I have to give a big shout out to the newcomer The Good Place. It's still airing, but so far the show doesn't fall under the trope of stretching its main storyline endlessly. Give it a chance, its only 20 minutes and is more packed with good content.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
2016 Television Top 10 Lists
- Thread starter Cornballer
- Start date
- Status
SliceSabre
Banned
Hell yea BoJack Horseman getting the respect it deserves. Easily my favorite show of the year.
DontBeThatGuy
Member
It's on plenty of lists, just not top 10, and also not superior in every way. It's just easier to digest, less unusual. (and less interesting too, imo).
It's good though.
lightskintwin
Banned
Atlanta was definitely more critically acclaimed, but it was not that unusual. The one thing Atlanta had going for it was it's social commentary that permeated throughout the series.
Insecure and Atlanta actually shared more similarities than differences.
tearsintherain
Member
Yes, The Good Place is fantastic!
Some of the entries on that list I feel are a bit suspect. I love Better Call Saul, but season 2 was not as good as season 1. Not even close. A bit weird to put that on any list. I'd argue the same holds true for You're the Worst and Mr. Robot.
Stranger Things, Westworld, and Atlanta belong on every list especially as they are all first seasons and really its amazing how much better season 1s of new shows are this decade than in the past. When you think back to classics like Seinfeld, Star Trek TNG, Friends, etc the season 1s of those shows tend to be just really, really bad.
I DVR'd Insecure for my wife to watch but she says she has zero interest in watching what is probably a "depressing show", and I have zero interest in watching a show focused on a black single female. Both of us love Atlanta though and she's the one who got me to watch it, she loves Glover from Community. Probably a really tough show to market (Insecure).
demosthenes
Member
Game of Thrones was great this year...
I'm surprised that Insecure is so lauded here. I find the show to be completely unremarkable. It's not horrible, but it's far from anything special, IMO.
High Maintenance is an under the radar show that I feel like a lot of people didn't watch that was really great. The distinct creative approaches to each episode are great and the character studies are very memorable.
High Maintenance is an under the radar show that I feel like a lot of people didn't watch that was really great. The distinct creative approaches to each episode are great and the character studies are very memorable.
DontBeThatGuy
Member
Atlanta just feels more fresh to me; the way it's shot, the writing, the vibe of the whole thing, which isn't to say Insecure didn't have it's own fresh voice in it's own way, but the trappings felt much more generic to me. I still appreciated it quite a bit by the time the season ended.
I will say that I expected Atlanta to be much weirder considering some of the hype beforehand, but I'm pretty happy with what we got regardless.
Cornballer
Member
lightskintwin
Banned
Weirdly enough, anytime Insecure was in business settings it had a The Office vibe going for it.
lightskintwin
Banned
Slate with the Queen Sugar pick. Queen Sugar was terrific.
DontBeThatGuy
Member
I need to stop procrastinating on this shit though, so many shows I haven't gotten around to yet. I haven't even seen an episode of Westworld yet.
blame space
Banned
i gotta watch season 4 of rectify.
DontBeThatGuy
Member
It's been solid, as always.
Norwegian Rudo
Member
The show I am surprised to see on so many lists is The Girlfriend Experience. From memory it got kind of luke-warm reviews when it came out.
It was a great final season, and had some of the best episodes ever in the series. As with some other quality network shows, it just perennially does not seem to be the kind of show TV critics are interested in. I definitely wouldn't take its absence from these lists as indicating any lower quality, for me and I think many it was at least as good or in some cases better than some of the previous seasons.
blame space
Banned
no one seems to like goliath but i think it's pretty good.
Yep, very happy to see The Americans getting the recognition it deserves; easily one of my favorite shows at the moment. It's been great throughout its whole run.
I need to check out Atlanta; it's on a lot of these lists.
OniBarubary
Banned
Bojack being on so many lists, and so high on a number of them, makes me deliriously happy. This show deserves all the praise it gets and then some.
First off, let me say thank you for not spoiler tagging the lists. I never understand why people do that.
I need to start watching a lot of those shows, especially Bojack. That one seems to be on just about everyones list. Really need to start watching The Expanse as well.
I'm actually a bit surprised that Game of Thrones didn't make more lists. I think that just had its best season yet. But I guess that just speaks to the quality of television that is going on right now. So that's good.
I need to start watching a lot of those shows, especially Bojack. That one seems to be on just about everyones list. Really need to start watching The Expanse as well.
I'm actually a bit surprised that Game of Thrones didn't make more lists. I think that just had its best season yet. But I guess that just speaks to the quality of television that is going on right now. So that's good.
I really liked that one as well. Just randomly ran into it on Amazon and decided to start watching it.
Yep. It's good fun Sci-Fi with pacing and plotting issues.
At moments is utterly brilliant, but most of the time it's... mealy.
Mr. Robot is pretty, everything about it is pretty. But it's also a lot smarter than most shows on TV and the "twists" (if you have to call them that) all make sense within the world it's built.
It's in my top 10 for sure, but I can understand why it wouldn't make others lists.
metalslimer
Member
It was an amazing year for TV. Surprised to see the night of in some of the lists and it was probably my least favorite show I watched all year.
richardhawk
Member
Yep. People are gonna tune into it too late and realize they missed something amazing. Glad to see Atlanta up there though.
NotTheGuyYouKill
Member
I'm surprised Westworld isn't mentioned more.
You say smarter, I say edgy trying way too hard to be cool. Blech.
WaffleTaco
Wants to outlaw technological innovation.
Needs more Game of Thrones honestly, there's nothing like it on TV with the production and spectacle and twists.
OniBarubary
Banned
Edgy literally means nothing.
Bojack is edgy.
It had a pop star singing a song about getting an abortion with lines such as:
"I'm a baby killer
Baby killing makes me horny
Aliens inside me
Gonna squash it like Sigourney"
or
"I hope and pray to god my little fetus has a soul
Because I want it to feel pain when I eject it from my hole"
That's the definition of edgy.
It's also one of the funniest things I've ever seen and I was in tears gasping for breath laughing at this shit.
Bojack is edgy.
It had a pop star singing a song about getting an abortion with lines such as:
"I'm a baby killer
Baby killing makes me horny
Aliens inside me
Gonna squash it like Sigourney"
or
"I hope and pray to god my little fetus has a soul
Because I want it to feel pain when I eject it from my hole"
That's the definition of edgy.
It's also one of the funniest things I've ever seen and I was in tears gasping for breath laughing at this shit.
shira
Member
What door?
dead souls
Member
It's a garbage show would be my hypothesis.
The fact that it even appears at all just shows the undeserved cachet HBO still has.
Androidsleeps
Member
Glad for The Americans, probably best show on television. You guys should give The Crown a chance, I know the premise seems meh but it really surprised me, great production.
I watched the Rectify pilot today and it was...okay. I'm gonna try and finish season 1 asap. But out of curiosity, does it get better in the later seasons?
I watched the Rectify pilot today and it was...okay. I'm gonna try and finish season 1 asap. But out of curiosity, does it get better in the later seasons?
pokeystaples
Banned
Insecure should be on more lists. The show is REALLY well done.
You have some unique tastes when Westworld is garbage yet you're watching The Vampires Diaries Season 8. To each their own though.
DontBeThatGuy
Member
It doesn't "get better", it just gets more fleshed out in every way, which is all you can ask for from a show like this.
OniBarubary
Banned
The first...hrm...4 or 5 episodes of Season 1 are pretty funny, but otherwise nothing amazing. What happens though is that the first couple episodes the show seemed to be finding it's feet and wondering what it wanted to do. Come the second half of the season, they figured it out and figured it out hard. The 2nd season and 3rd season are fucking tremendous television. It stops being a silly random comedy and instead becomes an incredibly dark comedy that has the most realistic depiction of depression I've ever seen in a TV show.
DontBeThatGuy
Member
A Moral Orel trajectory?
- Status