I kinda wanted to get all the NPCs, but then I realized when I killed Rom that they all started to becomes beasts, I suppose I can do everything I need before killing Rom?
Basically yes. There are two questlines that you have to be more involved and those are Eileen and Alfred. Others you either tell to go clinic or chapel and there is only one you want to send to clinic and one you need to tell to go to clinic since he will go the opposite place. From there their questlines progress as you go through the game.
For Eileen
- Meet first in the sewers
- Then near the chapel
- Go to Gascoigne boss room for NPC hunter fight where you need to help Eileen
- Go to VA boss room once you beat Rom.
- Then near the chapel
- Go to Gascoigne boss room for NPC hunter fight where you need to help Eileen
- Go to VA boss room once you beat Rom.
For Alfred
- Meet in the church that leads to Old Yharnam
- Then meet him near the Forbidden Woods entrance
- End of his questline requires you to go Cainhurst and I don't want to spoil it too much for you yet
- Then meet him near the Forbidden Woods entrance
- End of his questline requires you to go Cainhurst and I don't want to spoil it too much for you yet