I think I've made my decision (maybe), I think I only wanted the Air because it is something different (last phone was a Razr Ultra flip phone, before that I think it was my Pixel 6 pro, before that Oppo Reno 2 (shark fin motorised pop up camera), in the past I have had Windows Phones, a Linux Phone (Motorola ROKR E6) and I had the original Neonode N1 phone (that thing was tiny))
But the sacrifices are just too much, battery life ain't great, performance is so-so, just the single camera, and that single speaker (the main issue for me), its more expensive than the base iPhone 17 yet has fewer features/lower performance/less battery life)
My main use is probably YouTube, whether that's watching videos or listening to music, I also use my phone for watching Netflix/Prime/Disney+ before going to sleep at night, so I don't play games too much so performance isnt a massive factor, I do take the odd photo here and there though.
So, I've decided (currently have about a week to pull the trigger), and my choice is going to be.......... Samsung S25 Ultra (Yes, I know, not an iPhone at all, but with EE they are currently have the S25 Ultra on contract for less than the base iPhone 17 AND you also get a free 14" Samsung Chromebook). The 17 Pro phones are just very ugly to me, the AIr has too many sacrifices and the base phone is, just, boring (and, again, I want to watch lots of video so larger screen required), the Samsung is also boring but its very powerful, has amazing cameras, decent battery life, large screen and (like almost every phone since 2016) stereo sound. I'm still debating the Air though dammit, but is 'different' enough