It definitely makes sense that comrades who lived alongside Bertholdt and Reiner would want to talk and reason things out, but I like how Mikasa is consistently the one who will go "who cares?" and just want to kill them and get it done with. She was the same in the Annie confrontation. Besides her obsession with Eren, she also got her life destroyed a second time by the titans. She pretty much has as much wrath as Eren does.
I thought Armin was about to kill Berthodlt for a sec. I guess the psychological angle is still his thing, though, but I thought that's where it was going to go with "abandoning something."
Obviously wasn't expecting Erwin to get caught like that. And then, instead of everyone losing their motivation with that, they are pushed forward and to their deaths by the commander who stays headstrong even in that situation. Cool scene. Can't help but wonder if he's gonna have his arm grow back, though.