FINE ZACH ILL USE YOUR GRADEZ
I'm mainly just trying to isolate out what I need to watch from 2004-now. It's a huge gap, but I know it's worth checking out stuff like the night Eddie wins or the Cena/Umaga Last Man Standing match
It would take a little work -- and I don't agree with everything (of course) -- but you could use cagematch.net for 2004 and beyond. There are user ratings for all of the shows.