It's work for hire. They were paid for their stuff originally. Remember that when they decide to do a movie based on Legend of Spyro. It would be nice. Lots of things would be nice.
also- If Star Wars Ep VIII does well, will you be as pissed that George Lucas gets zip from that?
Yeah it's murky for me and I'm well aware my views on work for hire are very contradictory
It just kinda gets me when I hear that the creators of the characters / stories that get turned into huge things get nothing. Reprinting the comic in collections is one thing (which, funnily enough, thanks to the more progressive deals at Marvel / DC these days, they
do get a cut of) but when it's transformed into something else entirely it just gets weird to me. That's when it's ethically (NOT legally - quite rightly, the company the creator did the work for hire for has no legal obligation whatsoever) the right thing for the company to acknowledge the creators input financially or (more importantly to me), even as a credit.
It didn't bother me that, say, Eugene Jarvis didn't get a cent from the XBLA re-release of Smash TV, but fuck it made me angry his name was removed from the credits. That's just fucking low in my book.
Work For Hire (to me) is the Venn diagram point where creator rights, law and money intersect, and it'll never be satisfactory to everyone, but I'll always be on the side of the creator.
Lucas and Star Wars is kind of different though. He sold a pre-existing work that he owned to another company. If he made the original movies for Disney originally it would be more akin to this.
FAKE EDIT: But Gazunta, why are you so anti-X-Men movies but so madly in love with the Marvel Cinematic Universe? Well...coz a) as stated above, I'm a hypocrite and b) I hear all sorts of stories about Disney / Marvel quietly taking care of the artists that have their works used as the basis for the films / TV shows, so...uh...hmm.
Anyway. Kids. Work For Hire - READ UP ABOUT IT BEFORE YOU SIGN. I'm glad I knew about it growing up watching Kirby fight for his rights, and people like Dave Sim and Eastman & Laird show that you don't have to sign everything away to get results, and to know what you're getting into beforehand.
Man I'm glad that Spyro movie never got made though