Just finished Act 1. I liked it a lot! I have very little experience with the classic adventure games everybody loves (I played the first third or so of the first Monkey Island on XBLA and that's about it) so I can't really compare it to those but it was definitely a fun experience, if a little easy.
I stupidly got stuck onthe puzzle to activate the laser in the pyramid. I thought I had tried everything I could do but apparently I hadn't actually put both pieces in the wrong slots at the same time. I was wandering all over the place thinking I needed to heat something up with the coil.
Also does the game not let youI might be misremembering this part though, I did it a day or two ago.put the chum in the tear gas dispenser until after you activate the laser? I swear I tried to do that when I first got to Shellmound and I was trying to get the perfume, but I think Vella just said "I don't think I can put that in there" or something. I guess it makes sense since if you did it too soon you'd be able to start the feast without having the laser, but it was weird how that just arbitrarily became allowed.
I was able to put the chum in the sprayer before starting the laser, she just told the guy to wait so she can find a weapon.