• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

PC Handelds - Fortnite and Steam

FudgeIt

FudgeIt

Member
I am checking the market for replacements for the Steam Deck OLED as I prefer to have a device that anti-cheat isn't a concern, I don't think I want to dual boot the Deck and just prefer to go with something that is a Windows based handheld for that price point of around $600. Is there anything out there that is worth getting that isn't a Steam Deck? What are some recommendations out there?
 
You can get the z1 extreme asus ROG first gen for pretty cheap these days. Would be fine for fortnite I would imagine. Screen is a downgrade from OLED steam deck though.
 
If you want to play Fortnite i'd recommend a Legion Go Gen 2 with the z2 Extreme, it's not cheap though, but the 32gb of LPDDR5X @8000MT/s is going to future proof you for the longest, the Z1 Extreme Rog Ally does ok for Fortnite but you do get hit with stutters, and big fps drops even when it seems to be holding 100/120hz pretty well for the most part (though i haven't played Fortnite on it for about a year now)
 
Tobimacoss said:
Xbox Ally is the obvious one, $489 on Amazon or Best buy often on sales. Or the Xbox Ally X if you can afford it.
Click to expand...

That xbox ally x is $1k isn't it? It seems like a waste of money especially if I like playing games on my ps5 pro for the most part. Xbox Ally might be worth it but I wonder if the screen size sucks or it's not that bad.
 
FudgeIt said:
That xbox ally x is $1k isn't it? It seems like a waste of money especially if I like playing games on my ps5 pro for the most part. Xbox Ally might be worth it but I wonder if the screen size sucks or it's not that bad.
Click to expand...
It's a decent IPS screen with 120hz and VRR.

One thing of note is that microSD slot is unreliable but you can always upgrade the SSD.

Edit: If you are playing around the house, can't you just get PS Portal? Or do you really need to play MP games while traveling?
 
Last edited:
Topher said:
The Z1 extreme Rog ally is the best value by far, imo. I would choose it over the Xbox version easily myself
Click to expand...

The first and cheaper one? Maybe I'll grab that for the price yeah.
StereoVsn said:
It's a decent IPS screen with 120hz and VRR.

One thing of note is that microSD slot is unreliable but you can always upgrade the SSD.

Edit: If you are playing around the house, can't you just get PS Portal? Or do you really need to play MP games while traveling?
Click to expand...

I tried the ps portal like 3-4 times. It's really bad in my house like awful. Too many disconnections!
 
Last edited:
I think the Xbox one is a good deal as well. Z1E would have gotten you a little more performance, but in a handheld I want ergonomics. It's got controller handles instead of just being a slab. It's not like the Z1 Extreme would have unlocked any games you just couldn't play on the Xbox one. It'll crush Fortnite, COD and Esports stuff.
 
Last edited:
FudgeIt said:
The first and cheaper one? Maybe I'll grab that for the price yeah.
Click to expand...

Between the Xbox version and the non-Xbox version of the Rog Ally (not X), the trade off is battery for performance. Xbox has a better battery. non-Xbox has better performance.

FudgeIt said:
That one isn't near me unfortunately. The non Xbox one. I just clicked it and it says not near me :/
Click to expand...

Dang. Looks like they sold out. Might try ebay
 
simpatico said:
I think the Xbox one is a good deal as well. Z1E would have gotten you a little more performance, but in a handheld I want ergonomics. It's got controller handles instead of just being a slab. It's not like the Z1 Extreme would have unlocked any games you just couldn't play on the Xbox one. It'll crush Fortnite, COD and Esports stuff.
Click to expand...

Battery is main advantage in my mind. You can buy a grip for the non-Xbox version that improves the ergonomics. I generally do that anyway just to provide protection.

Performance difference can be around 10 fps at times so yeah, depends on what types of games you are playing.
 
Topher said:
Battery is main advantage in my mind. You can buy a grip for the non-Xbox version that improves the ergonomics. I generally do that anyway just to provide protection.

Performance difference can be around 10 fps at times so yeah, depends on what types of games you are playing.
Click to expand...
I'd have to see the benchmarks. an extra 10 fps in an already well running game or is it "unlocking" games that are just beyond a regular Z2? My biggest gripe with my Steam Deck is the ergonomics. I should shop around for some bolt-on handles I guess.
 
simpatico said:
I'd have to see the benchmarks. an extra 10 fps in an already well running game or is it "unlocking" games that are just beyond a regular Z2? My biggest gripe with my Steam Deck is the ergonomics. I should shop around for some bolt-on handles I guess.
Click to expand...

For most games, I don't think the difference is between making a game playable or not. It's just something to be aware of if you are going to play more demanding games.

I did some benchmarking between the Z1 Extreme and the Z2 Go at various wattages. The Z2 Go is has four more GPU cores than the Z2 A so Rog Xbox Ally would not perform as well.

Topher

Thread 'Z2 Go vs Z1 Extreme Benchmarks (Legion Go S)'

Legion Go S Z2 Go version is on sale at Best Buy for $499. I got an open box for $475, like new. The Z2 Go came with Windows but I installed Steam OS

Here are the benchmarks using the built in benchmarks for Black Myth Wukong, Cyberpunk 2077 and Shadow of the Tomb Raider. Run them all with the same settings, varying only the TDP (Simple Decky TDP)

Considering I paid $775 for the Z1 Extreme, I'm pretty sure I'm returning it and keeping the Z2 Go. Just can't justify $300 more for 4-9fps


Here are the results:


ao94YKOPy4O8C2WB.png
<<<<<Steam...
  • Like
  • Triggered
  • Fire
  • LOL
  • Treasure
  • Love
 
Last edited:
FudgeIt said:
The first and cheaper one? Maybe I'll grab that for the price yeah.


I tried the ps portal like 3-4 times. It's really bad in my house like awful. Too many disconnections!
Click to expand...
If you have well defined WiFi System and Pro connected to the router (or repeater / mesh node) through Ethernet, this shouldn't be happening.

You may want to consider reviewing local network config first and trying Portal again.
 
Topher said:
For most games, I don't think the difference is between making a game playable or not. It's just something to be aware of if you are going to play more demanding games.

I did some benchmarking between the Z1 Extreme and the Z2 Go at various wattages. The Z2 Go is has four more GPU cores than the Z2 A so Rog Xbox Ally would not perform as well.

Topher

Thread 'Z2 Go vs Z1 Extreme Benchmarks (Legion Go S)'

Legion Go S Z2 Go version is on sale at Best Buy for $499. I got an open box for $475, like new. The Z2 Go came with Windows but I installed Steam OS

Here are the benchmarks using the built in benchmarks for Black Myth Wukong, Cyberpunk 2077 and Shadow of the Tomb Raider. Run them all with the same settings, varying only the TDP (Simple Decky TDP)

Considering I paid $775 for the Z1 Extreme, I'm pretty sure I'm returning it and keeping the Z2 Go. Just can't justify $300 more for 4-9fps


Here are the results:


ao94YKOPy4O8C2WB.png
<<<<<Steam...
  • Like
  • Triggered
  • Fire
  • LOL
  • Treasure
  • Love
Click to expand...
Realistically Z1E may make some games a bit more playable at around 20W. 40FPS is a much better proposition vs low 30s. Or it may allow you to lock 30 frames vs uneven performance.

That said, it really depends on pricing.
 
StereoVsn said:
Realistically Z1E may make some games a bit more playable at around 20W. 40FPS is a much better proposition vs low 30s. Or it may allow you to lock 30 frames vs uneven performance.

That said, it really depends on pricing.
Click to expand...

Yeah, at that price point, you are going to have to trade off something. Sucks we don't have more options as the sub $600 market gets more harder to find a good option. Rog Xbox Ally is all that's available and it is literally shrinkflation in handheld form. Really shitty.

Open box or ebay is your best best. Speaking of....

FudgeIt FudgeIt Check and see if you have any Lenovo Go S Z2 Go in your area. That may be a good alternative. Better performance than Rog Xbox Ally. 55wh vs 60wh so battery difference is neglible. Still not as powerful as Rog Ally, but still.....a decent option.

 
StereoVsn said:
If you have well defined WiFi System and Pro connected to the router (or repeater / mesh node) through Ethernet, this shouldn't be happening.

You may want to consider reviewing local network config first and trying Portal again.
Click to expand...

What do you mean defined WiFi system? the modem is in the garage and Optimum came to my house to put an extender which I hardwired my ps5 pro into. I also have a google mesh system (prior to the extender) that I had hard-wired to but apparently Optimum told me that this one was WIfi 6 or the one below the highest and would cap out at 500mb instead of the 1gb that I have with Optimum so he told me to use the extender. It was terrible.

I don't know what else to really do, as I have gotten no help from Optimum :(
 
Topher said:
Yeah, at that price point, you are going to have to trade off something. Sucks we don't have more options as the sub $600 market gets more harder to find a good option. Rog Xbox Ally is all that's available and it is literally shrinkflation in handheld form. Really shitty.

Open box or ebay is your best best. Speaking of....

FudgeIt FudgeIt Check and see if you have any Lenovo Go S Z2 Go in your area. That may be a good alternative. Better performance than Rog Xbox Ally. 55wh vs 60wh so battery difference is neglible. Still not as powerful as Rog Ally, but still.....a decent option.

Click to expand...

this lenovo looks good but it's a Steam OS, I don't think I can play fortnite or games required anticheat unless I dualboot (which I don't know if I want to do) or xcloud, which screw streaming right now?
 
FudgeIt said:
this lenovo looks good but it's a Steam OS, I don't think I can play fortnite or games required anticheat unless I dualboot (which I don't know if I want to do) or xcloud, which screw streaming right now?
Click to expand...

You can just erase the Steam OS partition and install Windows if you want. There is a Windows version of the same handheld so you can just download the drivers from Lenovo.

 
I had looked into this before. This is a summary of what I found.
  • The regular ROG Xbox Ally is shit. Not worth considering.
  • The ROG Ally X non-Xbox is great, but oddly hard to find for a reasonable price. I often saw it close enough to the Xbox version to make the upgrade worth it, IMO. If you can find it for <$600, though, that's a different story.
  • The ROG Ally Z1E is a solid pick when on discount, but you really need to budget for a battery upgrade unless you plan on being tethered. There are kits available that simplify the install.
  • The Legion Go S is quite good and might be a good choice when on sale.
  • Many of the Windows handhelds are basically dog shit, even if the specs on paper are better than the Steam Deck. They often have bad software, mediocre battery life, or some other combination of issues that make them a non-starter.
  • The Windows handheld experience is not great and nowhere close to being as easy as SteamOS. Microsoft fundamentally has no idea what it's doing in this space and it shows.
 
evanft said:
I had looked into this before. This is a summary of what I found.
  • The regular ROG Xbox Ally is shit. Not worth considering.
  • The ROG Ally X non-Xbox is great, but oddly hard to find for a reasonable price. I often saw it close enough to the Xbox version to make the upgrade worth it, IMO. If you can find it for <$600, though, that's a different story.
  • The ROG Ally Z1E is a solid pick when on discount, but you really need to budget for a battery upgrade unless you plan on being tethered. There are kits available that simplify the install.
  • The Legion Go S is quite good and might be a good choice when on sale.
  • Many of the Windows handhelds are basically dog shit, even if the specs on paper are better than the Steam Deck. They often have bad software, mediocre battery life, or some other combination of issues that make them a non-starter.
  • The Windows handheld experience is not great and nowhere close to being as easy as SteamOS. Microsoft fundamentally has no idea what it's doing in this space and it shows.
Click to expand...

I agree with this
 
evanft said:
I had looked into this before. This is a summary of what I found.
  • The regular ROG Xbox Ally is shit. Not worth considering.
  • The ROG Ally X non-Xbox is great, but oddly hard to find for a reasonable price. I often saw it close enough to the Xbox version to make the upgrade worth it, IMO. If you can find it for <$600, though, that's a different story.
  • The ROG Ally Z1E is a solid pick when on discount, but you really need to budget for a battery upgrade unless you plan on being tethered. There are kits available that simplify the install.
  • The Legion Go S is quite good and might be a good choice when on sale.
  • Many of the Windows handhelds are basically dog shit, even if the specs on paper are better than the Steam Deck. They often have bad software, mediocre battery life, or some other combination of issues that make them a non-starter.
  • The Windows handheld experience is not great and nowhere close to being as easy as SteamOS. Microsoft fundamentally has no idea what it's doing in this space and it shows.
Click to expand...

I swear I'm just so close to getting a ps portal and figuring out my issues and also getting a switch 2. I'm so conflicted!
 
simpatico said:
I think the Xbox one is a good deal as well. Z1E would have gotten you a little more performance, but in a handheld I want ergonomics. It's got controller handles instead of just being a slab. It's not like the Z1 Extreme would have unlocked any games you just couldn't play on the Xbox one. It'll crush Fortnite, COD and Esports stuff.
Click to expand...
The white Xbox Ally also makes for the best streaming handhelds.
 
I can't tell if I'm an idiot or not. I feel like I made ecosystems so complicated. I love my ps5 pro, wish there was a damn handheld that downloaded shit. Damn you Sony!!!
 
I bought 2 months used MSI claw A7+ ( same processor as 8 AI lunar lake. With 1 tb upgraded in it for 430$ US. Not really sure why I bought it but I can play my PC games on it when I am far from the PC and it's really powerful ( same as extreme Z2 ) . Great device really
 
Topher said:
Another option is installing Windows on your Steam Deck

help.steampowered.com

Steam Support :: Steam Deck - Windows Resources

help.steampowered.com help.steampowered.com



Why?
Click to expand...
1080p 120 hz screen with VRR. Nvidia GFN can take full advantage of it at 1080/120 GFN Ultimate tier.

Streaming increases battery life by three fold. And most importantly, the device is more comfortable to hold, and D-Brand worked with Asus and MS to make a case that is perfect fit, the KillSwitch. The case adds even better grip.



dbrand.com

ROG Xbox Ally X Cases » Killswitch » dbrand

Shop dbrand’s premium ROG Xbox Ally X cases. Impact-resistant protection, ergonomic grip, and super customizable. Buy the best ROG Xbox Ally X case.
dbrand.com dbrand.com
 
evanft said:
  • The Windows handheld experience is not great and nowhere close to being as easy as SteamOS. Microsoft fundamentally has no idea what it's doing in this space and it shows.
Click to expand...
Yeah.
I installed Playnite on ROG Xbox Ally X after 1 hour of using Xbox App. Worked great! I don't care about Fortnite but having Gamepass is important for me. Bad pic but the menu can be customized to be a ton better than Xbox App, booting right into this, no Windows unless you want to fiddle with settings.

dWxQ5giKQJ9uFQRd.jpeg


Unfortunately my device had an A button that occasionally got stuck when pressing it (not uncommon on non-Xbox devices going by some googling) so I sent it back and asked for a refund.
 
Fess said:
Yeah.
I installed Playnite on ROG Xbox Ally X after 1 hour of using Xbox App. Worked great! I don't care about Fortnite but having Gamepass is important for me. Bad pic but the menu can be customized to be a ton better than Xbox App, booting right into this, no Windows unless you want to fiddle with settings.

dWxQ5giKQJ9uFQRd.jpeg


Unfortunately my device had an A button that occasionally got stuck when pressing it (not uncommon on non-Xbox devices going by some googling) so I sent it back and asked for a refund.
Click to expand...
Xbox Full Screen Experience isn't in its final form. It's just a placeholder.

It will eventually align with the new Cloud Gaming experience being tested.



 
Tobimacoss said:
Xbox Full Screen Experience isn't in its final form. It's just a placeholder.

It will eventually align with the new Cloud Gaming experience being tested.



Click to expand...

I know but that doesn't help right now. Today it's incredibly bad compared to Playnite. Or SteamOS game mode.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

"The Office" 's Michael Scott and Dwight Schrute Coming to Fortnite
2
59
369
Tomorrow replied
What is going on with Fortnite
41
535
NeoIkaruGAF replied
[Thurott] Fortnite is Coming to the Xbox App on PC With Xbox Play Anywhere Support
2
94
2K
kevboard replied
Steam Frame, Steam controller and Steam Machine Revealed
19 20 21 22 23
1K
5K
Hero of Spielberg replied
Fortnite x South Park Collab | 9th Jan
19
419
kevboard replied
Top Bottom