I've been thinking a lot about the events and results of day one, and come to the conclusion that Sorian is the most suspicious character on the island.
Sorian started the voting to lynch Tucah, an ordinary tourist. He had various reasons, most of which are not particularly convincing, so I suspect that Sorian was a wilful architect of the lynching and knew that Tucah was a tourist, or at least, not a fellow cultist.
I tried to argue against voting for Tucah citing a lack of logic behind this vote, sadly without success. Meanwhile, Sorian
convinced eight other people, most of which I imagine were unwitting tourists, to vote for Tucah. How did he do this? By presenting himself as an authority figure by dominating conversations and aggressively questioning everyone else. This behavior serves the dual purposes of directing attention away from him and getting people to trust him by virtue of being the loudest voice in the room. Sorian is an
absurdly prolific poster in this thread compared to every else, and I suggest that that alone should raise red flags.
VOTE: Sorian