-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Banshee - The 4th and final season - Fridays on Cinemax
- Thread starter RatskyWatsky
- Start date
- Status
xrnzaaas
Member
Last episode (4x08) just aired.
Yeah i figured it was revealed there, but i could read shit (and didn't wanna pause).
They did it. They managed to eek out a worse finale than expected.
Wow. Talk about not delivering the goods with the two main showdowns. Pathetic. No action scene in this season is going to come close to rate in Banshee's top lists. Amazing how they royally screwed this.
I like how all this time the police actually had a piece of information that raises doubts if Rebeca was killed by the same serial killer but it was never shared with the viewers and it was never discussed between the agents and officers. Laughable. and it's not like this was needed to spot Lillith lying about Rebeca being Bode's kill.
Didn't get a fleshed out motivation by Burton.
That scene at the start of the season where Proctor is turning Rebeca's room upside down in search of something amounted to nothing but senseless red herring.
Hey, Brock, how about bringing cop alive and make the biggest drug bust ever and propel your career?
'Good bye, Ana' - ..Go on, Carrie. The perfect setup. Go on. 'Good bye, *Hood's real name*'. God DAMNIT.
Magic Mushroom
Member
Sepinwall nailed it. Bumpy season, satisfying send-off and as a whole this remains my favorite action series by quite a margin. Shame about the budget cuts that prevented season 4 to come even close to the brilliance that was season 3, which had television's GOAT action scenes.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Outcast is their summer show. With The Knick in limbo, Quarry is all they have left for the fall. (and unless they jump on board another international show as co-producers like they did with Strike Back and Hunted, they won't have anything for next winter/spring either.)
Yeah, they spent all season building up the neo nazis as a huge threat only to have the senator guy come in and clip their wings just when shit is about to get real. Really lame way for them to go out.
That wouldn't have made any sense.
styl3s
Member
Personally i thought the Nazi brother fight was pretty damn good but the bowtieterminator vs hood was the biggest letdown since
They did it. They managed to eek out a worse finale than expected.
Wow. Talk about not delivering the goods with the two main showdowns. Pathetic. No action scene in this season is going to come close to rate in Banshee's top lists. Amazing how they royally screwed this.
I like how all this time the police actually had a piece of information that raises doubts if Rebeca was killed by the same serial killer but it was never shared with the viewers and it was never discussed between the agents and officers. Laughable. and it's not like this was needed to spot Lillith lying about Rebeca being Bode's kill.
Didn't get a fleshed out motivation by Burton.
That scene at the start of the season where Proctor is turning Rebeca's room upside down in search of something amounted to nothing but senseless red herring.
Hey, Brock, how about bringing cop alive and make the biggest drug bust ever and propel your career?
'Good bye, Ana' - ..Go on, Carrie. The perfect setup. Go on. 'Good bye, *Hood's real name*'. God DAMNIT.
Locke/Jack
It was... okay. The not mentioning the lunar cycle thing was probably because they couldn't really trust anyone, even most of the other police. Especially not Hood since he was a suspect. But yeah, it does sort of come out of nowhere.
Brock's motivations for not taking Proctor/Cartel guy in was set up at the beginning of the season (series). He'd become disenfranchised with the judicial system, and probably thought even with all the evidence, Proctor and the Cartel guy would lawyer their way out.
Burton's disliked Rebecca for awhile, unless I'm misremembering last season. He knows Proctor has a weak spot for her and well there's the side businesses. He knows she'd fuck Proctor over and take his place if she could.
Brock's motivations for not taking Proctor/Cartel guy in was set up at the beginning of the season (series). He'd become disenfranchised with the judicial system, and probably thought even with all the evidence, Proctor and the Cartel guy would lawyer their way out.
Burton's disliked Rebecca for awhile, unless I'm misremembering last season. He knows Proctor has a weak spot for her and well there's the side businesses. He knows she'd fuck Proctor over and take his place if she could.
spindoctor
Member
The montage at the end was cliched but still nice. Everyone got their moment to say goodbye. That's pretty much the only good thing I can say about this episode.
The Hood vs Burton fight was pathetic. Way to let down the fans who have been anticipating it for four full years now :|. And you don't even properly explain why Burton killed Rebecca? "He doesn't see you but I see you" What the fuck is that?! How do you rush by that crucial bit of story that solves the entire mystery of your season? The satanist killer being a red herring is infuriating in retrospect. What a poor choice to write that story into the limited number of episodes they had to close the story.
If budget was such a big problem, they should have cut it down to maybe 6 episodes (to give each episode more of a budget) and then skipped the useless serial killer story, Dushku's wasted role, the cartel business and even the neo nazi stuff. Just make it about Hood and co. versus Procter in an all out war for Banshee. Kill off characters along the way to make the story meaningful... and save your budget.
I don't want to be disappointed but I can't help it. This used to be one of the most fun shows on TV and they couldn't stick the landing. Heck they ended up miles away from the runway
The Hood vs Burton fight was pathetic. Way to let down the fans who have been anticipating it for four full years now :|. And you don't even properly explain why Burton killed Rebecca? "He doesn't see you but I see you" What the fuck is that?! How do you rush by that crucial bit of story that solves the entire mystery of your season? The satanist killer being a red herring is infuriating in retrospect. What a poor choice to write that story into the limited number of episodes they had to close the story.
If budget was such a big problem, they should have cut it down to maybe 6 episodes (to give each episode more of a budget) and then skipped the useless serial killer story, Dushku's wasted role, the cartel business and even the neo nazi stuff. Just make it about Hood and co. versus Procter in an all out war for Banshee. Kill off characters along the way to make the story meaningful... and save your budget.
I don't want to be disappointed but I can't help it. This used to be one of the most fun shows on TV and they couldn't stick the landing. Heck they ended up miles away from the runway
bitbydeath
Member
It was a bit too 'happy' ending for my tastes but otherwise wasn't 'How I met your mother' bad.
Budget cuts looks to be a huge reason the season went the way it had.
What information was this?
Burton said to Proctor Rebecca was ruining the business and he was too close to her to see it.
He was looking for a clue as to who killed her, this is how I had always taken this scene.
Would never work, Proctor is too powerful and they have tried this a million times before.
spindoctor
Member
All the serial killer murders happened on a new moon. Rebecca's was not.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/entertainment/news/article.cfm?c_id=1501119&objectid=11613973
Guess that explains a few things about S4, perhaps more so than the cited lack of budget.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
That's a bummer, but I can understand why he would want to take things easy this year if the physicality of the role was taking a toll on his body. Still, they could have found a way to maintain the level of action that fans were used to (more focus on Carrie and Job, give Burton and Bunker expanded roles, etc).
KingHenrik30
Member
Good ending. Not the best finale I've ever seen but I have certainly seen plenty worse.
Just finished it, bittersweet since this was a monumentally flawed season. I'll still be rewatching this show and giving out high recommendations. The highs were just about as high as anything out there and they were truly singular. Season 3 will always be special. Adios Banshee.
D
Deleted member 325805
Unconfirmed Member
I'm really sad to see the show end even if this was the weakest season, the finale was good and really emotional and I'm glad they got to end the story properly unlike many good shows.
dead souls
Member
I was hoping Hood would become a lumberjack.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Was Hobo Hood not enough for you?
Plasticine
Member
Let's be honest. It wasn't going to be that much of a fight. It was Burton and Proctor. The neo-Nazis were clearly outmatched.
holygeesus
Banned
This is such a cop-out plot contrivance though - Proctor's business was flourishing. All Burton had to do was concentrate his efforts on the real problem i.e. Carrie. That would have made for a more interesting confrontation than what we got at least, which felt completely out of character.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Miles Quaritch
Member
I SEEEE YOOOOOOUUUUUUUU
I laughed at that, probably shouldn't have but the delivery with the facial expression was just hilarious.
I laughed at that, probably shouldn't have but the delivery with the facial expression was just hilarious.
Miles Quaritch
Member
Yup, felt like a twist for no other reason than having a shocking twist.
By the by, cool avatar. Source?
It's a drawing from Taiyo Matsumoto's Sunny:
He's the author of Tekkonkinkreet.
Other than clash of the Nazi brothers, the episode felt underwhelming.
I was hoping they'd mirror last season and have Hood 180 as he was heading out of town for a final showdown with Kai. But they'd basically fizzled out that entire conflict over this shitty season, so no surprises that went nowhere.
I was hoping they'd mirror last season and have Hood 180 as he was heading out of town for a final showdown with Kai. But they'd basically fizzled out that entire conflict over this shitty season, so no surprises that went nowhere.
JadedWriter
Member
I think he's just going to go to DC to be Dawson's house husband.
Miles Quaritch
Member
It's a drawing from Taiyo Matsumoto's Sunny:
He's the author of Tekkonkinkreet.
Awesome, thanks for that.
Baron Aloha
A Shining Example
I thought the finale was one of the better episodes of the season but not really great. I'm glad we got a happy ending because it seems like so many shows now end on a sad note.
I'm also glad they didn't reveal Hood's real name.
I wouldn't mind them bringing the show back in a few years, honestly. I know that rarely happens but it would be nice.
I'm also glad they didn't reveal Hood's real name.
I wouldn't mind them bringing the show back in a few years, honestly. I know that rarely happens but it would be nice.
BoboBrazil
Member
They did reveal Hood's real name. It was in the folder at the end and Carrie called him by his name when she was saying goodbye.
Pretty sure when he was arrested (and they showed flashbacks to this in season 3), they never determined his real name?
So chances are whatever was in that folder was just an alias, unless I've missed something?
BoboBrazil
Member
Carrie called him Gary when she said goodbye at the end and that was also the name in the folder.
Here's the clearest version I could find. If you zoom in, it definitely says John Smith (at a few different parts of the report).
Plus, I'm pretty sure Carrie said "Carrie" not "Gary" at the end, as a way of correcting Hood when he called her Ana.
Once again though, not 100% sure on any of this, so I'm sure someone else will let me know if I'm way off here.
BoboBrazil
Member
I think you are right. I just rewatched that part and Carrie does say "it's Carrie". Sounded like Gary when I watched it on tv.
How would that not make sense? They are saying their goodbyes. Hood bids Carrie 'goodbye Ana' so the thing that makes most sense is her saying something along the lines of 'Take care, *Joseph*' or whatever parting that included Hood's real name. You even have posters above me mishearing Carrie's correction and thinking she said his name.
That's a tougher interpretation than of looking for something. Even if i accept it we're sill left with a rushed 'final reveal' they made little effort to explain. It was a 'shocking twist' for the sake of having it more than anything else - and they still fluffed the fight that what the purpose of it all.
They have Proctor meeting a known Carter criminal with a truckload of drugs next to them. No, Proctor can't get away with it this time.
Because the person that's controlling said system is the mayor Proctor himself...Brock had the chance to rid Banshee this menace. No way out this time. I don't even want to get into the absurdity of Proctor being Mayor and continuing doing his stuff but no it goes unnoticed by reporters. Any fool with a camera can overlook Proctor's (the mayor's) house and see what's going on. Carrie could have taken pictures of the meet with the cartel and posted it and you can bet Proctor wouldn't have stayed in charge. Or like i said Brock could have raided the meet.
I don't want to get into it because i understood it's not something i should expect from Banshee. I didn't stick with it for it's great writing, tight plotting, deep characters or dialogs. I expected and wanted my dose of enjoyable action and fight scenes, which S4 didn't deliver.
It's this change of tone and focus in the final season that is disappointing and perplexing. For some reason they thought they can hang as a show that's more than those action scenes. That wasn't what brought them to the dance.
After it was revealed he was the killer it made me think of that he did kind of always showed signs of distrust / resentment toward Rebecca.
Anyway, it was a happy season finale and I'm fine with that. Good ending to the series. Even though season 4 was a bit disappointing I still liked the 8 episodes. Plus, Brock using a rocketlauncher was great!
~Devil Trigger~
In favor of setting Muslim women on fire
great end, really enjoyed this show
that classic rocket gif got me into it lol
that classic rocket gif got me into it lol
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Hood is always living in the past - always thinking about Rabbit and the heist; the Albino and his time in prison; Siobahn's death; I mean, he's barely even been present this season, so it made total sense for him to call Carrie 'Ana'.
But Carrie isn't Ana anymore. She's Carrie. Ana already said goodbye to the real Hood a long time ago.
Audioboxer
Member
Safe, but fairly good send off. Banshee shall be remembered for the sum of it's parts and boy was it fucking amazing.
Shame about the budget. I think it could have done a 5th season easily. 4 felt rushed and muddled, but it was still a good watch.
All the sads now it's gone. RIP Job (as in not seeing the character on my TV anymore).
Shame about the budget. I think it could have done a 5th season easily. 4 felt rushed and muddled, but it was still a good watch.
All the sads now it's gone. RIP Job (as in not seeing the character on my TV anymore).
mekes
Member
I didn't know it was going to be the last one. I thought there was going to be 10 episodes for some reason. When Bunker had his fight it dawned on me that everything was being wrapped up. I'll really miss the show, it was a fun ride. Rapidly running out of either fun or interesting shows to watch, another one has gone without anything new coming up to take its place.
Pretty much just GOT and Fargo for me now.
Pretty much just GOT and Fargo for me now.
Audioboxer
Member
I've yet to start Fargo, it's up next. Quite excited as heard good things.
Do it asap. It's such a good show.
- Status