• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Attack on Titan (Shingeki no Kyojin) |OT| MMA Ultra(spider)man (NO MANGA SPOILERS)

Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MilkBeard

Member
Finally watched the last episode of Attack On Titan. Overall, I really enjoyed the anime, despite a few minor flaws. Really the biggest issue I have with the series is unexplained things/ missed potential. I feel like the entire show moved so fast and that they could have spent another season or two filling in some back story or gaps in things that are unexplained. Perhaps if more seasons are announced, they will go into greater detail.

But really, this anime had me on my toes, and I think it was episode five when I think I....nearly shat myself. I definitely want to see more of those kind of surprises.

For now I'm gonna go and see if there are other anime that can fill the void. I watched the first episode of Kill la Kill, and I enjoyed it, but it's really not my style. Too ridiculous. I like shows that are more along the lines of Attack on Titan with a focused story and plot development. I'm gonna try Sword Art Online to see what that's all about.
 
E

Elfforkusu

Member
Reporting in to say that after you people's collective hype over this thing wore me down over the course of the last few months, I just watched this whole damn series over the last week or so. I'd read a few random manga chapters of Attack on Titan, but it had never draw my interest. All the characters look the same, all the characters die. Well, the anime fixed the first one...

Episodes 5-8 were incredible, and while the rest of the show didn't match that, it was still excellent.

Watching it over such a short time frame, I'd say any pacing complaints felt extremely dubious. Soundtrack complaints were also dubious, since it was pretty awesome. Really solid show all around. Hopefully they can get a 2nd season going as soon as the manga provides enough material.

Also, Levi is awesome
 
M

MilkBeard

Member
Elfforkusu said:
Reporting in to say that after you people's collective hype over this thing wore me down over the course of the last few months, I just watched this whole damn series over the last week or so. I'd read a few random manga chapters of Attack on Titan, but it had never draw my interest. All the characters look the same, all the characters die. Well, the anime fixed the first one...

Episodes 5-8 were incredible, and while the rest of the show didn't match that, it was still excellent.

Watching it over such a short time frame, I'd say any pacing complaints felt extremely dubious. Soundtrack complaints were also dubious, since it was pretty awesome. Really solid show all around. Hopefully they can get a 2nd season going as soon as the manga provides enough material.

Also, Levi is awesome
Click to expand...

Yeah, I was hoping for another gut wrenching moment like in Episode 5 but it didn't quite happen. That was definitely the peak of the show for me. However, the rest of the show was good and it really picked up during the big Survey Corps operation. And yeah, Levi is a badass.
 
E

Elfforkusu

Member
MilkBeard said:
Yeah, I was hoping for another gut wrenching moment like in Episode 5 but it didn't quite happen. That was definitely the peak of the show for me. However, the rest of the show was good and it really picked up during the big Survey Corps operation. And yeah, Levi is a badass.
Click to expand...
I say 5 through 8, because the gut-wrenching moment in 5 is almost perfectly balanced by
Mikasa's reaction
at the end of episode 8.

There's a quote from the Count of Monte Cristo: "There is neither happiness nor misery in the world; there is only the comparison of one state with another, nothing more."

It's certainly 100% true in storytelling.
 
M

MilkBeard

Member
Elfforkusu said:
I say 5 through 8, because the gut-wrenching moment in 5 is almost perfectly balanced by
Mikasa's reaction
at the end of episode 8.

There's a quote from the Count of Monte Cristo: "There is neither happiness nor misery in the world; there is only the comparison of one state with another, nothing more."

It's certainly 100% true in storytelling.
Click to expand...

I can't remember exactly, but I think you're talking about when
she says "the world is cruel."
Yeah, that part hit home for me as well, in a sort of philosophical sort of way. If that's not what you're talking about, then you'll have to remind me.
 
K

kirblar

Member
MilkBeard said:
Yeah, I was hoping for another gut wrenching moment like in Episode 5 but it didn't quite happen. That was definitely the peak of the show for me. However, the rest of the show was good and it really picked up during the big Survey Corps operation. And yeah, Levi is a badass.
Click to expand...
Episode 21 is pretty insane.
 
E

Elfforkusu

Member
MilkBeard said:
I can't remember exactly, but I think you're talking about when
she says "the world is cruel."
Yeah, that part hit home for me as well, in a sort of philosophical sort of way. If that's not what you're talking about, then you'll have to remind me.
Click to expand...
The scene where Eren emerges from his Titan and she completely breaks down.
Remarkably well done. Also, the music for that scene is perfect... and it doesn't seem to be part of the standard OST. smh.
 
U

ultron87

Member
Of all the acrobatics in the show I think my favorite is still this little ground slide move Mikasa does right before Eren seals the wall. It just feels a lot more physical and real than some of the more high flying stuff she and Levi do later on.
 
L

Limit

Member
Ryan Gosling said:
Cant wait for a another season. Now my sundays feel empty without SnK. Any anime with the same sadness and epicness?
Click to expand...

There are a bunch.

1. Blassreiter. Here is the entire series, courtesy of funimation. Lots of gloom and some good action scenes.

2. Deadman Wonderland: Another recent great show with tons of despair. Keep in mind that unlike Blassreiter, this story is not complete. And so far there is no season 2 in sight.

3. Btoom: The intro tone of this show is likely to put some people off because the pathetic backstory of the protagonist may hit a little too close to home. The main character is a bum who spends all his time playing videogames, negating any and all family responsibilities. If you can get over that, there is a good story to be seen here. The protagonist definitely evolves over time. Like deadman wonderland, some plot here is left hanging and there is no season 2 on the horizon so far.


This should be enough for now. You can start going back in time and there are dozens of more shows with dark undertones to be found. There is code geass, Black Lagoon, Ghost in the Shell, etc.
 
R

Ryan Gosling

Member
Limit said:
There are a bunch.

1. Blassreiter. Here is the entire series, courtesy of funimation. Lots of gloom and some good action scenes.

2. Deadman Wonderland: Another recent great show with tons of despair. Keep in mind that unlike Blassreiter, this story is not complete. And so far there is no season 2 in sight.

3. Btoom: The intro tone of this show is likely to put some people off because the pathetic backstory of the protagonist may hit a little too close to home. The main character is a bum who spends all his time playing videogames, negating any and all family responsibilities. If you can get over that, there is a good story to be seen here. The protagonist definitely evolves over time. Like deadman wonderland, some plot here is left hanging and there is no season 2 on the horizon so far.


This should be enough for now. You can start going back in time and there are dozens of more shows with dark undertones to be found. There is code geass, Black Lagoon, Ghost in the Shell, etc.
Click to expand...

Thanks, i will check them out.
 
F

FluxWaveZ

Member
Limit said:
3. Btoom: The intro tone of this show is likely to put some people off because the pathetic backstory of the protagonist may hit a little too close to home. The main character is a bum who spends all his time playing videogames, negating any and all family responsibilities. If you can get over that, there is a good story to be seen here. The protagonist definitely evolves over time. Like deadman wonderland, some plot here is left hanging and there is no season 2 on the horizon so far.
Click to expand...

Heh, the protagonist's backstory hitting close to home is part of the reason I love Welcome to the NHK so much. Thanks for the recommendation; I've never heard of this one before despite it being pretty recent.
 
T

ThatCrazyGuy

Member
Finally saw the last episode. The series has its hooks in me. Im even being a weirdo about wanting Eren and Mikasa finally go the next step. Felt sad at the credits. Have to wait so long for more episodes. I will probably end up just reading the manga.
 
X

xkramz

Member
AoT IMO has the best OST in a anime that i ever heard. it gets you emotionally involved with the character and makes you want to rewind the scene again and again.
 
M

Mockingbird

Member
Ryan Gosling said:
Cant wait for a another season. Now my sundays feel empty without SnK. Any anime with the same sadness and epicness?
Click to expand...

Blue Gender: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=ELJc-qump5lbk you have a choice of sub or dub.

The themes are the same. Humanity is in a losing fight against a force that one day came out of nowhere. The odds of victory are so slim and people die. It's a really good show and finished in 26 episodes. Not as epic because the attack on titan director is one who specializes in epicness where every little action is epic, but it's a great show.
 
D

Dabanton

Member
After waiting ages I finally got to watch all 25 episodes over two days which was a much more enjoyable way to enjoy this show.

This was my first anime in a long long time as I fell out of love with it as nothing was really catching my attention and some of the tropes became a bit too much.

Not that SnK doesn't deal in some of those things but it's general premise was good. And the first episode was actually quite horrific. The titans are actually effectively creepy. Just seeing them eat people quite happily chilled the blood.

Overall I found it quite good. The mystery was handled well even the infamous episode 5 had me on the edge of my seat. But it I actually think the
female titan
arc was more interesting even though it was obvious who it was,it still managed to keep the central mystery going.
 
K

kiyomi

Member
Dabanton said:
Not that SnK doesn't deal in some of those things but it's general premise was good. And the first episode was actually quite horrific. The titans are actually effectively creepy. Just seeing them eat people quite happily chilled the blood.

Overall I found it quite good. The mystery was handled well even the infamous episode 5 had me on the edge of my seat. But it I actually think the
female titan
arc was more interesting even though it was obvious who it was,it still managed to keep the central mystery going.
Click to expand...

This was actually one of my biggest disappointment with the show. I should rewatch the first couple of episodes again, but the sense of mystery seemed so far greater initially, and the Titans were actually feared, although that was probably more of a result of the childhood/training arc. The Titans became increasingly less creepy, we saw less of the gorey monstrosities that they were in the initial first few episodes, and it got to the point where half of them looked like comic relief running around the forest.

It was only after the point you reference in your spoiler, where the
female Titan makes an appearance
Titans actually got interesting again.
 
I

Irminsul

Member
Monosukoi said:
This was actually one of my biggest disappointment with the show. I should rewatch the first couple of episodes again, but the sense of mystery seemed so far greater initially, and the Titans were actually feared, although that was probably more of a result of the childhood/training arc. The Titans became increasingly less creepy, we saw less of the gorey monstrosities that they were in the initial first few episodes, and it got to the point where half of them looked like comic relief running around the forest.
Click to expand...
I've personally never got that feeling, as there never was much progress in dealing with the Titans. Temporary "victories", sure, but in the end, basically everything ended in a defeat for the humans. I've actually think that's positive, as I feared they'd be capable of slaying Titans like nothing in the end. But they didn't.
 
K

kiyomi

Member
TUSR said:
People sure love to complain about this show.
Click to expand...

It had its' ups and downs. Mostly downs after an interesting start.

Irminsul said:
I've personally never got that feeling, as there never was much progress in dealing with the Titans. Temporary "victories", sure, but in the end, basically everything ended in a defeat for the humans. I've actually think that's positive, as I feared they'd be capable of slaying Titans like nothing in the end. But they didn't.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I guess I'm talking more about the way in which they're sheerly represented. You're right about them being almost pyrrhic victories in which there are heavy losses for seemingly not much gain. Nothing was really "dealt with", as you say, but it just felt like they were a little more intimidating earlier on.
 
V

VivaciousSoul

Member
The crew has gotten better at beating up some titans but this is only inside of the walls or in the giant forest. I hope there's another occasion for everyone to go again to Titanville away from the safety of all the buildings and trees on nothing but flat level ground for as far as the eye can see and see what the crew thinks of their progress then.

I can't see them winning this fight without harnessing the power. Which power is obvious to everyone who has seen all the episodes released so far.
 
G

ghstwrld

Member
Now that it's over, it's totally clear how much stuff in the second OP is hidden in plain sight; the part where Annie's covered in blood rain is so brazen. *.*
 
C

Crash Station

Member
Dabanton said:
This was my first anime in a long long time as I fell out of love with it as nothing was really catching my attention and some of the tropes became a bit too much.
Click to expand...

I'm sure some of those tropes are completely absent in many anime series, even modern ones. You could always ask for recommendations in the seasonal anime thread if you care to try and get back into the medium.
 
S

Superflat

Member
Lack of Potato Girl after the first half :T

I was completely enraptured up to episode 6, which was extremely effective at subverting your expectations if you didn't know what you were in for.

The
return of Eren and the ability to turn into Titans
sort of had me disappointed initially. I really liked the initial premise of humans doing everything in their ability in a futile attempt to scrap together whatever humanity has left for themselves.
But then they introduce giant titan on titan fights, none of which to me were all that interesting in comparison to humans outsmarting Titans.
I wasn't sure if I liked that direction (I still kinda don't know if I'm 100% behind it), but whatever, that's not what the creator intended, and I respect that.

I'm still anticipating what's coming up and I enjoyed the series thoroughly, despite a few pacing issues in the middle.
 
N

Nibel

Member
Titan Bros, after fellow Gaffer kirbler recommended Hunter X Hunter to me, I can say: this is legit

The arc which I'm watching now (Chimera Ant arc) feels really a lot like Attack On Titan from the sheer brutality and the situation the humans are in; and all the other arcs until then are really excellent since most stuff doesn't play out like you think. It kind of feels like a more intelligent Dragon Ball to me; and I really do appreciate the adventure aspect of this show

It really is a great show and I hope that will kill the thirst of some of you!
 
F

FluxWaveZ

Member
Nibel said:
Titan Bros, after fellow Gaffer kirbler recommended Hunter X Hunter to me, I can say: this is legit
Click to expand...

Last time I followed a recommendation from this thread I ended up watching Btooom! and I loved it, so I might as well continue with Hunter X Hunter since people have always been talking about it in this thread.

Was certainly intrigued after episode 1, though I didn't feel as though it would turn out to be anything special just from that.
 
R

rexor0717

Member
ghstwrld said:
Now that it's over, it's totally clear how much stuff in the second OP is hidden in plain sight; the part where Annie's covered in blood rain is so brazen. *.*
Click to expand...

I'm not going to say anything detailed, but the anime does make some things...really obvious.
 
N

Nibel

Member
FluxWaveZ said:
Was certainly intrigued after episode 1, though I didn't feel as though it would turn out to be anything special just from that.
Click to expand...

Watch a few more episodes - the first arc deals with the hunter exam which is pretty cool and well made, but the anime gets into god-tier territory in the second arc
 
S

Soriku

Junior Member
FluxWaveZ said:
Last time I followed a recommendation from this thread I ended up watching Btooom! and I loved it, so I might as well continue with Hunter X Hunter since people have always been talking about it in this thread.

Was certainly intrigued after episode 1, though I didn't feel as though it would turn out to be anything special just from that.
Click to expand...

You ain't seen nothin yet.
 
K

kirblar

Member
FluxWaveZ said:
Last time I followed a recommendation from this thread I ended up watching Btooom! and I loved it, so I might as well continue with Hunter X Hunter since people have always been talking about it in this thread.

Was certainly intrigued after episode 1, though I didn't feel as though it would turn out to be anything special just from that.
Click to expand...
You kinda have to get past the first 26 eps or so for the series to reveal what it's really doing.

Not that they're bad, but they're intentionally sort of formulaic.
 
A

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Kiryu said:
I ordered 1-7 volume of Attack on Titan books. Is there anything different from anime?
Click to expand...

Its more graphic (mostly when Titans eat people) and the author's art style is pretty rough.
 
C

Crash Station

Member
Nibel said:
Titan Bros, after fellow Gaffer kirbler recommended Hunter X Hunter to me, I can say: this is legit

The arc which I'm watching now (Chimera Ant arc) feels really a lot like Attack On Titan from the sheer brutality and the situation the humans are in; and all the other arcs until then are really excellent since most stuff doesn't play out like you think. It kind of feels like a more intelligent Dragon Ball to me; and I really do appreciate the adventure aspect of this show

It really is a great show and I hope that will kill the thirst of some of you!
Click to expand...

You should post in the OT if you're caught up.
 
N

Nibel

Member
cosmicblizzard said:
You should post in the OT if you're caught up.
Click to expand...

I'll join you guys as soon as I'm at 98 - I'm reading the earlier pages of that thread and it's fun to read the reactions of people who watched each episode at their releases

Fucked x Fucked is a valid description of the CA arc :lol

Enough of HxH though, sorry for derailment, but it's a good show if Titan made you thirsty for more quality anime
 
T

titiklabingapat

Member
FluxWaveZ said:
Last time I followed a recommendation from this thread I ended up watching Btooom! and I loved it, so I might as well continue with Hunter X Hunter since people have always been talking about it in this thread.

Was certainly intrigued after episode 1, though I didn't feel as though it would turn out to be anything special just from that.
Click to expand...

Goddamn, I'm jealous. What I would give to watch HxH for the first time again (especially with 99 episodes now)!
 
Tizoc

Tizoc

Member
When will the next season air? Honestly with the way this season ended, I'm better off watching all eps. in one go, but I really do hope the author can wrap up the series within the next few years.

As is though, and I know I asked before but I don't feel like re-reading the manga from the start:
Which chapter continues from the events of Season 2's finale please?

Ryan Gosling said:
Cant wait for a another season. Now my sundays feel empty without SnK. Any anime with the same sadness and epicness?
Click to expand...

Sadness? Def. Watamote, dunno about Epic but it's crazy awesome.
 
S

Soriku

Junior Member
Tizoc said:
When will the next season air? Honestly with the way this season ended, I'm better off watching all eps. in one go, but I really do hope the author can wrap up the series within the next few years.

As is though, and I know I asked before but I don't feel like re-reading the manga from the start:
Which chapter continues from the events of Season 2's finale please?
Click to expand...

A second season hasn't been announced yet so who knows.

Start reading from chapter 33 or so.
 
A

Arksy

Member
Hey, I just want on a 3 month trip. I watched up until the end of that battle back in episode 8 or something.
Everyone was threatening the main character because he was a titan.
Worth getting back into?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Attack on Titan - Season 4 Part 3 Part 1 - ANIME ONLY Discussion Thread, no manga hints/impressions
30
3K
Edge Lord replied
Chainsaw Man |OT| True Best Friends Kick Devil Balls Together
2
84
9K
Doom85 replied
Mobile Suit Gundam: The Witch from Mercury |OT| This witch rides a Gundam (Up: Season 2 now airing!)
|OT| 2 3 4
150
14K
The Sum of Zero replied
Lara Croft Crowned Most Iconic Video Games Character of All Time, According to BAFTA Poll
2 3 4 5
208
14K
ResurrectedContrarian replied
Spider-Man 2 Prequel Comic Spoilers
Spoilers
3
1K
LordCBH replied
Top Bottom