Yep I was thinking the samething Mig :lol
Btw Jim rocks...
HOUSTON -- There will be a few misguided individuals who, needing someone to blame for Carlos Beltran's departure, will direct their recriminations at Houston general manager Tim Purpura.
To those who would pillory Purpura because Beltran held the Houston Astros hostage to the 11th hour Saturday night before doing what he obviously intended to do all along -- go for the green -- we say why stop there?
Why not blame Purpura for the price of gas or the weather? That would make about as much sense as blaming him for Beltran bolting.
The fact is the Astros gave Beltran $100 million reasons to return. All of the talk about wanting to play for a winner and liking Houston and playing in warm weather were clearly nothing more than calculated posturing designed to get more money. At least Randy Johnson, after the Astros traded for him during the playoff drove of '98, made it clear to the organization he would not re-sign with them when the season was over.
Agent Scott Boras could have informed the Astros weeks ago that they had no shot at bringing his client back. But that's not Boras' job. His job is to get his clients top dollar, and Beltran will now get that from some other club.
Complete coverage >
Purpura and the Astros had little choice but to take Boras and Beltran at their word, putting everything else on hold. The Astros didn't want to pursue other free agent outfielders and perhaps send the wrong message to Beltran as well as take up money that could be used to sweeten the offer to the budding superstar. Meanwhile, Boras used Houston as a foil to try and start a bidding war between the two New York teams.
"We went as far as we could to get it done, but in the end we ran out of time," Purpura said. "Despite all of our best efforts, we weren't able to get it done and it's certainly very disappointing."
The Astros first offered $70 million, then $75 million, then $84 million and finally $100 million over seven years with a chance to make it $112 million over eight years if the 2012 option was granted. The final offer was more money than Houston has ever offered any player, and that includes Jeff Bagwell, Craig Biggio, Johnson or Roger Clemens. And it wasn't enough.
That's as much money as Cardinals first baseman Albert Pujols received on his extension last year and more than Angels outfielder Vladimir Guerrero got last year, two players whose statistics clearly surpass Beltran's, and Pujols is three years younger. And it wasn't enough.
Perhaps, in the end it will work out well for the Astros. The baseball landscape is littered with long-term deals that have failed spectacularly (think Jason Giambi, Mo Vaughn, Denny Neagle, and Houston's own disappointment with a promising young outfielder coming off a breakout season a few years ago, a guy named Richard Hidalgo).
For all of his obvious gifts, Beltran is still only a career .284 hitter who has hit more than 30 home runs in a season just once. While Beltran may prove to be the kind of talent along the lines of Guerrero or Pujols, he hasn't done it on a grand scale yet, with the exception of his 12 postseason games this past season. And that followed a July 1 -- October 3 stretch during which Beltran hit .249.
But Houston was willing to gamble he was a budding superstar. You could say Purpura and the Astros didn't do what could reasonably be expected to bring back Beltran. They went above and beyond that.
Purpura and baseball operations president Tal Smith are known in the industry for being shrewd when it comes to putting a dollar sign on talent. They knew a fair price for Beltran, and owner Drayton McLane Jr. exceeded that price by a significant margin.
To his further credit, McLane has never made a more impassioned sales pitch in his life. The community also got in on the effort. Fans signed petitions and held Web site drives urging Beltran to return. There were dozens of fans milling around Minute Maid Park late Saturday night awaiting word on Beltran's decision.
Local civic and business leaders got involved in an effort. Teammates like Jeff Bagwell phoned Beltran. Roger Clemens agreed to arbitration, leaving the window open for his return while Beltran made up his mind.
"I can't say enough about the effort everyone put in to try and get this done," Purpura said. "It was a team effort on the part of a lot of people. There were too many issues. We just ran out of time."
It was a combined effort as everyone gave it their best shot. But in the end Beltran wouldn't take $100 million to play baseball in Houston. For him, it wasn't enough.
Blame greed if you like. Blame Boras or Beltran.
Just don't blame Purpura.
Jim Molony is a writer for MLB.com.