It is no longer is day 1 Magnum, where you at?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Bloodborne |Mafia OT| The Night Brims With Defiled Scum
- Thread starter ScraftyDevil
- Start date
It is no longer is day 1 Magnum, where you at?
II-Vanguard-II
Member
Sure
Town IMO
1: Me (obviously)
2: weemadarthur you wouldn't put me on the spotlight if you were scum so i'm leaning toward you being with the town
3: Mazre
Scum are probably :
1:Kristoffer (Still he's the most suspicious out of everyone)
2:Seath
3:haly (the guy we lynched tried to defend him that makes him instantly suspicious)
Vote: Kristoffer
Spoiled Milk
Banned
That's, like, the weirdest town and scum list ever.
You and Seath have been pretty iffy from the start. Even as I would've changed my vote from Day 1 (but got sidelined due to some unfortunate events on my end), you're still not off the hook in my eyes, and I feel that my findings from the previous day still holds value.
weemadarthur
Member
Ok, glad you showed up. If I understand correctly, you've never played Mafia before? We'd love to hear more of your thoughts. What in particular makes Kristoffer suspicious? Why is Seath scummy? Why is Mazre towny? You explained your assessment of Haly, so thank you on that one.
And I will post a small disagreement with your assessment of me. If I'm scum, and you're not on my team, then me getting you voted out is a win for me. Because a) I don't lose me or my partners, b) there's one less townfolk and I'm closer to winning. So I would absolutely put a spotlight on you for those reasons. Remember everyone wants to trick each other. Scum want to trick town into thinking they're on the same team. Townfolk want to trick scum into saying stupid things, or killing a basic vanilla member instead of a powerful role.
Next invisible person:
Vote: magnumboy20xx
weemadarthur
Member
I can't actually remember your findings. Your posts have been very short and infrequent, and I'm not sure how you think and react to things. Could you please do a top town/scum list with reasons?
II-Vanguard-II
Member
of course you'd think that you're #1 on my scum list
even if they're have a single team they could have someone taking the fall so it'll take pressure off the others plus seath and kris have been acting very strange
Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre Mazre
Where has he been hiding? I appreciate the total 2 posts he's put in this day phase talking about how busy he was last day phase and a couple 'yeah i agree with that' comments. Scum doesn't want to vote him. Nobody wants to talk about him. we need to murder him
Where has he been hiding? I appreciate the total 2 posts he's put in this day phase talking about how busy he was last day phase and a couple 'yeah i agree with that' comments. Scum doesn't want to vote him. Nobody wants to talk about him. we need to murder him
Squidy, you've been kinda vague all day. Just curious who your top scum currently are.
TBF, I agree with him, the scum list is ok if maybe a bit safe with a lot of "he just behaved weird" with few actual examples, but the town list is....not convincing. First of all, never put yourself in your top 3 town list, those lists are to show everyone what you currently are thinking, and you thinking you yourself are town is such a given that literally tells us nothing. Your reasoning of weemad being town doesn't make a lot of sense imo (Why wouldn't a scum weemad put you in the spotlight to appear active and hunting for scum?) and you don't even give a reason why you think mazre is town, which is especially problematic if you consider mazre is actually a lynch candidate right now, so if you really feel he is town, you will have to tell us why you think that and it would be a mistake to lynch him.
II-Vanguard-II
Member
at this point i suspect everyone that's why my town list i kinda weird cause i don't have any one to put in it and now that i look at it mazre is actually kinda sketch. my vote is still on kris though and i don't have concrete proof either, if i did i would show it to everyone so for now i have to go with suspicion .
I've been vague? I've been VAGUE? quote me where I've bene vague, this is not an effective defense Mazre.
Here is a little tip for future games: if your really suspect everyone, it is better to be straight forward about that and just say it, instead of putting people in a top town list you don't actually feel strongly town about just to have a couple in there. That's not very useful and could even actively hurt us since we will assume you feel strongly town about those players.
Spoiled Milk
Banned
Amazreing grace
Vote: Mazre
Vote: Mazre
weemadarthur
Member
I want to talk about him, but you're kinda handling it. I also want to talk about magnumboy, Palmer and zipped, so I'm focusing on them while you attack mazre. And the noobs. And probably Kristoffer. But mazre remains on my list.
In his favor, he had like two posts with a helpful point. This is +2 town behavior compared to some other players at 0/0. So he probably doesn't TOP my list unless everyone else steps up while he stays quiet.
Is no one concerned with how there's no reason attached? Cmon Kristoffer, at least try and hide bandwagoning.
Spoiled Milk
Banned
Listen, you troll, if I wanted to be constantly harangued by a cross eyed gremlin about what I'm doing and why I'm doing it, I'd call my ex-girlfriend. Last time I gave reasons for doing anything I almost found a noose around my neck, despite metric shit-tons of other players having ephemeral or totally non-existent game presence and bandwagoning aplenty, so this time around I'll just vote however I want and let the trusted sleuths do the sleuthing while we still operate on virtually nothing except lint and receipts. Your finger pointing histrionics are simply trite at this juncture and while we all (mostly) are moving on from the misguided indictment of yours truly, you still hang on desperately to me like a horsefly on dogshit because I called you out at daybreak and was slow to move off. If you really want an autograph that badly, you should speak up now, but otherwise: kindly crawl out of my ass, you healing church neophyte.
Freakinchair
Member
Unless you think that scum intentionally bandwagoned on their own scum player (Ri'Orius) to save their other scum player (Kristoffer) that vote makes no sense. A lot of people are throwing shade on Kristoffer but to me its completely unwarranted with the way things went day 1. Sure he's acting very strange and might not be thinking things through very well but all the evidence points to him either being town or neutral. I'm not going to throw out the idea that there are multiple factions at work (with Kristoffer being on a faction other than town) since it is still technically possible but I also won't assume it at this point for my voting.
I have Kristoffer and Seath as two of my most trusted posters (I never thought I would ever say that about Seath but here we are...) and I have Mazre and Weemad as suspicious. It's crazy how our lists are basically polar opposites. I would also like to mention that Ri'Orius voted for you initially in day 1 which means you're either town for sure or he was preemptively voting for you in the case he dies (thus making you look like a townie). You, however, never replied to his prod which makes me think that you're just a confused townie at this point - a scum would have answered his prod since it would have been discussed beforehand.
I'm back btw
ScraftyDevil
Banned
Keep it civil, gentlemen. Such beastly behaviour is unbecoming.
Spoiled Milk
Banned
I should have re-read the rules. Sorry! I'm used to other forums where meanness is encouraged.
Are you even paying attention to the game? like at all?
Spoiled Milk
Banned
Is this implying that I don't have reasons for what I do or that there have already been plenty of reasons for voting for Mazre? I actually posted my reasons for suspecting Mazre either today or yesterday and was delaying a vote because I believed him to he inactive, not scum. But he always shows up... consistently during suspicion.
Fair enough, I went back and saw prior justifications. I'd still like to see reasons on the page someone's voted on, can't say that's unwarranted.
Also, just ribbing you Kris, no hard feelings.
Spoiled Milk
Banned
Same, I'm just playing aggressively
for a new player, you've been playing a wonderful game.weemadarthur
Member
Magnumboy? You dead mon?
MagnumBoy20xx
Neo Member
I'm sorry for not posting at all in this day phase until now. Truthfully, I have been playing awful this game. I've been having a hard time keeping up with the thread, and thus have not gotten any reads whatsoever which has never happened to me before. It's gotten so bad for me to the point that I might ask for a replacement. I want to try and give this game a go for one more day phase, but if I continue to be unable to contribute, I'll bow out. It isn't fair to you guys or anyone else who wants to play this game if I generally do nothing but waste a player spot.
weemadarthur
Member
This is sudden. Is something in particular up right now?
Vote: zippedpinhead
You've been around, but hardly saying anything. You have made very safe reads on people who rather put themselves in the spotlight, but not given much on new topics, or said anything really original on existing topics. This is play that I call coasting.
ScraftyDevil
Banned
Why are you still reading this?
It's not too late.
Turn back now, before they catch you.
Can't you see you're in danger?
Have you no sense?
Evil draws near.
Sunset is upon us.
It's not too late.
Turn back now, before they catch you.
Can't you see you're in danger?
Have you no sense?
Evil draws near.
Sunset is upon us.
Spoiled Milk
Banned
mazre (3)
squidyj 602 (648)
squidyj 704
flame_ac 790
kristoffer 815
kristoffer (3)
haly 612 (749)
verelios 774
mazre 795
ii-vanguard-ii 802
never forever (2)
palmer_v1 613
haly 800
kalor (0)
zippedpinhead 619 (718)
squidyj (1)
camjo-z 627
seath (0)
seath 634 (649)
squidyj 648 (704)
verelios (0)
kristoffer 639 (730)
nudull (1)
seath 649 (753)
freakinchair 697
mickd (1)
kalor 679
weemadarthur (1)
roytheone 680
hobohodo (1)
zippedpinhead 718
kristoffer 730 (747)
freakinchair (0)
kristoffer 747 (761)
kristoffer 761 (798)
haly (1)
seath 753
ii-vanguard-ii (0)
weemadarthur 770 (806)
magnumboy20xx (1)
weemadarthur 806
squidyj 704
flame_ac 790
kristoffer 815
kristoffer (3)
verelios 774
mazre 795
ii-vanguard-ii 802
never forever (2)
palmer_v1 613
haly 800
kalor (0)
squidyj (1)
camjo-z 627
seath (0)
verelios (0)
nudull (1)
freakinchair 697
mickd (1)
kalor 679
weemadarthur (1)
roytheone 680
hobohodo (1)
zippedpinhead 718
freakinchair (0)
haly (1)
seath 753
ii-vanguard-ii (0)
magnumboy20xx (1)
weemadarthur 806
CrimsonFist
Member
Hi, been vaguely following the thread. Need to read back in a bit more detail before giving thoughts though.
Alright Mick, you've had a good 24 hours to do something of value, and you haven't. Since you decided to leave your vote on me again, I guess I'll be the one to call you out.
VOTE: MickD
Other people have been poked and prodded about their activity, but you've got 13 posts and you've said absolutely NOTHING. Seriously, for those playing along at home, this is the list of Mick's contributions to the game so far:
1. OMGUS votes me after I make a joke vote on him
2. Attempts to bandwagon after saying he wouldn't, says it was a newbie mistake
3. Tries to do some roleplaying about being a character from Bloodborne
4. Mentions that Kalor's vote on him feels scummy
5. Votes me again anyway
Do you plan on contributing anything or are you just going to be one of those blendy players who mysteriously sticks around until endgame and ends up either being "hidden in plain sight" scum or an inactive townie intentionally left alive as a red herring? It's fine to be new but you have to actually play at some point.
Anyway, that vote up there was just to get Mick's attention. As for my current thoughts on someone worth talking about: something is up with you, Kristoffer. It's like you don't really care who ultimately gets lynched as long as there's a lynch - half the time you don't even give reasoning for your votes until somebody asks for some. It was understandable when you were potentially on the chopping block and needed an out, but now it's D2 and you're still swinging your vote around trying to haggle for temporary alliances and hoping to get enough momentum to start something. Not sure if maf or neutral, but I'd be fine with your lynch either way (which is a bit bittersweet because that rant at Verelios was hilarious).
VOTE: Kristoffer
VOTE: MickD
Other people have been poked and prodded about their activity, but you've got 13 posts and you've said absolutely NOTHING. Seriously, for those playing along at home, this is the list of Mick's contributions to the game so far:
1. OMGUS votes me after I make a joke vote on him
2. Attempts to bandwagon after saying he wouldn't, says it was a newbie mistake
3. Tries to do some roleplaying about being a character from Bloodborne
4. Mentions that Kalor's vote on him feels scummy
5. Votes me again anyway
Do you plan on contributing anything or are you just going to be one of those blendy players who mysteriously sticks around until endgame and ends up either being "hidden in plain sight" scum or an inactive townie intentionally left alive as a red herring? It's fine to be new but you have to actually play at some point.
Anyway, that vote up there was just to get Mick's attention. As for my current thoughts on someone worth talking about: something is up with you, Kristoffer. It's like you don't really care who ultimately gets lynched as long as there's a lynch - half the time you don't even give reasoning for your votes until somebody asks for some. It was understandable when you were potentially on the chopping block and needed an out, but now it's D2 and you're still swinging your vote around trying to haggle for temporary alliances and hoping to get enough momentum to start something. Not sure if maf or neutral, but I'd be fine with your lynch either way (which is a bit bittersweet because that rant at Verelios was hilarious).
VOTE: Kristoffer
Spoiled Milk
Banned
Wonder if this is what adds insight. Probably met the witch.
Spoiled Milk
Banned
Wrong on all counts, busta rhymes. I didn't vote for Ri just to save my own ass; I voted for him because it was the right thing to do. Previously, on GAFia:
Check out these receipts, brah. I had an opportunity to save myself (voting for Haly would have tied us) but I refused to take it because I had a good feeling Haly was town and I still think he might be a power rule. I almost sacrificed myself for the sins of town. I'm like Bloodborne Jesus!
Now here's a long reminder about why you suck:
can't win if ya don't play
Sit on your hands, Camjo! That won't stop the mafia from cutting those fingers off. It's a good thing I read you as stupendously towny town, no beasts here. Yeah, that's right. I like you. But you're still wrong.
You think I don't give reasons for who I lynch? Wrong! Out of the four people I voted for this day phase, I gave reasoning for three of them previously. I stated that I didn't like the way Verelios slinked in the shadows all throughout Day 1 and was entirely uncommittal about anything he did, hiding behind a facade of fresh meat confusion. Boohoo, he's scum. I explained very forcefully that I didn't feel comfortable with a vigilante running amok deciding in solitude who to give silver bullet justice to in the dead of the night. And I stated previously that Mazre was suspicious, but that he was probably just inactive. When squidyj made the case for Mazre again and he was still missing, I switched my opinion accordingly. The one I didn't give reasoning for was Hobohodo, and yet... my reasoning from Day 1 still applies. After all, this is a game of instinct, isn't it?
I am the one who drives this game forward. I am the steam engine, and while you may not like the conductor, by the old gods, we are going to go somewhere, whether you like it or not. So buckle up and look sharp, because we're going to Lynchtown.
CrimsonFist
Member
Haven't finished reading everything yet, but for now:
Three people killing? huh. I know there's been a bit of multi faction speculation, but it still seem weird to assume that there were three killing roles going around last night, especially when there's a) been no real evidence of multiple factions as far as I can tell, and b)
And yes, I know you tried to backtrack on this a few posts later. Still something that strikes me as interesting.
Anyway, late now. Will finish reading over things tomorrow.
Three people killing? huh. I know there's been a bit of multi faction speculation, but it still seem weird to assume that there were three killing roles going around last night, especially when there's a) been no real evidence of multiple factions as far as I can tell, and b)
And yes, I know you tried to backtrack on this a few posts later. Still something that strikes me as interesting.
Anyway, late now. Will finish reading over things tomorrow.
Freakinchair
Member
CrimsonFist swingin right out of the gate. Welcome duder!
My reasoning for voting Camjo is because of no lynch on D1 - It's been that way the entire time and I've said it before. Your play is aggressive (net casting IMO) and that's cool and all but I don't buy you being town, how do I know you're not? I believe I'm playing homie.. Taking time to process and re-read everything over and over, but there are some (nearly most) of you I just can't read whatsoever and I'm sorry you don't see it that way. Is everyone guilty till innocent? Because I'm thinking the opposite. It wasnt OMGUS, it was your no lynch and odd aggressiveness.
Happy to defend myself in the spotlight, bring it. Definitely keeping my vote as is, since I really hate the bandwagon approach.. But if I change my vote, Im going to get all types of flack from all. I guess it wont matter since its looking like Mazre gone die.
Kristoffer - You didnt add my vote in #831 from #780
I think Squid, Chair are town.
I believe Camjo, Nudull, magnumboy20xx (due to no post) is scum
Leaning scum - Haly
Cant read - Kalor, Krist, Palmer
Seath is hilarious.
Happy to defend myself in the spotlight, bring it. Definitely keeping my vote as is, since I really hate the bandwagon approach.. But if I change my vote, Im going to get all types of flack from all. I guess it wont matter since its looking like Mazre gone die.
Kristoffer - You didnt add my vote in #831 from #780
I think Squid, Chair are town.
I believe Camjo, Nudull, magnumboy20xx (due to no post) is scum
Leaning scum - Haly
Cant read - Kalor, Krist, Palmer
Seath is hilarious.
I answered your accusation in my second post of the phase. Since then you've offered nothing new in the way of argument.
I know lies and ruses are part of Mafia but could you refrain from telling lies about me and limit them to yourself?
Squid seems to be town, as far as I'm concerned. weemadarthur, I'm leaning towards town, though I admit I've had some early doubts. Camjo? Ehhhhh.
As for scum? Kristoffer, Chair and Seath I've mentioned already. All three of them have displayed some level of suspicious behavior, and I'm not about to let go just yet. The fact that they're beginning to gang up on me only makes things more interesting. Vanguard's made a good point about Haly as well, who I've had an eye on. Getting defended by the first scum we've killed brings up a lot of implications, though it could just as easily have been a diversion.
New players being thrown into the mix now sort of muddies things, but I'll see what they do first. I recognize that it's crunch time on Day 2, so I'll need to think a bit on my vote.
As for scum? Kristoffer, Chair and Seath I've mentioned already. All three of them have displayed some level of suspicious behavior, and I'm not about to let go just yet. The fact that they're beginning to gang up on me only makes things more interesting. Vanguard's made a good point about Haly as well, who I've had an eye on. Getting defended by the first scum we've killed brings up a lot of implications, though it could just as easily have been a diversion.
New players being thrown into the mix now sort of muddies things, but I'll see what they do first. I recognize that it's crunch time on Day 2, so I'll need to think a bit on my vote.
CrimsonFist
Member
I think the one really bad post Mazre made is that reply to Squidy (810). Being generally inactive and then showing up the moment you're mentioned with a pretty weak comment. Aside from that, doesn't seem like there's too much that stands out. But then he hasn't been that active.