• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

GTA V has gone gold.

I love IV myself but I wouldn't call it the best GTA game. I still say San Andreas holds that title. I think V will blow them both away. But there were things that I really loved in IV that were inevitable to come to the series anyway. Like a cover system. I was so excited to see that introduced. Physics. NPCs reacting realistically to bullet hits among other things. And all the little details like the way tires get blown out, doing a donut long enough would even burn out your tires, flying out the windshield during hard crashes, bullet cracks in the windshield, the explosions at the time, all the little things that increase the immersiveness and improve the action. It's only going to be improved in V.
 
The things that GTAIV dropped from San Andreas (and the stupid justification for dropping them) used to bother me, disappointed me really. But, since replaying it, the things that really bother me are mission variety. The mission variety is terrible in IV, almost every mission is the same action by the user, and the few that don't still end up being reduced to something much simpler.

GTAIV has less mission variety than San Andreas and Vice City for sure, but I'm even willing to go out and say that IV has less variety than GTAIII. I've been shocked at how bland the missions are, that even the good ones -- the ones that I remember fondly -- aren't as good.

Raptomex said:
I love IV myself but I wouldn't call it the best GTA game. I still say San Andreas holds that title. I think V will blow them both away. But there were things that I really loved in IV that were inevitable to come to the series anyway. Like a cover system. I was so excited to see that introduced. Physics. NPCs reacting realistically to bullet hits among other things. And all the little details like the way tires get blown out, doing a donut long enough would even burn out your tires, flying out the windshield during hard crashes, bullet cracks in the windshield, the explosions at the time, all the little things that increase the immersiveness and improve the action. It's only going to be improved in V.
Click to expand...

THis is pretty similar to how I feel. I feel like the things that were obvious improvements in IV over San Andreas, like firing mechanics, cover, physics, and so on, are things that advanced along side the rest of the gaming industry. The physics in IV are very impressive, but for me, those technological leaps wear off quicker than good mission variety and a lot of things to interact with in the world.
 
GTA IV was the biggest heartbreaker for me this gen easy. I put collectively probably 300 hours into GTA 3/Vice City/San Andreas. Not even 30 hours into GTA IV and I had a lot less fun doing it. Overrated is hard to judge, but it's far and away the biggest disappointment.
 
Neuromancer said:
I did not like Niko as a character; I did not like the story; there were a few good characters (Little Jacob, Brucie) but many more uninteresting or unlikeable ones; lack of mid-mission checkpoints was unforgiveable; too many missions devolved into shooting hordes of dudes (a complaint I have with many games); chase sequences were overly scripted so you couldn't actually catch people until the game let you; Liberty City was uninteresting and not much fun to explore; bottom line is I did not enjoy playing the game after the first few hours and that's a major problem for me. That said I can see why people might have liked it, that's all subjective after all. And I don't need every game to be Saints Row crazy either, there's a happier middle ground somewhere.
Click to expand...

I know we have talked about it before; just didn't think it was on the level of a 5 at all. As for the game not letting you catch people until they wanted you to; I have shown a few different times some missions where you could do interesting things to stop a chase, but I get it. The scripted sequences were actually fun for me, as they weren't scripted just to be scripted. Be it a cop road block, a ramp to hit, a line of dialogue to hear..it all was done for a reason.
 
Marleyman said:
How do you explain myself and many others around here who think it is the best GTA? For me and others those polls mean dick; that is what some just don't get.
Click to expand...

Yours is as an individual voice. You're entitled to your opinion, but I'm talking about the consensus surrounding the series as a whole. Recent history hasn't been as kind to IV as it has certain installments that precede it.
 
The fact that Gay Tony is the last GTA-related product that they made makes me hyped for 5. It seemed like they really found their groove this gen with that expansion. I want everything about that to carry over into GTA5. From the characters to the fantastic mission variety (something GTA4 and TLaD lacked).
 
Acquiescence said:
Yours is as an individual voice. You're entitled to your opinion, but I'm talking about the consensus surrounding the series as a whole. Recent history hasn't been as kind to IV as it has certain installments that precede it.
Click to expand...

Sorry, but using the term consensus in this sense would give the advantage to myself, not your opinion of it being "the most overrated game of the generation." That is FAR from the consensus and is the exact opposite.
 
The Albatross said:
The things that GTAIV dropped from San Andreas (and the stupid justification for dropping them) used to bother me, disappointed me really. But, since replaying it, the things that really bother me are mission variety. The mission variety is terrible in IV, almost every mission is the same action by the user, and the few that don't still end up being reduced to something much simpler.

GTAIV has less mission variety than San Andreas and Vice City for sure, but I'm even willing to go out and say that IV has less variety than GTAIII. I've been shocked at how bland the missions are, that even the good ones -- the ones that I remember fondly -- aren't as good.
Click to expand...
Yeah, that was the problem. Missing features. But me personally, in each GTA game I've always completed the game 100% then just did random shit, causing chaos. Even the features in SA were cool but nothing to keep me coming back ALL THE TIME. Like truck deliveries, you just drive from one location to another with cops chasing you. It's not like VCS where they added drug dealing and made it relatively in depth. Sometimes there's shootouts or ripoffs. They attempted adding gang wars in TLAD and Drug Wars in TBoGT which were all pretty much the same as vigilante missions in IV. You drive to a location, with allies in the DLC, and blow everyone away. It's cool but all the same. Also, in TLAD your gang members can level up if they survive but at high levels they all die anyway, it needed work. Hopefully the crew thing in V really improves on this. Another problem I had with those missions in IV was, you can do 50 of them and they will always take you to the same 5 or 6 locations. It's a huge city and they only allow these missions to take you to the same 5 or 6 spots. They should somehow randomize locations so it's more immersive. And add more variety then just drive here, kill everyone.

I've been playing IV recently as well and yeah, many of the missions are similar. Drive here, take this guy/these guys out. I don't really have a huge problem with it because I love shooting missions but compared to SA there were no really memorable missions. Three Leaf Clover was great but if you really think about it, it's almost the same as the others with more people to shoot. Still, it was epic. I think even Houser said he wants V to have more missions like that. With this heist stuff, there's no doubt they will be more in depth.
 
Marleyman said:
Sorry, but using the term consensus in this sense would give the advantage to myself, not your opinion of it being "the most overrated game of the generation." That is FAR from the consensus and is the exact opposite.
Click to expand...

I think GTAIV was a good game, but I think he's right -- it is an easy contender for most over-rated game of this generation.

The last thread to talk about Over rated games was this one:

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=650235&highlight=most+over+rated

not only is GTAIV obviously one of the main games in the article, but it's mentioned a lot in posts. I'd wager if we started a "Most over-rated games from this generation," GTAIV would be one of the contenders on the list. I wouldn't put it at most over-rated (that is a special place in hell for me -- Uncharted 3), but it'd be on my top 5, and probably a lot of other people's.
 
The Albatross said:
I think GTAIV was a good game, but I think he's right -- it is an easy contender for most over-rated game of this generation.

The last thread to talk about Over rated games was this one:

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=650235&highlight=most+over+rated

not only is GTAIV obviously one of the main games in the article, but it's mentioned a lot in posts. I'd wager if we started a "Most over-rated games from this generation," GTAIV would be one of the contenders on the list. I wouldn't put it at most over-rated (that is a special place in hell for me -- Uncharted 3), but it'd be on my top 5, and probably a lot of other people's.
Click to expand...

It is on here, no doubt about it. I just don't see how a game that still gets a bunch of play 5 years later is so overrated. I get the criticisms of the game, trust me..I don't get how it is that overrated.
 
Marleyman said:
Sorry, but using the term consensus in this sense would give the advantage to myself, not your opinion of it being "the most overrated game of the generation." That is FAR from the consensus and is the exact opposite.
Click to expand...

Look at the sentence you quoted...

Acquiescence said:
It's a game full to the brim with flaws . You look at polls and read threads about the GTA series in general and it's easy to see more fans favour Vice City and San Andreas than they do IV.
Click to expand...

Where did I mention that GTA IV being "the most overrated game of the generation" is the consensus? I didn't. The consensus of how the GTA series as a whole is perceived is what I'm talking about.
 
Acquiescence said:
Look at the sentence you quoted...



Where did I mention that GTA IV being "the most overrated game of the generation" is the consensus? I didn't. The consensus of how the GTA series as a whole is perceived is what I'm talking about.
Click to expand...

If you didn't I apologize; I thought that was what you were referring to when you mentioned consensus.
 
I just know someone is going to give it a 6.5 to get clicks. Will probably be criticized for "lack of focus", lol
 
I think if you maybe weigh up GTAIV with the DLC packs it improves it a bit but it was a bit poor compared to San Andreas due to a lack of content and scale.
From what we know of GTAV it looks like it's going to give us a real reminder of SA in terms of that scale and exploration of the map along with all the detail in the game.
GTAIV seemed a bit bland at times. I didn't feel a great urge to explore as I did before. In fact in the earlier GTA games I used to get in a car and try and explore as much as I could right away. I'd try and find ways to cross the barricaded bridges and tunnels. I remember in GTA3, I flew the Dodo plane into the baseball stadium.
 
A picture from Rockstar's website where they were discussing GTA3 with the fans.

gta3_gta4_scripts1.jpg


On the left is GTA3's script. On the right...well you know.
 
I wouldn't mind a shorter, tighter story in GTA V, at least to complete the story, with other missions being an optional as just part of being a criminal and living that life.
 
Sn4ke_911 said:
GTA IV was by no means a bad game but the amount 10s it got made it the most overrated game of all time, it just didn't deserve all those perfect scores.

Seeing it still sitting on #1 at metacritic is a joke. I'd be very surprised even if GTAV is better that it can kick IV from the throne.
Click to expand...

So how do you distinguish between deserving 5 perfect scores and deserving 10?
 
Acquiescence said:
Recent history hasn't been as kind to IV as it has certain installments that precede it.
Click to expand...

Perhaps on that's video forums that's true, but do you realize how little that represents the consensus of the entire market of people who play video games?

If GTAIV was as poorly received by the "community" as you claim it is, then why are so many still purchasing new copies of it?

Black Door said:
Maybe they should realize that sometimes, less is more...
Click to expand...

How about no.
 
Acquiescence said:
Yeah, again, this just smacks to me of history repeating itself. I remember the pre-release buzz of GTA IV, and it was absurd compared to the final product that came out in the end. There were a multitude of people saying the same thing you're saying now - "Look at the graphics, the range of missions, look at all the social things you can do, look at the cellphone capabilities, look at the Oscar-worthy story, look at how improved the gunplay is, the return to Liberty City!"... and so on and so forth. Fast forward 6 years and it's an easy contender for most overrated game of the generation. It's a game full to the brim with flaws . You look at polls and read threads about the GTA series in general and it's easy to see more fans favour Vice City and San Andreas than they do IV.

Be excited for GTA V by all means, hell I am. But this time I'm not going to be suckered in by rave reviews and "overblown hullabaloo" as MetalGuardian puts it (which is a nice way of putting it). There's still going to be a ton of shit the game does wrong in the end, but that won't stop 90+ "journalists" giving it a perfect score.



That's what I'm saying. I did too. A lot of people did - the buzz was insane at the time.
Click to expand...

That has also sold like 25 million units... so I don't know if that matters?
 
Muffdraul said:
It wouldn't be a GTA thread if there wasn't a shit fight about GTA IV. I'm always game.

A lot of the things that some say are "huge faults," I personally don't give a damn about. I acknowledge that GTA IV lacks mission variety. I acknowledge that a lot of the missions are overly scripted, especially the car chase missions where the enemy car apparently has a force field around it and gets unlimited magical speed boosts every time you come withing 20 feet of their rear bumper. I acknowledge that the driving controls and physics were touchy and came with a steep learning curve.

But none of that bothers me, because in the final analysis, I got a LOT of pleasure from learning how to drive in GTA IV, and mastering long drawn out car chases that never would have happened if I'd just blown up their car 5 seconds after starting the chase. I enjoyed going from regularly failing chase missions in the beginning, to being able to stick to them like glue for the duration.

It doesn't bother me that GTA IV is lacking missions variety, because I enjoyed the missions as they were. It didn't bother me that lots of San Andreas' bells & whistles didn't carry over to GTA IV, because a lot of those bells & whistles were wasted on me anyway.
Click to expand...

Cool, I had no problem with the driving controls as I loved driving in GTAIV and am a boss at it. Let's talk about no mid-mission checkpoints? Or let's talk about no unlockable stuff really.. or no way to spend your money. Or play a fun diversion? And no I'm not talking about darts or bowling or armwrestling. The soundtrack isn't that great compared to older titles. You cannot customize any vehicles. You have no garage ( but can park 2 cars outside your home ).

The fact that most of the 'choices' you have to make in the game have zero impact. Man I could go on and on. There are a ton of things why GTAIV is worse than most GTA3 era GTA games in my opinion. It just lacks fun mostly.
 
Spehornoob said:
I wouldn't mind a shorter, tighter story in GTA V, at least to complete the story, with other missions being an optional as just part of being a criminal and living that life.
Click to expand...

I think you'll be pleased.

I have read interviews with Rockstar stating they realize not everyone finished GTA IV, for whatever reason, and that V will be 'shorter,' at least the main game, but mission variety will be through the roof.

I think a lot of people here and elsewhere are underestimating how much of a paradigm shift the whole 'planning and executing heists' mechanic will be. It has the potential to feel revolutionary while playing, and I will afford Rockstar the trust to pull it off. Can't wait to return here after finishing the game to see the miserable haters try and explain how much they hated V and how in no way does it improve on IV's supposed inadequacies.

Will make for some entertainment toilet reading at the very least.
 
valkillmore said:
I think you'll be pleased.

I have read interviews with Rockstar stating they realize not everyone finished GTA IV, for whatever reason, and that V will be 'shorter,' at least the main game, but mission variety will be through the roof.

I think a lot of people here and elsewhere are underestimating how much of a paradigm shift the whole 'planning and executing heists' mechanic will be. It has the potential to feel revolutionary while playing, and I will afford Rockstar the trust to pull it off. Can't wait to return here after finishing the game to see the miserable haters try and explain how much they hated V and how in no way does it improve on IV's supposed inadequacies.

Will make for some entertainment toilet reading at the very least.
Click to expand...


I don't think they ever said the game will be shorter, but if they did can you find a link?
 
Mustainium said:
Perhaps on that's video forums that's true, but do you realize how little that represents the consensus of the entire market of people who play video games?

If GTAIV was as poorly received by the "community" as you claim it is, then why are so many still purchasing new copies of it?



How about no.
Click to expand...

Because it's the ONLY GTA game on current gen? LOL.

Also yes, sometimes a tighter script is better. You must not have played many games or seen a lot of movies.

NoSkillz187 said:
Does anyone know if horses will be in GTA V? The RDR horses are still hands down the best horses in any game.
Click to expand...

YES there are indeed horses. Can you ride them? Why wouldn't you.....
 
My only real problem with GTAIV (outside of the shooting) was the horrible lack of check-points during missions; the final mission in particular was a pain because of this. Thankfully that was something they fixed with the Episodes from Liberty City - so I'm not concerned about that at all with GTAV.
 
woen said:
I want to ride horses, cows and pigs. Especially pigs.
Click to expand...

I want to fuck pigs you will get that if you've seen all of the leaked vids :P

No but seriously i was so fucking happy when i saw the horses. RDR is my favorite R* game yet and you can bet those horses will be rideable.
 
Sn4ke_911 said:
I want to fuck pigs you will get that if you've seen all of the leaked vids :P

No but seriously i was so fucking happy when i saw the horses. RDR is my favorite R* game yet and you can bet those horses will be rideable.
Click to expand...

Did this come from the leaked commercials? I don't want to watch them, but this is good to hear.
 
Sn4ke_911 said:
I want to fuck pigs you will get that if you've seen all of the leaked vids :P

No but seriously i was so fucking happy when i saw the horses. RDR is my favorite R* game yet and you can bet those horses will be rideable.
Click to expand...

I doubt
you'll be able to ride those horses. It would be epic, though.
 
Sn4ke_911 said:
I want to fuck pigs you will get that if you've seen all of the leaked vids :P

No but seriously i was so fucking happy when i saw the horses. RDR is my favorite R* game yet and you can bet those horses will be rideable.
Click to expand...

My lack of will power. :(. I had to highlight it. Wish I didn't.
 
Sn4ke_911 said:
I want to fuck pigs you will get that if you've seen all of the leaked vids :P

No but seriously i was so fucking happy when i saw the horses. RDR is my favorite R* game yet and you can bet those horses will be rideable.
Click to expand...

I didn't see the leaked vids, I was spoiled enough with the achievements

RDR is one my favorite games on this gen, so if we can ride horses in GTA V...it would be the surprise of the year.
 
I might be wrong but don't we already know what the first mission is from previews? or was that a different mission?
 
Maybe just me but if the length of the story is about the same as previous GTA games then each character's story would surely end up being quite short?
 
Certinty said:
Maybe just me but if the length of the story is about the same as previous GTA games then each character's story would surely end up being quite short?
Click to expand...

I could be wrong but each characters story is kind of like one long connected story. They are all connected and it isn't like a complete all of Franklins story, now move on to Trevor's story.
 
Certinty said:
Maybe just me but if the length of the story is about the same as previous GTA games then each character's story would surely end up being quite short?
Click to expand...

Wut. San Andreas took me like 60 hours and GTAIV was like 45-50. Plus the narrative will intertwine much more than, say, GTAIV did. ~10 hours for each character's side stories + ~15-20 for the "trio" story is more than enough time. And that if the narrative is even truly split up in that way.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Crimson Desert Has Gone Gold | Releases March 19, 2026
News  2
71
103
videogamedude replied
Borderlands 4 has gone GOLD
News  2
66
2K
Walliwallipaloo replied
Lost Soul Aside has gone gold
Opinion News 
42
1K
The_hunter replied
eli_handle_b․wav: Anchormen in GTA V
Trailer 
1
139
notseqi replied
GTA Series Has Sold Nearly 455 million Units, GTA V Counts For Nearly Half
19
3K
amigastar replied
Top Bottom