icecold1983
Member
i dont remember any other recent title where it was so bad its one of the first things i noticed. now it can never be unseen.
2015 Console Screenshot Thread (PS4, XB1, Wii U) [READ OP!]
- Thread starter VanWinkle
- Start date
i dont remember any other recent title where it was so bad its one of the first things i noticed. now it can never be unseen.
Killzone:SF had pretty low res cube maps on some surfaces from what i remembered.
icecold1983
Member
theres select areas yes, but overall it was pretty reasonable. i dont know if you tried the hardline beta, but i dont know how dictator found it to be on the same level as most other games. it was searing holes into my eyeballs everytime i played bank or downtown map.
I wasn't saying the AA was the same in Ryse and Infamous, I was saying that they are the best example of that particular AA solution IMO.
Having not played Ryse on the One in person, I cant say I agree or disagree about its image quality compared to Infamous. I would expect Crytech be more experienced with an AA solution they created though. As someone who is currently playing Far Cry 4 on the PS4, I have to say I'm impressed with its over all use of HRAA. Its not a perfect technique, but its a hell of a lot better than FXAA (and arguably better than SMAA, but both are great AA solutions)
Just to be clear here. There are ALOT of AA solutions, some are great, others are not. This gen so far has a great deal of good new AA solutions. Ryse has great SMAA T1x, Infamous has great SMAA T2x and Far Cry 4 has great HRAA.
No i didnt, but the worst cubemaps i've seen were in Deus Ex: Revolution. They were like scary low res.
icecold1983
Member
i never played that game, but thats a pure gen 7 console title. these are all gen 8 titles.
Summer Haze
Banned
Are you talking about the AA implementation itself or the overall IQ?
N7Commander95
Member
First try, hope these are good!
icecold1983
Member
i was talking about AA but both titles have better overall IQ as well.
GavinUK86
Member
First try, hope these are good!
Doesn't load. You'll have rehost them somewhere else like abload or flickr.
N7Commander95
Member
cheers, will do!
Dayum, the Driveclub and The Order 1886 pics look absolutely amazing! Seriously, nothing really touches The Order in visual fidelity right now. Also, I never realized Sunset Overdrive was so beautiful, especially the colors. I love seeing those KZ SF pics with volumetric lighting too. Can't wait for Uncharted 4 screenshots at the end of this year 
TommyTosser
Member
Just picked up FH2 because of this thread. Thank you.
Summer Haze
Banned
Far Cry 4 maybe, but definitely not Ryse. At least not on console anyway. Infamous: SS has a much sharper and cleaner IQ in my experience.
Gotta disagree with you about Ryse. Infamous is native res and much cleaner looking. Ryse might have less visible aliasing but it's also blurry by comparison.
icecold1983
Member
more sharpness at the cost of much more temporal instability. a losing tradeoff. i judge games in motion, not screenshots.
Sounds like preference which is a waste of time to even argue.
Summer Haze
Banned
But Ryse is blurrier in motion too. It has a "vaseline-filter" look due to the upscaled 900p, on top of the heavy use of motion blur. Infamous looks cleaner and sharper in both screenshots and in-motion from my experience playing both games.
*Shrugs*
N7Commander95
Member
God this game is so gorgeous
Summer Haze
Banned
LordBaztion
Member
I guess its hard to get the right moment with the X1 screenshot feature.
Considering you are talking about SMAA T2x vs SMAA T1x and are actually trying to compare different games with different integration as well as DIFFERENT RESOLUTIONS, I'll have to just say, ok. Cool. That's your opinion, you are entitled to it and I'm not going to tell you you are wrong... All I ask is that you respect others opinions too.
Found a summary of some different AA techniques:
MLAA : Post processing AA
FXAA : Post processing AA, fatser than MLAA, simillar quality
TAA : temporal - time axis AA (others are all space axis)
SMAA 1x : improved MLAA, better quality, faster speed, slightly slower than FXAA
SMAA T2x : SMAA 1x + TAA 2x
TXAA : heavy blurring, solves subpixel problem
Caayn
Member
That picture is fake
Two problems with the Order on a 21:9 display;
1. The PS4 doesn't support 21:9 resolution as an output resolution, connecting the PS4 to a 21:9 display and you'd get what you see in the attached picture below. (Black bars added to both sides of the screen)
2. Even if the PS4 supports 21:9, the Order is only 1920*800. All 21:9 displays are 2560*1080 or higher, resulting in the Order becoming more blurry than it already is thanks to upscaling.
This is how the Order will look on a 21:9 display, I used a video to simulate how it would look.
Excuse me for the terrible picture quality of my phone 
Considering you are talking about SMAA T2x vs SMAA T1x and are actually trying to compare different games with different integration as well as DIFFERENT RESOLUTIONS, I'll have to just say, ok. Cool. That's your opinion, you are entitled to it and I'm not going to tell you you are wrong... All I ask is that you respect others opinions too.
Found a summary of some different AA techniques:
MLAA : Post processing AA
FXAA : Post processing AA, fatser than MLAA, simillar quality
TAA : temporal - time axis AA (others are all space axis)
SMAA 1x : improved MLAA, better quality, faster speed, slightly slower than FXAA
SMAA T2x : SMAA 1x + TAA 2x
TXAA : heavy blurring, solves subpixel problem
Alien Isolation doesnt have proper SMAA T1x implementation. I think they messed up name, and T1x is actually 1x.
Fair enough. Its hard to find anything to post about this... Being from 2 different games and all.
icecold1983
Member
Considering you are talking about SMAA T2x vs SMAA T1x and are actually trying to compare different games with different integration as well as DIFFERENT RESOLUTIONS, I'll have to just say, ok. Cool. That's your opinion, you are entitled to it and I'm not going to tell you you are wrong... All I ask is that you respect others opinions too.
Found a summary of some different AA techniques:
MLAA : Post processing AA
FXAA : Post processing AA, fatser than MLAA, simillar quality
TAA : temporal - time axis AA (others are all space axis)
SMAA 1x : improved MLAA, better quality, faster speed, slightly slower than FXAA
SMAA T2x : SMAA 1x + TAA 2x
TXAA : heavy blurring, solves subpixel problem
i fail to see what you hope to accomplish by replying to a statement about temporal stability with screenshots. alien isolation is an ugly mess in motion. the implementation is irreverent wrt ryse and FC 4 having IQ a good deal better than infamous. im willing to bet you and the others in this convo think the smaa options in crysis 3 look better than txaa as well.
also temporal AAs are not created equal. ryse temporal aspect is mostly copied from nvidias txaa. you can see a very similar implementation in evolves post process only txaa variant(if you have nvidia). its extremely similar to ryse during movement but the evolve implementation breaks w/ no movement. im willing to bet the order and FC 4 are also copying txaas method of sampling from several frames using an accumulation buffer.
xenogenesis
Member
Actually it was a comment about temporal stability in motion... About console AA, not PC AA... I also never said Ryse or FC 4 look better, or worse than Infamous. Lets remeber this broke out because I dared to share the opinion that Infamous and Ryse have some of the best AA in current console games. CLEARLY that opinion is not welcome here.
First try, hope these are good!
Definitely limited Xbox One screens.
The Order looks so nice, I almost want to play it just for its graphics.
icecold1983
Member
huh? i think somewhere you confused my posts with someone elses. and yes, temporal stability by definition will always be referring to motion.
N7Commander95
Member
whoops thanks for reminding me to put the platform in ha ha
VE3TRO
Formerly Gizmowned
Anyone that runs Photoshop and having the problems with the XB1 limited screens you can use this quick action. Just open the file then play the action for each screenshot.
https://mega.co.nz/#!pUMVGYbB!qi-48lo-deTyjHezPT-rlAfnWJlR0DNnfwV13TDTPJA
Some samples.
https://mega.co.nz/#!pUMVGYbB!qi-48lo-deTyjHezPT-rlAfnWJlR0DNnfwV13TDTPJA
Some samples.
slackjaw10
Neo Member
Wow, that looks amazing! I need to download Project Spark and check out all of the user-created stuff.
Thanks. I've started this project today and thought I'd share some screenshots.
btw: I can't see your farcry screenshots.
Hmm, maybe something to do with hosting on OneDrive.
VlaudTheImpaler
tl;dr
Sunset Overdrive, XB1 screenshot share function, Full RGB.
N7Commander95
Member
Summer Haze
Banned
Wow, beautiful. Reminds me of the movie 'Avatar'.
Inf3cted_b3ast
Member
Driveclub photomode
Similar threads
- Poll