The E60 performed a lot better than the E39. Had a better interior too.
It just looked a little off...
Some people just love a bit of nostalgia.
As an all round package the e60 stomps all over the e39 and pretty much every other super-saloon that's ever existed.
Disagree. The E39 is more enjoyable to drive. The problem with the E60 is that it has an amazing motor but the motor wasn't suited to such a heavy car. That motor should've gone in something else. Like the E92 M3, lol. I prefer the E39 M5's driving dynamics and the way the motor is in tune with the chassis. It's blissful.
And no, the 2nd gen CTS-V devours the E60 M5. The ONLY way I'll ever pick up an E60 M5 is if I can find one with a 6-speed. That SMG II trans is garbage IMO.