• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Autumn Anime 2015 |OT| Like leaves on a tree… we’re falling one by one.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are just jealous because you didn't think of the beam sabre jacuzzi first.


Well...I guess I just don't believe that love can bloom on the battlefield like you Otacons can.
1.0
 
Lupin III 2015 02

This still isn't terribly exciting but it still looks really good. I am curious to see what others think once people start watching it though. I think I am actually enjoying the old ass Part 1 series more.
 
Have you perhaps forgotten everything that's happened in the first episode?

Oh I remember the first episode. How they save each other in space.

I still think their actions towards the end are ridiculous even by Gundam standards. Especially since this is a more grounded Gundam series.
 
Sakurako-san 02

I liked this episode. For a moment I thought that cop was Sakurako's
fiancee
but I guess not. We also got a glimpse of Sakurako's past with Shoutarou. She never calls him by name, but this time she did. Just what is their relationship? Also isn't the VA for the child in this case the same one that voiced Naru from Barakamon?
 

Firemind

Member
Oh I remember the first episode. How they save each other in space.

I still think their actions towards the end are ridiculous even by Gundam standards. Especially since this is a more grounded Gundam series.
It's not Gundam without escalation.

Actually, that applies to any mecha series.
 
Sakurako-san 02

I liked this episode. For a moment I thought that cop was Sakurako's
fiancee
but I guess not. We also got a glimpse of Sakurako's past with Shoutarou. She never calls him by name, but this time she did. Just what is their relationship? Also isn't the VA for the child in this case the same one that voiced Naru from Barakamon?
That flashback was of a different person. She calls out Soutarou, not Shoutarou. Similar names, but that's probably why she calls him boy.
 
It's not Gundam without escalation.

Actually, that applies to any mecha series.

There's a difference between escalation, and characters acting erratically.

They start out trying to kill each other in the beginning, save each other, go back to trying to kill each other, and then fall in love when they meet up again.

It's nonsense. It's the worst type of romance, the cliche I'm fallen for the enemy romance. And then they go on to get other people they're close to killed because they need to be together.
 
I thought this was me mistaking what she said with a faulty translation. Well damn. Maybe spoiler tag it for other folks, this may be plot relevant.

EDIT: As for that last part on your edit, that would make a lot of sense actually.

I rewatched those scenes and the names are definitely pronounced differently.
 

Firemind

Member
There's a difference between escalation, and characters acting erratically.

They start out trying to kill each other in the beginning, save each other, go back to trying to kill each other, and then fall in love when they meet up again.

It's nonsense. It's the worst type of romance, the cliche I'm fallen for the enemy romance. And then they go on to get other people they're close to killed because they need to be together.
What can be described as erratic?

He's infatuated with her. Ergo he tries to save her life a second time after he finds out about the identity of the pilot. Then he confesses in the heat of the moment. It's not like Aina has anything to live for. She's being used as a puppet and she desires to be free. She also cares for her people, more than her own life, as shown in the last act so I don't know what you're on about.
 
I rewatched those scenes and the names are definitely pronounced differently.

And just like that things have gotten even more mysterious thanks to you. I went back to the OP
and noticed how, close to end of it when it shows Sakurako in the house, you see her looking out the window and she sees what seems like a younger Shoutarou. Then we also see Shoutarou going after a younger version of Sakurako. We are then brought back to the house, and she's trying to get out while these butterflies (something that killer kept talking about this episode, so it may be something bigger than we think) are flying around
. I feel like I need to start paying more attention to this show because we are being given little tidbits of info everywhere.
 
What can be described as erratic?

He's infatuated with her. Ergo he tries to save her life a second time after he finds out about the identity of the pilot. Then he confesses in the heat of the moment. It's not like Aina has anything to live for. She's being used as a puppet and she desires to be free. She also cares for her people, more than her own life, as shown in the last act so I don't know what you're on about.

Their romance is nonsense because their love quickly dissolves all the rationality these characters had before. You talk about how Aina loved her people, but she flat out abandons them at the end to be with Shiro. Shiro flat out ignores his comrade's safety because he wants to be with Aina that much. Their love is so strong that they forget they're in the middle of a war!

It's directly weakens theme the series was setting up. War up to that point killed people regardless of how good or evil they were, whether or not they were loved. The only difference was that Shiro and Aina's are the main characters, and therefore of course their love is special. So special that they abandon everything around them for their love.

And I think that's a shit romance right there. A romance that actively makes me dislike the two leads. A romance that takes away from the brutality of war the show had established up to that point.
 

Cornbread78

Member
Their romance is nonsense because their love quickly dissolves all the rationality these characters had before. You talk about how Aina loved her people, but she flat out abandons them at the end to be with Shiro. Shiro flat out ignores his comrade's safety because he wants to be with Aina that much. Their love is so strong that they forget they're in the middle of a war!
War up to that point killed people regardless of how good or evil they were, whether or not they were loved. The only difference was that Shiro and Aina's are the main characters, and therefore of course their love is special. So special that they abandon everything around them for their love.
A romance that takes away from the brutality of war the show had established up to that point.

I don't have any clue what series your talking about, but that sounds like an amazing plotline for a romance.
 
I don't have any clue what series your talking about, but that sounds like an amazing plotline for a romance.

It could be for you. Good romance, like good comedy, is very subjective.

All I know is that I finished Mobile Suit Gundam: The 08th MS Team thinking how much I hated the two main leads, and how much more interesting some of the side characters were.
 
Yokai Watch dub 6

Did Disney XD just air a cartoon where the main protagonist and his friends watch porn on a kids network? And air it unedited?
 

Phatmac

Member
A decent episode for our favorite stalker gorilla. The impact is kinda lost as it seems like a parody of Gintoki's past story with his sensei. It at least makes us remember that Kondo is a strong samurai despite being treated as comic relief character. It still hit me a bit hard at the end so it was fine. I'm not really digging the op as the animation makes it feel like an ed instead. The ed is still amazing and it probably should've been the op as the song is much better. Excited for Afro shinsengumi next week.
 

Cornbread78

Member
Sakurako ep.2
Wow, that was an excellent episode and much better than the first. Boy Bruce Lee coming through. I guess we will get some backstory for Sakurako moving forward. Good stuff.
 
Sakurako-san 02

Ohhh now this episode was great. Significantly better than the first and the exact kinda this I like out of my mystery/detective shows. Especially liked the part where she noticed the injury on the child's arm and explained the way it works. Also got to see a bit into Sakurako's past, I have an idea where its going as well. The bumbling police letting her do whatever she wants doesn't bother because most detective/PI stories have had this element throughout the genre's lifespan otherwise the stories just wouldn't work.
 
is fucking nonsense. Holy shit, it feels like they fall in love over the course of an episode. To the point where they betray literally everyone else that's been close to them in the series up to that point.
Their romance ruined the series for me. It was just so outlandish that I couldn't take it seriously. I mean fucking really? You just betray all your comrades at the drop of a hat for the dick/pussy that quick? Holy shit.
 

Firemind

Member
Their romance is nonsense because their love quickly dissolves all the rationality these characters had before. You talk about how Aina loved her people, but she flat out abandons them at the end to be with Shiro. Shiro flat out ignores his comrade's safety because he wants to be with Aina that much. Their love is so strong that they forget they're in the middle of a war!

It's directly weakens theme the series was setting up. War up to that point killed people regardless of how good or evil they were, whether or not they were loved. The only difference was that Shiro and Aina's are the main characters, and therefore of course their love is special. So special that they abandon everything around them for their love.

And I think that's a shit romance right there. A romance that actively makes me dislike the two leads. A romance that takes away from the brutality of war the show had established up to that point.
I feel like you missed the point of several episodes where it's explained there is no good or bad side in war. They even refer to it specifically in the last arc; the base commander mentions that neither side plays fair. Shiro has been questioning the war ever since their second encounter, which is why he eventually deserted and followed his own ideals. You may find it irrational, but it is in no way out-of-character. They didn't abandon their ideals. Shiro fought to end the war and Aina fought to save her people; she piloted the Apsaras so that the base personnel could escape safely. I feel that you put too much weight around their relationship. Their love led them to this path, but they're not selfish characters. It could be argued that Shiro is the most level-headed, steadfast Gundam protagonist around.
 

Phatmac

Member
Solid episode of detective work with a grim case. Hoping that the show will have longer arcs as the mystery of the week format can get tiring. I wish the high school mc was more interesting but he got better after stopping the addict with karate. Sakurako continues to be great with her need for sleep and bones. I wonder if we'll ever see her fiancée.
I like the fact that they kept her magical girl-like transformation when getting ready to study a crime scene but wish they changed her attire instead of reusing the same one from episode 1. Hope it keeps being good with more insight into her backstory.
 

Lain

Member
K: Return of Kings 1

A direction-less mess that's already harder on the eyes than the first season.
The CG felt out of place and clashing.
Add to all this that I don't remember what happened at the end of the first season and the beginning here feeling all over the place and I'm not sure on what drugs they were when making this.
 
K: Return of Kings 1

A direction-less mess that's already harder on the eyes than the first season.
The CG felt out of place and clashing.
Add to all this that I don't remember what happened at the end of the first season and the beginning here feeling all over the place and I'm not sure on what drugs they were when making this.

Did you skip the movie?
 

javac

Member
Not into shounen and long running series of that nature but every time I see Yu Yu Hakusho on GAF the visuals impress me which maybe I'm being judgmental but when I think of shounen, I never think of good look series and I'm put off by them conceptually so I'm always left flabbergasted with YYH. Might need to pick up the BD's.
 

Phatmac

Member
I need to get off my ass and continue watching YYH. It's just so long though. It hasn't aged as poorly as I thought it would.
 

Risette

A Good Citizen
YYH is the best long-running shounen series. lots of talent worked on it, both on the animation and direction/storyboarding front
 
YYH is the best long-running shounen series. lots of talent worked on it, both on the animation and direction/storyboarding front

Even being a big fan of HxH and JoJo I must concede that YYH is the best out of all of them despite me having not seen it for years. Gintama might beat it in my personal book but when it comes to animation/direction YYH destroys.
 

wonzo

Banned
yyh = hxh99 > jojos >>>> gintama >>>>>>>>>> hxh2011

the inevitable akb49 adaptation will own them all
 

Cornbread78

Member
Nodame Cantabile Finale ep.4-6
The biggest take away from these episodes is the musical growth exploding for Nodame and Chiaki taking his mom's advice and not forgetting about his "angel" Nodame and being there for her and her studies. That is the biggest leap by far in Chiaki's growth of affection for Nodame in two seasons and led to a pretty comfy and romantic moment for the two.. Good stuff as they try to close out all the characters plotlines..
 

Sterok

Member
Yokai Watch Dub 6

How is this not getting censored? Like, they were practically watching PG porn. I'm impressed that all the Yokai so far have been distinct and entertaining.
 
Sakurako 2

Much better than the first episode. Not bad at all.

I do have a beef with how this show handles exposition. "Oh by the way I'm a blackbelt" is just too damn convenient. Similarly on episode one, the MC basically explained Sakurakos past in an info dump which could have been handled much better.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom