Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. |OT| Tahiti is a Magical Place (to...Hey guys, I found it!)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Gintamen

Member
Cap managed to take a hit of Thor's hammer with his shield.
If Cap had taken that hit by himself he would be splattered all over the ground. You have no idea what you talking about, please inform yourself a bit before coming up with bad arguments like that.
 
If Cap had taken that hit by himself he would be splattered all over the ground. You have no idea what you talking about, please inform yourself a bit before coming up with bad arguments like that.

he wouldnt be splattered imo more like what blonsky looked like after hulk kicked him into a tree which is pretty close i guess
 

Joni

Member
Your argument is that others heroes don't help out? Have you even watched Cap2 yet?
No avenger to be seen helping out in the biggest crisis. Same in Iron Man 3.
I can kinda understand there. Thor is in his world, Captain America is travelling, Stark is in his area. Spider-Man lives in New York just like the Fantastic Four and just like Stark now that his house is gone. It works now because everyone is spread out and they each have their role. Otherwise it would be like a movie where Wolverine takes on a bad guy alone while inside of the X-Men mansion.

If Cap had taken that hit by himself he would be splattered all over the ground. You have no idea what you talking about, please inform yourself a bit before coming up with bad arguments like that.
As I said, I have only seen the movies and the cartoons. That is enough information to discuss the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the Spider-Man cinematic universe. Everything else doesn't exist there.
 
I can kinda understand there. Thor is in his world, Captain America is travelling, Stark is in his area. Spider-Man lives in New York just like the Fantastic Four and just like Stark now that his house is gone. It works now because everyone is spread out and they each have their role. Otherwise it would be like a movie where Wolverine takes on a bad guy alone while inside of the X-Men mansion.


As I said, I have only seen the movies and the cartoons. That is enough information to discuss the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the Spider-Man cinematic universe. Everything else doesn't exist there.

and spider man is portrayed as way stronger than cap and especially most of the x men which is the first thing you were arguing against.
 
See, I never got that from any of the animated shows or the movies. I'd think many non-comic book fans would feel the same.

I think the problem with the movies and cartoons is that the animated or movie series never last long enough to show that Peter Parker is holding back a lot of his power. There never seems to be a good time to bring that up.

Anyways, he's held up an entire building in the comics:

813119-webbing2_super.jpeg
 

CryptiK

Member
I think the problem with the movies and cartoons is that the animated or movie series never last long enough to show that Peter Parker is holding back a lot of his power. There never seems to be a good time to bring that up.

Anyways, he's held up an entire building in the comics:

813119-webbing2_super.jpeg
No he is holding up one support beam and praying that the Bugle doesnt fall down around his ears.
 

Joni

Member
and spider man is portrayed as way stronger than cap and especially most of the x men which is the first thing you were arguing against.
No, the first I argued was that he doesn't seem strong enough to be in a world where Stark and Richards live in the same city. I also argued he doesn't seem A-tier in the movies. People posted comic book pages and discussed the Spider-Man versus X-Men thing, but I'm behind on my X-Men movies so I won't go there. You seem familiar with the comics, so you know his strength there. I don't, the comics don't appear here and I'm not interested in reading them. A lot of people who watch the show, the movies, ... fall in that category.

I think the problem with the movies and cartoons is that the animated or movie series never last long enough to show that Peter Parker is holding back a lot of his power. There never seems to be a good time to bring that up.
See, that is what you don't get from the movies.
 

neoanarch

Member
I'm not sure what you're arguing about here. Your original point was that Spider-man would get overshadowed by the other heroes and that he isn't that strong. Both wrong, your perception of them doesn't matter. Marvel would keep him as close to his comic strength and intelligence as possible. This entire argument is a giant "what if" that isn't gonna go anywhere though.

In strength only Thor and Hulk out power him. But his speed, spider-sense and webbing would let him go toe-to-toe.

In intelligence he is smarter than Stark, only less focused and driven to really pursue his science career fully.
 
No, the first I argued was that he doesn't seem strong enough to be in a world where Stark and Richards live in the same city. I also argued he doesn't seem A-tier in the movies. People posted comic book pages and discussed the Spider-Man versus X-Men thing, but I'm behind on my X-Men movies so I won't go there. You seem familiar with the comics, so you know his strength there. I don't, the comics don't appear here and I'm not interested in reading them. A lot of people who watch the show, the movies, ... fall in that category.


See, that is what you don't get from the movies.

i have never read a spider man comic everything i've talked about is from the movies and i mention that in my posts
 

DrBo42

Member
I'm not sure what you're arguing about here. Your original point was that Spider-man would get overshadowed by the other heroes and that he isn't that strong. Both wrong, your perception of them doesn't matter. Marvel would keep him as close to his comic strength and intelligence as possible. This entire argument is a giant "what if" that isn't gonna go anywhere though.

In strength only Thor and Hulk out power him. But his speed, spider-sense and webbing would let him go toe-to-toe.

In intelligence he is smarter than Stark, only less focused and driven to really pursue his science career fully.

Shouldn't be true considering how sophisticated his tech is. So many heroes being on genius level or close to across both DC and Marvel is really dumb.
 

Zen

Banned
In strength only Thor and Hulk out power him. But his speed, spider-sense and webbing would let him go toe-to-toe.

In intelligence he is smarter than Stark, only less focused and driven to really pursue his science career fully.

He can not go toe to toe with Thor or Hulk and that last line seems like complete comic book bs.
 

neoanarch

Member
Dude get a grip its fiction none of it is true.


Parker was building some really sophisticated stuff while he was still a teenager.
 

Hagi

Member
No, the first I argued was that he doesn't seem strong enough to be in a world where Stark and Richards live in the same city. I also argued he doesn't seem A-tier in the movies. People posted comic book pages and discussed the Spider-Man versus X-Men thing, but I'm behind on my X-Men movies so I won't go there. You seem familiar with the comics, so you know his strength there. I don't, the comics don't appear here and I'm not interested in reading them. A lot of people who watch the show, the movies, ... fall in that category.


See, that is what you don't get from the movies.

The only heroes stronger than Spidey in the MCU are Thor and the Hulk, this is just going from Amazing Spider-man 2. Also Stark and the FF have their own shit to deal with so to expect them to deal with Sandman robbing a bank when Doom is plotting to kill the world or the Mandarin is holding a Mongolian pride parade at the steps of Stark tower is a tad silly.

There's so much shit going on in a day to day basis in New York that no one hero could fix it all. Just wait till the Netflix shows start and they add Daredevil, Iron Fist and Luke Cage to city. Not to mention the rumored Dr Strange movie.

Anywho i need to catch up with the show before the finale.
 

Asbel

Member
I'm not sure what you're arguing about here. Your original point was that Spider-man would get overshadowed by the other heroes and that he isn't that strong. Both wrong, your perception of them doesn't matter. Marvel would keep him as close to his comic strength and intelligence as possible. This entire argument is a giant "what if" that isn't gonna go anywhere though.

In strength only Thor and Hulk out power him. But his speed, spider-sense and webbing would let him go toe-to-toe.

In intelligence he is smarter than Stark, only less focused and driven to really pursue his science career fully
.

I'm pretty sure when Spidey is with these guys, the opposite is protrayed. Show me spidey going one on one with Thor or Hulk or being smarter than Stark when they are together.
 
Peter Parker would be so hugely overshadowed by every other superhero and it would be weird people like Reed or Stark don't help stop people Elektro despite living in the same city. Spider-Man works best in an isolated universe. He has powers, but he isn't that strong.

Parker is one of the strongest heroes outside of Cosmic Marvel. Hell there was an issue he held up an entire building all by himself. Dude is no joke and can EASILY hang with Captain America, Iron Man, and Thor. (though Thor falls into Cosmic Marvel and is more powerful, he can still hang with him)
 

Fuzzy

I would bang a hot farmer!
Cap managed to take a hit of Thor's hammer with his shield.

As I said, I have only seen the movies and the cartoons. That is enough information to discuss the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the Spider-Man cinematic universe. Everything else doesn't exist there.
From the first Captain America movie speaking about the shield:

Howard Stark: "It's completely vibration absorbent."

That means anyone could've been holding the shield and taken that hit from Thor according to the movies.
 

Joni

Member
I'm not sure what you're arguing about here. Your original point was that Spider-man would get overshadowed by the other heroes and that he isn't that strong. Both wrong, your perception of them doesn't matter. Marvel would keep him as close to his comic strength and intelligence as possible.
I would find Spider-Man's new strength strange because the previous movies portrayed him as smart, agile and not that strong. He is strong, but not Avengers strong in those movies.

Parker is one of the strongest heroes outside of Cosmic Marvel. Hell there was an issue he held up an entire building all by himself.
Yep, comics. Not movies. As I said, I don't read comics as do many movie viewers.

The only heroes stronger than Spidey in the MCU are Thor and the Hulk, this is just going from Amazing Spider-man 2.
I haven't seen that one yet, but he doesn't look that strong in the four others. He seems strong, but not robot suit strong.

Also Stark and the FF have their own shit to deal with so to expect them to deal with Sandman robbing a bank when Doom is plotting to kill the world or the Mandarin is holding a Mongolian pride parade at the steps of Stark tower is a tad silly.
So they'll need to find reasons to explain. The movies take place around the same time they're released. The show proves Thor 2 and Captain America 2 are about 6-7 months apart. There are already questions why nobody helps anyone else while they still have the advantage of geographical distance.

i have never read a spider man comic everything i've talked about is from the movies and i mention that in my posts
In that case we're drawing different conclusions. For instance, Spidey does stop the train, but he can't without his webbing. The Thing holds up the London Eye in the Silver Surfer even when the others aren't helping, The Hulk throws a tank. Both of them would be living in New York. Stark has an army of suits.

From the first Captain America movie speaking about the shield:

Howard Stark: "It's completely vibration absorbent."

That means anyone could've been holding the shield and taken that hit from Thor according to the movies.
Okay. That would still leave people like The Thing and Hulk in this hypothethical movie universe.
 

Hagi

Member
I always thought Vibranium had a limit to the kinetic force it could negate hence why during the scene Thor drops the hammer they all get knocked down because it releases the energy stored in its bonds or some shit.
 
In that case we're drawing different conclusions. For instance, Spidey does stop the train, but he can't without his webbing. The Thing holds up the London Eye in the Silver Surfer even when the others aren't helping, The Hulk throws a tank. Both of them would be living in New York. Stark has an army of suits.


he isnt as strong as thor or hulk whatever but that has nothing to do with what started this conversation

Peter Parker would be so hugely overshadowed by every other superhero and it would be weird people like Reed or Stark don't help stop people Elektro despite living in the same city. Spider-Man works best in an isolated universe. He has powers, but he isn't that strong.

the way he has been portrayed in the movies compared to characters from other movies he is above cap, hawkeye, bw, wolverine and most the x men and i would argue loki aswell in a 1on1.

im not arguing anything about who would or could come to help or who is stronger but to say spiderman would be overshadowed based on the movies is i think crazy
 

The Hermit

Member
And, fuck...an inclusion in that poster that is a bit of a spoiler for the finale....don't like it...don't like it one bit...

was really hoping Ward would die....now they're going to go the full redemption route...

By now we should be all acepting that hes becoming Taskmaster, so yeah, that won't happen.

Trip is very "nice" in all his scenes, Coulson likes him, so I think hes going to die...

Maybe I am watching too much Game of Thrones, lol

Ps: pietorium if you want to talk abou spiderman power, make another topic
 

gazele

Banned
I hope he becomes taskmaster and is a grey mercenary character but I doubt it, same with Skye she'll probably be a new character too :-/
 

Htown

STOP SHITTING ON MY MOTHER'S HEADSTONE
Is the show really so terrible that everyone would rather talk about anything else except the show itself? Lol.

No.

Most people in the thread are fine with what the show's doing now. This is just an offshoot of an earlier conversation about the movie rights to other heroes possibly reverting to Marvel.
 
No.

Most people in the thread are fine with what the show's doing now. This is just an offshoot of an earlier conversation about the movie rights to other heroes possibly reverting to Marvel.

And since the show operates within the MCU, the conversation is still relevant to AoS anyways.
 

hamchan

Member
I've now caught up to the show and the last few episodes have actually been pretty good. Like, I actually care about more characters than just Coulson now.

Captain America 2 sure helped this show a lot huh?
 
So how long till either Coulson and his team or Carter and her team time travel and team up for a two part crossover "event"?
But not before initially fighting before realizing they're on the same side, of course.
 

Mariolee

Member
So how long till either Coulson and his team or Carter and her team time travel and team up for a two part crossover "event"?
But not before initially fighting before realizing they're on the same side, of course.

I'm thinking they'll somehow record something for Coulson and his team to help them ala Doctor Who.
 

Zen

Banned
Yeah even Peter himself has said it, and furthermore we have never seen Spider-Man go toe to toe with the Hulk or Thor. Thor and Hulk can go toe to toe against Juggernaut (regardless of who wins) and Spider-Man was only ever able to beat Juggernaut by tricking him into cement foundation. He was completely outmatched.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=topxx&id=5&pg=8

Is the show really so terrible that everyone would rather talk about anything else except the show itself? Lol.

Last episode sucked!
 

Zen

Banned
I think they said that once in the issue of what if spider-man kept the symbiote or something, but regardless it is a what if. Peter is very smart, but he is not Stark/Reed.
 

Gintamen

Member
Peter is not smarter than Stark. That has been established in many comic resources multiple times.
It's pretty funny how the smart guys make fun of Stark for thinking he's the smartest guy in the room though. Happened like two or three times in the last three months of comics.


In Iron Man 3 he solved the problem the girl was working on for many years in his one night drunken conquest to sleep with her.
It's not like she was anywhere near the tier of the real geniuses of the Marvel universe...
 

Zen

Banned
It's pretty funny how the smart guys make fun of Stark for thinking he's the smartest guy in the room though. Happened like two or three times in the last three months of comics.

The other smart guys just feel threatened by how accomplished and together Tony has his shit.

It's not like she was anywhere near the tier of the real geniuses of the Marvel universe...

She was obviously well above average intelligence and there are a handful of people on the scale you are talking about.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom