Margaret Thatcher has died

Status
Not open for further replies.
We were talking specifically about the guy who claimed he had £53 per week to live on to Ian Duncan Smith and he challenged him to live on the same?

What on earth are you on about?
I was only speaking on your assertion your bills are paid and then you are given 53 ontop of that.

I've stated as much every bloody time. It's clear you are being obtuse on purpose. And I am done this time.
 
I find feisting on the blood of dead people abhorrent, but I'm not surprised by the reactions. End of comment
 
Jesus Christ, people. A senile old lady has died, what more do you want? Disagreeing with her political history is all well and good, but the bile and hatred in this thread is quite distasteful to say the least. I expected more from GAFfers, I really did.
 
I was only speaking on your assertion your bills are paid and then you are given 53 ontop of that.

I've stated as much every bloody time. It's clear you are being obtuse on purpose. And I am done this time.

How did you manage to grasp that nugget of complete reading miscomprehension from what I actually typed?

I'll try again in plain English.

The guys works, and claims he only receives £2700pa from his employment.

He also receives housing benefit.

His housing benefit was cut, so he rang up saying he'll have £53 per week to live on after the cut and challenged IDS to do the same.

He got investigated, turns out he likes gambling, has sky tv, with broadband and a mobile..... I then said he was lying.
 
Jesus Christ, people. A senile old lady has died, what more do you want? Disagreeing with her political history is all well and good, but the bile and hatred in this thread is quite distasteful to say the least. I expected more from GAFfers, I really did.

The fact she's been senile and old for a while doesn't detract from the pain she caused when she was younger and not senile
 
How long did the repayment of discounts apply?

We had a massive property price boom around 97-99 which stuff literally tripled in price over a short space of time, I would imagine a lot cashed in to the buy to let guys who were buying houses on 110% mortgages and cashing in further...... I bought a place around 98 for £35k which I sold in 2005 for £110,000.

It was my first house and I was very lucky I guess, obviously the new place I bought was also exponentially higher, but I had a large deposit (On paper.) which meant I could get a better mortgage rate which I still have. 1.25% is the rate I'm currently paying thanks to my lifetime tracker mortgage.
The discount only had to be repaid until the minimum period of 5 years had elapsed, then it could be sold at market rate and a healthy profit so over the years the houses got sold as the buyers and their descendants cashed in. Since you're talking about an Act put in place in the 1980 and not significantly changed until 1997 (when Labour significantly reduced the discount which led to a bit of a housing bubble but that's a different story), that's 17 years of the housing stock getting depleted moving into private hands, and 33 years of houses bought on the cheap moving into the private market.
I guess what I'm getting at is, how do you prevent people from selling their own houses? Landlords couldn't acquire properties that weren't willingly sold. They didn't buy them directly from the council at a discounted rate, they brought them from private sellers at a price that 'the market' felt was perfectly fair.

I'm swamped with work at the moment so I'm probably overlooking some huge and obvious loophole or predatory acquisition or something. I'll do some more reading later on.
 
Cremation? So there goes the hopes of thousands that were planning on vandalising her grave

I wouldn't be surprised if that was a factor in it. However, it does appear that Thatcher herself had a significant amount of influence over her own funeral (St Paul's rather than Westminster Abbey is by her request for example), so perhaps she wanted to avoid that circumstance.
 
Jesus Christ, people. A senile old lady has died, what more do you want? Disagreeing with her political history is all well and good, but the bile and hatred in this thread is quite distasteful to say the least. I expected more from GAFfers, I really did.

Anyone honestly surprised by the reaction is simply ignorant of the history surrounding the subject. Whoever you vote for and whatever you think of the reaction is irrelevant. Being surprised, though, really is odd.
 
Hardly special, the current RN is half the size it was after the Falklands thanks to fairly brutal budget cuts.

We are now down to 6 destroyers. woop.

It's a bit different, though. Our Navy is far smaller than it used to be, but when the new Carriers come online, it'll be a much more effective fighting force than it was in 82. Between the Type 45's and the Eurofighters in Ascension, I think the decline of the RN back then was fairly "special" (insomuch as it's not really the case, now).
 
Well, I'm certainly not as happy as some people are about her death, but neither am I particularly sorry of care about it either.

This woman destroyed large parts of the country, she ruined the rail system and made it one of the worst and overprices in Europe, handed over our utilities to private companies, she destroyed entire towns and cities during the Mining strike which was the genesis of people living off benefits which resulted in far less social mobility, she also presided over a deregulation of the financial sector and we all know what happened there.

Essentially, we're still paying for all her mistakes. Generations of families stuck of benefits, all of which can undoubtedly be traced back to the late 80's/early 90's, a terrible rail system that is both antiquated and disgustingly overpriced and a financial sector that almost brought our country to its knees.

The only thing she didn't destroy was the NHS, but worry not, good ol' Cameron has that covered. Baseless cunt that he is.
 
Her dying doesn't suddenly wipe away everything that she did. I won't celebrate her death, but I sure as hell am not going to celebrate her life, nor am I going to blast those who do. She was a vile woman, with horrible policies which affected the lives of thousands.
 
Anyone honestly surprised by the reaction is simply ignorant of the history surrounding the subject. Whoever you vote for and whatever you think of the reaction is irrelevant. Being surprised, though, really is odd.

So I'm ignorant of the history, am I? I fucking lived through it all and have very vivid memories. It doesn't excuse dancing on graves.

Where were all your posts complaining about her policies when she was alive? A lot of people celebrated when she left politics. Celebrating her death is fucking ghoulish.
 
There's also a lot of "As a Northerner/Irishman/Welshman/Scouser/Chilean Opposition Member" etc in this thread. Seems like a line of faux-authenticity that doesn't fly in any arena other than Thatcher bashing.

As someone born and raised in the US who has no stake in this whatsoever (no "regional bias"), you seem to be waving away the criticisms of those who don't like her and attributing that to "regional bias." From what I've read in this thread and elsewhere, if she ravaged communities as much as she did (despite how necessary these actions were), if she didn't supply some level of means to help these communities get back on their feet, she deserves some amount of hatred.
 
For those unaware, she's the Reagan of Britain. Except the majority of Brits don't like her for what she has done, whereas its the exact opposite with Reagan in the US.

So how is this a controversial perception that risks getting someone banned? I'm not understanding why everyone is so scared to talk about her policies...

It's because they want to say some sexist shit that's irrelevant to her politics, isn't it
 
So I'm ignorant of the history, am I? I fucking lived through it all and have very vivid memories. It doesn't excuse dancing on graves.

Where were all your posts complaining about her policies when she was alive? A lot of people celebrated when she left politics. Celebrating her death is fucking ghoulish.

Living under a rock? People have been condemning her policies for years. It's impossible to have the missed the various complaints levelled against her and her policies.
 
Perhaps there should have been seperate threads, one for people to RIP, and one for people to let rip.
 
There are plenty of people in the U.S. who have the same (lack of) regard for Reagan as Britons do for Thatcher. The actual difference is that the people who like Reagan go apeshit for him, while Thatcher fans seem somewhat more reserved and realistic.
 
Jesus Christ, people. A senile old lady has died, what more do you want? Disagreeing with her political history is all well and good, but the bile and hatred in this thread is quite distasteful to say the least. I expected more from GAFfers, I really did.

Nothing wrong with celebrating a person's death. Plenty of people deserve to die.

What is interesting I think is to see how many here celebrating Thatcher's death were complaining of people celebrating the death of chavez or bin laden or saddam etc... Plenty, probably.
 
How did you manage to grasp that nugget of complete reading miscomprehension from what I actually typed?

I'll try again in plain English.

The guys works, and claims he only receives £2700pa from his employment.

He also receives housing benefit.

His housing benefit was cut, so he rang up saying he'll have £53 per week to live on after the cut and challenged IDS to do the same.

He got investigated, turns out he likes gambling, has sky tv, with broadband and a mobile..... I then said he was lying.


The £53 a week does not include things such as housing benefit which you can apply for extra.

The £53 a week figure is what the guy is left with after rent and bills....
.

EDIT And it isn't it's the lowest amount of JSA you can get (under 25 no dependants)
 
So how is this a controversial perception that risks getting someone banned? I'm not understanding why everyone is so scared to talk about her policies...

It's because they want to say some sexist shit that's irrelevant to her politics, isn't it

It's because of the sheer hatred they have of her, the language they would have to use to describe her would get them banned. It's nothing to do with sexism, its just if they didn't keep their emotions in check, what they would say would seem grossly offensive.

Its easy to underestimate how much hate Thatcher does receive, and justifiably so in some senses.
 
I guess what I'm getting at is, how do you prevent people from selling their own houses? Landlords couldn't acquire properties that weren't willingly sold. They didn't buy them directly from the council at a discounted rate, they brought them from private sellers at a price that 'the market' felt was perfectly fair.

I'm swamped with work at the moment so I'm probably overlooking some huge and obvious loophole or predatory acquisition or something. I'll do some more reading later on.

You can't really, I bet a lot sold after the boom, took massive profit, then went back to renting.
 
Her politics were objectionable, but she was a bold and commanding leader, I have some respect for her purely based on those things. I can't say I think this is some sort of dark occasion, I won't be taking to the streets hammering bin lids or anything. I might finally watch The Iron Lady though.
 
Living under a rock? People have been condemning her policies for years. It's impossible to have the missed the various complaints levelled against her and her policies.

You missed my point. I'm totally aware of how Thatcher is generally viewed by Joe Public in the UK, and how a lot of her policies have been widely condemned. But she's been inactive and ineffective for many, many years now. Her death doesn't change anything. It's not like a current dictator has just been deposed.
 
You missed my point. I'm totally aware of how Thatcher is generally viewed by Joe Public in the UK, and how a lot of her policies have been widely condemned. But she's been inactive and ineffective for many, many years now. Her death doesn't change anything. It's not like a current dictator has just been deposed.

But her death just brings the subject into the public consciousness again. If you'd specifically asked Joe Public what he thought of Thatcher on Sunday he would have said the same thing.
 
I guess what I'm getting at is, how do you prevent people from selling their own houses? Landlords couldn't acquire properties that weren't willingly sold. They didn't buy them directly from the council at a discounted rate, they brought them from private sellers at a price that 'the market' felt was perfectly fair.

I'm swamped with work at the moment so I'm probably overlooking some huge and obvious loophole or predatory acquisition or something. I'll do some more reading later on.

You can't. I know a couple of people (friends of my late parents) who bought cheap council homes in the 80's/early 90's and are now making a killing by renting them back to councils. They are eagerly awaiting the next big sell off. It's an incredible money maker.

Another failure of Maggie's, soon to made much, much worse by the baseless cunt PM we have now.
 
But her death just brings the subject into the public consciousness again. If you'd specifically asked Joe Public what he thought of Thatcher on Sunday he would have said the same thing.

It also can't help that british media seems to be glorifying her, when she was a really awful person.
 
You missed my point. I'm totally aware of how Thatcher is generally viewed by Joe Public in the UK, and how a lot of her policies have been widely condemned. But she's been inactive and ineffective for many, many years now. Her death doesn't change anything. It's not like a current dictator has just been deposed.

But her death just brings the subject into the public consciousness again. If you'd specifically asked Joe Public what he thought of Thatcher on Sunday he would have said the same thing.

Pretty much.
 
So, I heard Man United and Man City are playing a Derby tonight...

I can totally see there being an impromtu minute's silence and the Northern fans kicking off about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom