'm going with this.
Listen MS buys Sega and gives Shenmue a reboot/remake full on budget, triple A and I'm buying the most expensive Xbox, the most expensive Xbox controller, the most expensive Gamepass subscription, I'll buy a t-shirt, shit I'll even… buy Halo Infinite deluxe or whatever it's called at full price. Fuck I'll buy Redfall.
Listen I'll go on X and start xing about #xgiving
Motherfucker I'll buy that pizza controller and eat it on live stream. I'll go viral.
Listen MS buys Sega and gives Shenmue a reboot/remake full on budget, triple A and I'm buying the most expensive Xbox, the most expensive Xbox controller, the most expensive Gamepass subscription, I'll buy a t-shirt, shit I'll even… buy Halo Infinite deluxe or whatever it's called at full price. Fuck I'll buy Redfall.
Listen I'll go on X and start xing about #xgiving
Motherfucker I'll buy that pizza controller and eat it on live stream. I'll go viral.
Last edited:
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
It's like Yakuza, it's riddled with check marks, excessive cutscenes, it's third person, really wants to be cinematic, no customization, average mechanics, open world but it's always the same map, been around since 2005, 14 years before it came to Xbox… and now… you know where I'm going with this.
Listen MS buys Sega and gives Shenmue a reboot/remake full on budget, triple A and I'm buying the most expensive Xbox, the most expensive Xbox controller, the most expensive Gamepass subscription, I'll buy a t-shirt, shit I'll even… buy Halo Infinite deluxe or whatever it's called at full price. Fuck I'll buy Redfall.
Listen I'll go on X and start xing about #xgiving
Motherfucker I'll buy that pizza controller and eat it on live stream. I'll go viral.
But Shenmue fucking sucks tho
Yakuza is already a superior Shenmue.
[/runs away]
Last edited:
Because that podcaster critiqued FF for having too many cutscenes yet wasn't critical of P5 for the exact same thing.
Which game is better to who is always subjective so I'm not here to say otherwise. For somebody who hates a game because of "too many cutscenes" though P5 shouldn't be the game they have a different opinion of unless that wasn't actually the real reason they didn't like the game. I think a lot of these comparisons come from brand association, that's all I'm saying. whether that's P5s recent release on gamepass or FF16 PS5 exclusivity. Not saying the comparison is invalid or anything.
Last edited:
kvltus lvlzvs
Member
Persona 5 rocks, and the "gameplay" parts of the game are the worst parts of the game. I just want to drink smoothies on Sundays, get good grades, hang out with my bros and flirt with the ladies. Boring 3 hour long dungeons dont do it for me too much, but they do serve to mix things up a bit.
Thirty7ven
Banned
But Shenmue fucking sucks tho
Yakuza is already a superior Shenmue.
Yakuza is nothing like Shenmue.
Punished Miku
Gaslighter Pro: 16.7 Fireflops
That's my guess. Personally, I do think Persona has too many cutscenes. I find it boring. But I have played visual novels before that are nothing but text "cutscenes." Maybe the dialogue in one grabbed him so the cutscenes didn't feel too frequent, and in the other game he didn't like the dialogue? Maybe it was the story? Maybe it was the setting? Maybe it was the pacing, or the action gameplay not gelling well with the passive cutscenes? I just find it easier to let people like what they like and assume they're not lying.
I actually didn't really realize who started it in this thread, but it was the same guy who said the same thing to me about Hellblade 2 lol. Very same person. What do I do? Do I explain that the game isn't even out yet, so I have never said I even like Hellblade 2? I never even hardly complimented the trailers and just said I want to see the gameplay and not cutscenes (people can check). Do I explain that I actually hated Hellblade 1? Do I explain that I liked multiple 3rd person cinematic games in the past (GoT, Spider Man 1, GoW2018, Days Gone, Uncharted 4, etc.)? No one wants to read this, and it just needlessly drags threads down. And that's if I even manage to successfully defend myself from the accusation that I'm a paid shill that can't be trusted. If not, then reputation damage and possible ban. Why not just ... let people like what they like and talk about games? Seems better for everyone.
Last edited:
mayham2199
Member
But Shenmue fucking sucks tho
Yakuza is already a superior Shenmue.
[/runs away]
Honestly I loved Shemnue but it's true. You could literally just remake the whole Shemnue story in the Yakuza world and you wouldn't know the difference.
Timberwolf25
Member
Does anyone have a TLDR of that pdf? Are we near the end of this?Now, some news, for a change and breaking the topic trend
Full transcript from the CMC between MS, Activision, CAT.
Bernardougf
Member
At least persona 5 is a proper persona game.. FFVXI is a devil may cry wannabe that dont achieve much outside been another mediocre action game
c'mon lets be friends ? 
bitbydeath
Gold Member
I'm reading through it still, so far:Does anyone have a TLDR of that pdf? Are we near the end of this?
MS have not yet provided a solution for CMA to consider.
Ginzeen
Banned
They already have. That's why it's pending review until August 29th.I'm reading through it still, so far:
MS have not yet provided a solution for CMA to consider.
bitbydeath
Gold Member
Here's what triggered CMA's re-involvement.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
This is a transcript of the CMC that happened around weeks ago, this is not new information.
CMA have since then said they will have a provisional draft ready by the 9th, meaning they have something to work with between then and now.
Last edited:
FoxMcChief
Gold Member
Let them have their false hope.
bitbydeath
Gold Member
This transcript shows theirs a two prong approach where they want CMA to close up the old deal and be presented with a new one which CMA may still reject if similar to the old one.
Last edited:
bitbydeath
Gold Member
New deal may involve divestment.
HoofHearted
Member
All of this is old news ... and has been actively re-hashed multiple times since the hearing ...
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
bitbydeath
Gold Member
It's new to me, I didn't know MS were considering divestment as an option and there has been a lot of misinformation going about here where people thought CMA are bending over for Microsoft or even that they've accepted a deal.
HoofHearted
Member
Clearly you haven't been paying attention to the thread - this was one of many news articles regarding divestiture options MS and CMA were discussing prior to the hearing:
PaintTinJr
Member
It is all still factually true, rather than based on people's memory until now, but I agree it is redundant info because the judge was given satisfaction behind close doors - no pun intended - meaning that the order summary was all that remains that didn't hit the cutting room floor, and without coverage of him reasoning what he received to agree to cancelling of the judicial review appeal, we have no read on where things stand, other than it looks like the CMA are fully bent over to ignore the three SLCs that arise from Microsoft gaining ownership of Activison/CoD.
bitbydeath
Gold Member
Thread moves too fast to keep up.Clearly you haven't been paying attention to the thread - this was one of many news articles regarding divestiture options MS and CMA were discussing prior to the hearing:
Ginzeen
Banned
Is that CAT judge still going to do the appeal?
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Last edited:
bitbydeath
Gold Member
The summary is that MS have offered a new deal to the CMA, if found similar to the old they will prohibit it by the end of August and the deal would be dead. CMA have only gotten involved again because they had too, not because they want too.
It could go either way, depending on what the new deal entails.
Ginzeen
Banned
Nah. It's highly likely to pass, but theirs still a chance for failure. Just a small one
bitbydeath
Gold Member
I wouldn't be so confident, the CMA aren't ones to be bought so the deal offered by MS would have to be really good/different for them to change their minds.Nah. It's highly likely to pass, but theirs still a chance for failure. Just a small one
PaintTinJr
Member
???
Ginzeen
Banned
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked