Any recommendations for protein bars? Want to use them as snacks. Too many choices for my little brain to comprehend. Still waiting on my powerblocks to arrive in the mail so I can finally get started!
I think the important piece when deciding what kind of protein bar to get is how you are going to use it: as a pre/post-workout snack or as a meal replacement. Some tips I've found may help those deciding between bars:
"If it's a snack, the bars should have less than 180 calories," advises Dawn Jackson Blatner, RD, the national media spokesperson for the American Dietetic Association in Chicago. "If it's a meal, the bar should be more than 200 calories and needs to be eaten with fruit and vegetables to satisfy you for four or more hours till you eat again."
In fact, substituting an energy bar-paired with an apple or veggie salad-for one meal each day can help you lose weight. "By adding fruits and vegetables, which are high in fiber and water, you'll feel more full," says Blatner. "This can help accelerate weight loss." If your goal is to drop a few pounds, Blatner says you need to read the nutrient label to make sure your meal-replacing bar contains:
-at least 200 calories
-3 grams or less saturated fat
-3 grams or more fiber (to help you feel full)
-at least 10 grams of protein (to help tide you over till your next meal)
My wife gave me an awesome Easter basket that just contained a variety of different protein bars so I've had a chance to try Clif Bars, Clif Builder's Protein Bars, Pure Protein Bars, and a variety of other commercially sold bars and I've found most to contain way too much sugar and saturated fat content for my liking (save for Pure Protein). I have not had Quest bars, but from what I've read about their nutritional content, it seems to be more in line with what an appropriate snack protein bar should be, although it being more cost prohibitive.
Because of these issues above and that I prefer to have something to snack on rather than have bars as a meal replacement, I've found a good method of making my own protein bars. There's a recipe for those interested (with nutritional information) I posted earlier in the thread which can be found
HERE.
In short from everything I tried and have read about I find the quality of (snack) protein bars to be:
- Best - Homemade
- Better - Quest Bars (pricey)
- Good - Pure Protein Bars (180 calories, 2g sugar, 20g protein, more affordable than Quest)
For those looking into meal replacements, I have had
PowerBar ProteinPlus Bars and
Clif Builder's Protein Bars and while they are tasty, at 300 and 280 calories and 19g and 20g of sugar, respectively, you may want to watch your constant consumption of these. I'd lean towards the PowerBar over the Clif Builder's due to the reduced fat and sugar content (albeit slight) and three types of protein it contains (soy, whey, and casein) as I've found it sustains me more so than the Clif Bar.
With all that said, I've found that using lower-calorie protein bars as a snack during the day or pre/post workout, followed with a protein shake after a workout to be my preferred method of feeling full as well as best supplying myself with a sufficient amount of protein while maintaining a low sugar/fat consumption.
Hope this helps those with questions and looking for good places to start with protein bars!