Ristamar said:
Nope, at least not at the 2 Wal-Marts in my area. They demand a receipt now. Perhaps they're more lenient around the holidays, as I did exchange games there last winter, or maybe they finally cought on to the scheme. However, it doesn't hurt to try if you have something you want to offload. If you do, let me know how it turns out.
Here's an update for Ristamar or anyone else who cares:
I took the two games I bought (Cel Damage and LoTR: TTT) to the WalMart near my house, and attempted to "exchange" them. Unfortunately, it didn't work because the customer service woman saw the sticker residue from the CC security tags that I had pulled off (WalMart games don't have security tags on them, since they're kept behind glass). She didn't yell at me or anything, because my story was that someone had bought the games for me and they weren't quite what I wanted, so I was trying to return them without the person's feelings getting hurt. She just said, "Find out where they get these games from, because it wasn't here."
So, I went home, regrouped a bit, and used a combination of cleaning solvents to get the remaining sticker residue off of the packaging. I got about 90% of it off, and it looked pretty passable. Then, when I went to a different WalMart, I placed the "return" stickers they give you when you walk in the door (if they see you're returning something) on the same spots where the security stickers were, to further mask any remaining stickiness. The return worked perfectly, and I ended up with a $45 gift card for WalMart -- not exactly the $100 I had hoped for, but still a $35 profit on the whole thing. Had I known how relatively painless it would be, I would've bought more shitty games to do the same thing with.
So, yeah, if you have the time and inclination, a WalMart exchange can be done. And don't feel bad about it, either (my girlfriend was trying to guilt trip me the whole time), because it's not hurting anybody -- Circuit City got their money, you get some profit, and WalMart gets to resell the games you gave them.