weemadarthur
Member
Didn't you get the memo?
Godfathery claims were SO last season.
Go ahead and revote me to show your scumminess even more.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Arkham Asylum Mafia |OT| It's time to kill the Bat
- Thread starter franconp
- Start date
Didn't you get the memo?
Godfathery claims were SO last season.
Go ahead and revote me to show your scumminess even more.
Gladly.
Vote: weemadarthur
One of out of you and zipped is scum, and this seems incredibly made up.
You think time is scum?
Good on you for claiming I guess. Your role isn't too interesting though. Do you get informed if your BP is used up?
weemadarthur
Member
Yes. He is just trolling now.
Look at his last post, he thinks "doctor" is an unlikely claim, based on his adding things to it that don't actually exist.
Have you ever seen Timeaisis come to conclusions like that, seriously?
You literally just said you are a bat lookalike. How are we supposed to interpret that?
Maybe if you were actually clear with your town "team" instead of obfuscating literally everything about your role, this would be easier. But no, you continue to make this incredibly hard for us to read you.
AbsolutBro
Member
What is it with people in this game constantly putting words in people's mouthes?
it would help if the original words were clear in the first place
AbsolutBro
Member
No, I'm still suspicious of anyone who gave this many shits about a stupid name.
Cool, then lynch me after we resolve this weemad/zipped situation, how about that?
weemadarthur
Member
Maybe everyone who disobeys Rule 6 should be modkilled, and I can be the last person left in the game.
Is it so hard to tell my posts from zipped's posts?
I don't see how you could view weemad as being anything but purposefully obtuse for no reason
weemadarthur
Member
A bit from the wiki. About the character. Since zipped wants to get into flavor arguments as some sort of indication of alignment.
AbsolutBro
Member
Because weemadarthur had a reason, even posted it. Whether you agree with it or not is immaterial. Y'all are just pissed weemadarthur had the audacity to say no to the mob.
weemadarthur
Member
If you thought with the brain at the other end of your spine, you'd see that my MULTIPLE listed reasons are completely logical and pro town.
Alright, well spell it out for us.
Are you hush? Are you a doctor? Can you cure poison? Do you investigate as town or scum?
I don't understand why it's is so hard to be clear here. You've posted like 3 or 4 times without clearly stating anything.
weemadarthur
Member
Yes, answered earlier.
Yes, claimed since day 2
Yes, claimed in the first post i ever made in this game. [er...pretty sure it was that one]
If I was a miller, it would say that in my role card, right? Cause it doesn't say that. I am town. Just straight up town.
Have you even read the thread? All those answers were there.
If weemad is town, they're intentionally obfuscated their role name so that instead of hunting for scum, we've argued about their potential role name and what it means for the past two days. If they're town, instead of looking for scum or making a case against anyone else, they're protected their hide and refused to give us a name because they felt inclined to do so for their own (maybe legitimate reasons), but to the detriment of the town overall.
This is clear to me because we are still fucking talking about it right now.
Finally thank you. And yes, of course I've read the thread. You are just confusing. That's all.
weemadarthur
Member
Don't blame me for the stupid flavor argument discussion and the chasing after unnecessary data. It's an idiotic discussion to have had, and I have constantly tried to change the subject to something that matters.
@Lone Prodigy Are you asking for a replacement? Are you still playing?
@Flame & Fireblend Do you believe Bronx's role claim?
weemadarthur
Member
His hero is ynnny in Archer.
AbsolutBro
Member
Since it caught very little discussion, I figured I would point out Bronx is claiming BP in a game with two others claiming doctor. That doesn't strike anyone as unlikely, even if we all agree that one doctor is likely lying?
OK, so.
Most of what can be said about the 50/50 has been said I wager, besides more defenses and the like. It's very unlikely there are two people who can cure poison in a single game.
I just have one thing to ask of Sorian. This post you made shortly after Zipped claimed two days ago:
Is this implying that Natiko saw them as a poison doc when they used their ability? Or was this just a mix of the cop read and your reaction from Zipped's full claim?
Most of what can be said about the 50/50 has been said I wager, besides more defenses and the like. It's very unlikely there are two people who can cure poison in a single game.
I just have one thing to ask of Sorian. This post you made shortly after Zipped claimed two days ago:
Is this implying that Natiko saw them as a poison doc when they used their ability? Or was this just a mix of the cop read and your reaction from Zipped's full claim?
weemadarthur
Member
@Bronx What are you thinking at this point? Any role claims you believe/disbelieve?
@Sorian You gonna vote?
@Sorian You gonna vote?
Zippedpinhead
Member
Yes highly suspect, especially since we already had a role that gave out bullet proof, and penguin and his gamble for BP role
weemadarthur
Member
There are a lot of extra kills.
A poisoner
Robin got a bonus, under circumstances
Splinter caused a double lynch
There is a serial killer/lyncher.
I'm not sure about him being BP, but I believe him more than I believe Timeasis claiming to be bulletproof. Even if unnatural. He has obfuscated what he meant by it though.
I don't understand the question? I was just reporting that Natiko and I were leaning town on his role name and by this point in the game, the result didn't really matter to me anymore.
Sure
VOTE: Flame_AC
What I meant was, from that comment, it sounded like you knew he was going to claim poison doc as well or something (where you say 'you get poison doc' and 'I was lightly reading it as town')
I figured it was just part of the conversation, otherwise.
weemadarthur
Member
XD
Maybe I don't at that. I won't even try to argue with you on exactly correct role terms and game design.
Anyway you claimed an extra killing ability.
Maybe I don't at that. I won't even try to argue with you on exactly correct role terms and game design.
Anyway you claimed an extra killing ability.
Oh, no I was saying I lightly read the name itself as town and the "you get poison doc" was just me reiterating his claim before getting to my point. On a base level, poison docs are usually town so maybe I sprinkled some of that in there sub consciously.
gotcha, just checking
Lone_Prodigy
Member
LP
weemad - Hush, doctor
Fireblend
Bronx - Bane, BP
Flame - Freeze, RB
Penguin - Penguin, gambler
Time - can't remember, thunderdome
AB - Riddler, watcher
Faddy - can't remember, lynch bomb
Fat - Anarky, override
Sorian - Joker, neutral killer
Zipped - Batmite, poison doc
weemad - Hush, doctor
Fireblend
Bronx - Bane, BP
Flame - Freeze, RB
Penguin - Penguin, gambler
Time - can't remember, thunderdome
AB - Riddler, watcher
Faddy - can't remember, lynch bomb
Fat - Anarky, override
Sorian - Joker, neutral killer
Zipped - Batmite, poison doc
So it seems like A_B's role claim stands up.
I still don't believe weemad though which means that unless A_B was lying about the night 2 self target, which I have no reason to doubt now at all there needs to be some scenario where scum would target themselves. As much as I want to be critical of A_B's play I can't see any real scenario where he is scum now.
So that brings us to our alleged doctor. Could Nudull have been poisoned on night 1? And cured himself night 2? Yes. Does this make him town? No.
However what it leads me to believe is that Zipped is lying and he is the poisoner looking to get a potential poison doc out of the way before he strikes again. So neutral, not scum.
Which then begs the question as who the hell is scum. Possibly weemad.
Not me, Fat, A_B, Flame (who I am inclined to believe). Leaving L_P, Fireblend, Time and Bronx and Penguin who both claim some sort of Bulletproof.
I still don't believe weemad though which means that unless A_B was lying about the night 2 self target, which I have no reason to doubt now at all there needs to be some scenario where scum would target themselves. As much as I want to be critical of A_B's play I can't see any real scenario where he is scum now.
So that brings us to our alleged doctor. Could Nudull have been poisoned on night 1? And cured himself night 2? Yes. Does this make him town? No.
However what it leads me to believe is that Zipped is lying and he is the poisoner looking to get a potential poison doc out of the way before he strikes again. So neutral, not scum.
Which then begs the question as who the hell is scum. Possibly weemad.
Not me, Fat, A_B, Flame (who I am inclined to believe). Leaving L_P, Fireblend, Time and Bronx and Penguin who both claim some sort of Bulletproof.
We are waiting for you and Fireblend to claim iirc.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
List of players and arguments for town/scum
weemad
town - having a doctor makes sense
scum - counter-claimed by Zipped, no actual successful protection, stubborn play style which has dominated conversation
Bronx
town - uh
scum - convenient and easy claim, scum won't touch him
Flame
town - blocked Sorian
scum - blocked Sorian
Penguin
town - quiet, unassuming, no reason to lie
scum - quiet, unassuming, convenient and easy claim, no way of verifying
Time
town - claimed ability happened when he said he would
scum - interesting choices for thunderdome
AB
town - no counter-claim
scum - no useful results, could be a scum role
Faddy
town - generally active
scum - claim prevents death, could be a scum role
Fat
town - claimed ability happened when he said it would
scum - uh, still alive?
Sorian
town - lol
scum - lol
Zipped
town - having a poison doc makes sense
scum - counter-claimed by weemad, no actual successful save
weemad
town - having a doctor makes sense
scum - counter-claimed by Zipped, no actual successful protection, stubborn play style which has dominated conversation
Bronx
town - uh
scum - convenient and easy claim, scum won't touch him
Flame
town - blocked Sorian
scum - blocked Sorian
Penguin
town - quiet, unassuming, no reason to lie
scum - quiet, unassuming, convenient and easy claim, no way of verifying
Time
town - claimed ability happened when he said he would
scum - interesting choices for thunderdome
AB
town - no counter-claim
scum - no useful results, could be a scum role
Faddy
town - generally active
scum - claim prevents death, could be a scum role
Fat
town - claimed ability happened when he said it would
scum - uh, still alive?
Sorian
town - lol
scum - lol
Zipped
town - having a poison doc makes sense
scum - counter-claimed by weemad, no actual successful save
Lone_Prodigy
Member
I'm a minion.
who do you kneel before?
You are claiming vanilla. I don't believe you.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
I wouldn't expect you to.
Time to claim friendo
weemadarthur
Member
@LP
It should be noted perhaps that zipped did not in any way counterclaim me. I counter claimed him because he role claimed part of my role.
Now, would you like to offer your actual thoughts on who is actually scum? Random arguments are not very helpful for us to read you.
It should be noted perhaps that zipped did not in any way counterclaim me. I counter claimed him because he role claimed part of my role.
Now, would you like to offer your actual thoughts on who is actually scum? Random arguments are not very helpful for us to read you.