Yeah Raw has better talent but SD not only utilizes their roster better but, like stated, it's being written by the guy who used to write NXT. It makes more sense as a whole. For example, let's take this week's SD episode. Here's a few parts:
- Pre-intro segment shows Styles egging Ziggler on after the Ambrose loss, fight breaks out
- 10min opening segment that sets up 4 storylines: Ziggler/Styles again, tag team tourney for the new belts, women tourney for the new belt and Slater's whole thing
- All through the night they had matches in both tourneys which shows progression with each talent, Ascension looked tough, Breezango looked better than ever, AA looked great
- Another Styles/Ziggler showing which sets up a challenge for Ambrose's belt also a match from them later, made this seem more like a real feud given they've had 3 real segments about them already that were short and sweet. 4 if you count their match and the Ambrose staredown at the end
Here's a big reason why SD is better
- Carmella/Nikki...Carmella turns on Nikki which makes perfect sense. Carmella was a struggling babyface after only 1 month and they realized this, turned her heel and she's instantly better going against Nikki, the returning babyface who's still very popular. Unlike with Reigns on Raw and others, they immediately turned Carmella. She's more comfortable in this role too. Hell, the Usos are teasing a heel turn themselves which also makes sense.
It's stuff like that which is why it's better. Constant progression and common sense really. If Reigns was on SD (and Vince said they could do what they want with him), Reigns would be a heel, Cesaro would be in a main event spot (or about to be) and it would be great. Styles is killing it on SD and while he was killing it before, we know this man will not only be champion but he's got guys like Cena, Ambrose and Orton to work off of. With Reigns? It was great but idk about anyone else, I always looked at it as "ok he's being used to put Reigns over" type of situation. Here? Given he went over Cena? I think "man they love this guy he's getting his shot with main eventers like Ambrose and Cena", I feel he'll be more respected from a writing standpoint rather than being used as a placeholder on Raw.
Besides that, it's 2hrs compared to 3hrs. When I watch SD I think "wow it's over?" but when I watch Raw I think "thank god it's over."