I like it.
Weekends: Singer 911, 911RS, 650S
Daily: Macan S Diesel, 1M/135i
Winter Beaters: Focus RS, V60 Polestar
Hauling duty: Ram 2500 Cummins Laramie
-------------------------------------------------
On a slightly related note, over the past few weeks I've driven a few things in my budget for our second car. I had my list narrowed down to: G35/37 Coupe, BRZ/FRS, 128i, 135i, RX8, and 328i X Drive (E90). I'm pretty much sold on the 128i. I know what to look for, I know what I'm getting into. The 135i I like more, obviously, but not enough to warrant more expensive fixes and a higher entry price. I think the 128i might be the best kept secret when it comes to affordable fun coupes. Less weight than the 135i, hydraulic steering, great sounding engine, super reliable engine, and a very simple interior that has everything you need in a driver's car.
I know matmanx hasn't had a great experience, but that sort of stuff isn't as big of a deal for me as I'd only be putting 4-6k miles a year on it.
If the manual didn't feel like shit, I would have opted for the G35/37, as I'm familiar with the longevity of that engine from my EX35. The 1 series just felt so damn good. I'd like a slightly tighter shifter, and the suspension tightened up a bit as it'd be a second car.
Also, just passed 6k miles on the 2500 Cummins. Thing just devours miles, moves anyone out of the way, and is so comfy. I did 12 hours of driving in one day, barely any fatigue at all. The road presence is pretty great too.
Get the 135i. By far the best of all those cars. It's really not that unreliable. And you'll love Juivvebox 4 and 400-500 wtq