ComputerMKII
Banned
I can't seem to find it. Would you mind posting the URL please?Amir0x said:
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
A Dance with Dragons |OT| - Read the rules or Melisandre casts magic missile
- Thread starter Amir0x
- Start date
Basileus777
Member
ComputerMKII
Banned
Thank you.Basileus777 said:
D
Deleted member 1235
Unconfirmed Member
got my kindle copy, was too late for my train ride to work, but I'm eagerly looking forward to tonight. It's a real shame that I'm at 85% of the magicians by lev grossman, don't think that's getting finished. hah.
I'm still a ways from starting A Dance with Dragons as I am only half way through A Game of Thrones, but I'm curious if I'll be able to skip A Feast for Crows and be okay. I heard a Feast for Crows was absolutely terrible and I don't want to read 1,000 pages of tripe if I can skip it. If necessary, maybe I'll just read a summary on wikipedia or something.
Do not skip it.LM4sure said:
It's not terrible, I actually enjoyed it quite a lot (and I think the fact that I knew I'd be able to read ADWD immediately after helped).
There are crucial POVs, a broader view of the war, some really interesting moments and some MAJOR story devleopments that are pulled off well. Also the writing in AFFC is probably the best of the series... In short: DO NOT SKIP IT.
Palette Swap
Member
Wow, my wife actually got me a copy of the book this morning (in fucking Paris of all places), can't wait to get home.
KingGondo said:
Just reread the book, and I have to agree. Once you sit back and stop caring about what happens next, you soon realize the slow-paced chapters are often the best written. The "broken men" monologue, especially, is a beautiful piece of writing.
Palette Swap said:
Damn. I'm in France, and I'm getting it tomorrow at best. I really hate you right now.
bengraven
Member
ColonialRaptor said:
I KNOW RIGHT. AND I TOLD YOU ALL SO.
golem said:
Yeah, that chapter was changed from the preview too. Originally
Jon just hung him from the top of the Wall. George decided something more poetic would be the decapitation, so it's funny to see that line where he's like "no, I cannot hang you".
Awesome Animals
Member
So...how is it so far!!
It was probably for the best that I went in with my expectations lowered, it allowed me to enjoy what's good about AFFC much more.Sotha Sil said:
I really enjoyed Brienne's story as a whole, between her encounters with the remnants of the Brave Companions, the various hedge knights we get to meet, and more fun with Pod Payne and the levity brought by the Septon she meets, one of the few incorruptible characters in GRRM's world.
I also thought that GRRM did a nice job getting inside the mind of a paranoid, delusional character (Cersei) as well as that of a religious fanatic in Damphair.
Wonderful stuff. Not to mention the fun chapters in the Eyrie as Littlefinger bends the Vale to his will.
aronnov reborn
Banned
anyone have pics of the maps in the front of the book up yet? I can't really make them out on my kindle and was wondering if they were online etc yet?
John Harker
Definitely doesn't make things up as he goes along.
LM4sure said:
I kind of wish I was capable of skipping it. It left a bad taste in my mouth all these years. What a chore to churn through!
I'm pretty stoked about Dance though (mainly because the show rekindled my affection for the series) so will be heading to B&N at lunch to grab it.
Mockingbird
Member
Thing is, adwd's timeline goes past affc's, so you cannot skip it for some charas.
Btw, this shit came to my kindle at 12:05 or something. WTF amazon?
Btw, this shit came to my kindle at 12:05 or something. WTF amazon?
Large Professor
Member
Jarmel said:
One thousand pages in one day, that would be impressive.
I didn't receive mine yet
LegendofJoe
Member
I think the long wait for AFFC and ADWD, and the negativity it engendered lead a lot of people to be unfairly critical of Feast. In terms of plot advancement and character dynamics it was certainly a let down in comparison with Swords. That said however, in terms of world building and setting description Feast is the best of the series in my opinion. I strongly feel that if people who were disappointed with the book made an effort to read it again with an open mind their opinions concerning its quality would change.
Unconditional
Member
I forgot this was coming out this soon. Can't wait to get my hands on it.
malingenie
Member
OMG @ the Reviews! Can't wait!
HarryHengst
Member
Jarmel said:
no real spoilers, but spoilered it just to be sure.
- Tyrions chapters are the weakest.
- Wait no, Daenerys chapters are. Ugh, i didnt really care for her before but apparently i could care less! Except for Barristan, he's a cool bro.
- fuck GURM for the last chapter. They killed one of my nigga's. :'(
- the Boltons are really fucked up.
- bit too many cliffhanger-style "is he dead or not?" endings.
- Wait no, Daenerys chapters are. Ugh, i didnt really care for her before but apparently i could care less! Except for Barristan, he's a cool bro.
- fuck GURM for the last chapter. They killed one of my nigga's. :'(
- the Boltons are really fucked up.
- bit too many cliffhanger-style "is he dead or not?" endings.
It's a good book, probably rank it third after ASOS and ACFK.
Fleet_of_Foot
Member
Unconditional said:
Ha.
bonesmccoy
Banned
Oh my.
Grrrr, amazon says my copy shipped Sunday night through Fedex from a CA warehouse 1 hour away from my house. Yet, it's been in transit from the original mail place for two days!!! I hope my book isn't lost...
Can anyone that has used amazon before give me some assurance? Is this standard or something until an hour before delivery?
Can anyone that has used amazon before give me some assurance? Is this standard or something until an hour before delivery?
PhoenixDark
Banned
KingGondo said:
Probably. I'll most likely buy it again once the paperback hits, to match it with my collection. I need to re-by the other paperbacks considering they're falling apart (that's what I get for loaning books to my brothers...)
Wow, well I just checked the actual Fedex website using Amazon's tracking number, and the estimated delivery date is set as tomorrow, not today (but amazon still shows July 12). I cannot wait one more day for this book lol! Think I'm going to buy it from borders and return the amazon book; they said they will pay for shipping because I got first day shipping and it didn't get here the first day.
Unconditional
Member
Fleet_of_Foot said:
My sense of time is messed up because of all the waiting. I was expecting another delay somehow.
My old copies of ACOK and ASOS are falling apart because I read them by the pool, and the binding glue started to melt (yay Oklahoma heat).PhoenixDark said:
I'll probably cave and buy the new paperbacks eventually as well. And the eventual Mega-Premium-Hardback edition when the series is complete
in 2022. :-/
HarryHengst
Member
Whole book spoilers, really do not read unless you've finished the book:Jarmel said:
Tyrion ends up doing a Grande Tour through the nations of the Free cities and doesnt even reach Daenerys. HE does meet Aegon, son of Rhaegar, who was saved by Viserys. But yeah, Tyrion ends up being some kind of goddamn gladiator riding on a pig, together with another dwarf (sounds familiar?), for a while.
And Daenerys ends up being in Meereen the whole book, without even getting a mile closer to Westeros, because she goes back to a Dothraki khalasar in her final chapter ("i have to go back to move forward" was quite the kick in the balls after reading so many chapters of her bumming around Meereen). Thank god Aegon is a smart Targaryen who manages to conquer a few castle's in Westeros because he had no intention of fucking around in the Free Cities.
In the end their plots felt pretty useless, except for the Aegon bit, but make up about 1/3 of the book. The plot really isnt advanced at all, and you'll have to wait for the next book for that. Dont get me wrong: they're not bad chapters to read, its just really frustrating that, after so many years of waiting, it all leads to, well, not much. I know that a big part of the book is all moving the pieces around for next part of the play, so i have high hopes that the next book can be another ASOS, but it will be years before that book is released.
Also, with GURM doing the whole "is he dead or not!"-cliffhanger with both Jon ánd Stannis in one chapter i couldnt help but roll my eyes a bit. So i hope that both are dead for real, because that would really surpise me.
And i'm still pissed he killed Kevan. Fuck you GURM.
And Daenerys ends up being in Meereen the whole book, without even getting a mile closer to Westeros, because she goes back to a Dothraki khalasar in her final chapter ("i have to go back to move forward" was quite the kick in the balls after reading so many chapters of her bumming around Meereen). Thank god Aegon is a smart Targaryen who manages to conquer a few castle's in Westeros because he had no intention of fucking around in the Free Cities.
In the end their plots felt pretty useless, except for the Aegon bit, but make up about 1/3 of the book. The plot really isnt advanced at all, and you'll have to wait for the next book for that. Dont get me wrong: they're not bad chapters to read, its just really frustrating that, after so many years of waiting, it all leads to, well, not much. I know that a big part of the book is all moving the pieces around for next part of the play, so i have high hopes that the next book can be another ASOS, but it will be years before that book is released.
Also, with GURM doing the whole "is he dead or not!"-cliffhanger with both Jon ánd Stannis in one chapter i couldnt help but roll my eyes a bit. So i hope that both are dead for real, because that would really surpise me.
And i'm still pissed he killed Kevan. Fuck you GURM.
Similar threads
- Poll