Zool 2 instead of Rayman or something is a questionable choice (Zool 2 is a DOS/Amiga port, so of course it's 16-bit style, while Rayman was a Jaguar original, and limited-time exclusive...), and Checkered Flag might have been better compared to Genesis Virtua Racing, 32X Virtua Racing Deluxe, or SNES (Super FX) Stunt Race FX, rather than Mode 7 F-Zero, but overall, pretty good. I mean, F-Zero clearly has better gameplay, graphics, and style than Checkered Flag, but wouldn't it be more fair to compare it to competing polyagonal racing games?
As for Star Fox vs. Cybermorph, Star Fox does clearly win on music (Cybermorph has none ingame...) and artistic design, but its abysmal framerate hurts it a lot, and he didn't mention that. Cybermorph's looks a bit higher, though it does also have a terribly close draw distance, and it's free-roaming instead of a rail shooter, so the gameplay is different. Haven't played it so I can't say how good it is... Star Fox is likely the better game, though, sure. But unless your cart's overclocked or you're playing it emulated, that awful framerate is brutal, like all polygonal 3d Super FX games.
Overall though, nice summation of Atari history, and a great leadin for the next video... definitely looking forward to it.
nincompoop said:
Are you fucking joking?! Iron Soldier looks no different than a SuperFX game. Meanwhile the 3DO was pumping out graphics like this
Could Jaguar do this, for example?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GGXytmFQHns
The Playstation, Saturn, and DOS PC couldn't, evidently, given that on all of those platforms the game has pea-soup fog blocking off your vision at about the point where on the 3DO it just drops the terrain detail... 3DO didn't do a good job of porting the game, sadly. I remember loving the PC version (despite the frustrating controls that take some time to get used to), but seeing that makes me want a 3DO... But anyway, I don't think Battlemorph, Iron Soldier, I-War, or the others can match that. Based on videos Battlemorph looks okay, but not quite that good, and with mostly just flat-shaded polygons thanks to hardware limitations.
Of course the 3DO did have the worst version of Doom thanks to an amazingly terrible framerate, so it wasn't all good.
(On that note, SNES Doom was surprisingly good, and is really fun... framerate's a bit slow, but it's playable. Great soundtrack, only pre-Xbox console version with the actual unaltered PC level designs, good gameplay, world map...)