he always seems to give Attack up way more credit than its worth for some reason.
also overall units never mean that much.
Is it just me or is kuda kinda of meh for most people if they have sgx? I mean he truly shines only if your whole party has the amasoejhiwfoaweo sphere.
Otherwise SGX is still better imo unless I'm missing something.
Straight up, Kuda will always do more damage than SGX in a 1-1 comparison. Sphere frogs and geldnite axes exist (in addition to hidden +crit bonuses), so bridging the gap to max crit rate is easy compared to pre-sphere frog/amanohabaken era.
Then there is the consideration for buff stacks and how many people within the party get to benefit from it, which has a multiplying effect essentially.
Kuda->Elza->Dilma->Other DD (Kajah/Azazel/Loch/Golem/Hogar/Rowgen/Logan/Lorand)etc.)->Maxwell->Maxwell
Is always going to outdamage
SGX->Elza->Michele/Kuhla->Dilma->Maxwell->Maxwell
Mainly because the units involved are getting their buffs sooner, therefore applying it to more people in the chain in addition to including better units with better stats and higher base multipliers attached to their BB/SBB.
To have a more "fair" comparison to Kuda, you would have to bring Garnan or Bordebegia to the party to get the same style of party compression effect.
IE
Bordebegia/Garnan->Michele/Kuhla/Hogar/Lerone->Dilma->Other DD->Maxwell->Maxwell
Then there are also the considerations for elemental affinity/resistance (dark has none), BC generation if going more than one round, and so on. FH points generation ends up being a different kind of discussion though where having the element shift ends up being worth more depending on the unit spread and variation of elements involved.
For questing and boss fight, I think he's a space saver, which (finally) allows you to not bring Michele. I do think, however, think that SGX's dark buff is just so useful in allowing you to cover up for any potential bad elements.
The bad elements thing doesn't really exist anymore when 5/6 positions of your party (arguably automatically, if we are assuming highest damage possible scenarios) can be dark/light negating that issue entirely.
I mean, when you party could consist of Kuda, Elza, 2 maxwells, Kajah, and Dilma (who would be the only one of any concern in terms of elemental resistance), I really don't think it matters anymore.